The disgusting truth about Hillsborough
#11
Thatchers government were vile, nothing ridiculous about that. They treated the working class like rats. It was a regime totally lacking compassion or basic human decency.
I agree all clubs had scum fans, and still do, but hooligans, past reputation etc is utter bullshit in the story of Hillsborough.
Tragedies bring great change and 30 years on I believe grounds are far better places, but that’s no comfort to the families of the dead, who have had their lives ruined.
Reply
#12
When after anyone who could possibly be prosecuted and convicted for manslaughter has died then the state will admit limited liability for the deaths they are culpable for. Another 20 years or so and the truth will out. But no one will take responsibility til then.
The state looks after its own.
Reply
#13
True sunshine it’s the state says sorry but it means nothing as those behind it are in their graves. It’s like the Irish government apologising for the slavery of the Magdalene homes and the church destruction of families.
Trying to unravel a web of cover ups and corruption is near impossible.
With Hillsborough there will never be justice.
Reply
#14
(11-30-2019, 12:48 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Thatchers government were vile, nothing ridiculous about that. They treated the working class like rats. It was a regime totally lacking compassion or basic human decency.
I agree all clubs had scum fans, and still do, but hooligans, past reputation etc is utter bullshit in the story of Hillsborough.
Tragedies bring great change and 30 years on I believe grounds are far better places, but that’s no comfort to the families of the dead, who have had their lives ruined.

There was already legislation in place to control safety.

The Safety of Sports Grounds Act 1975, introduced under Harold Wilson,  brought about the introduction of the safety certificate.  Local Authorities are responsible for both issuing and enforcing a safety certificate in respect of sports grounds designated by the Secretary of State.   So the relevant local authority issued safety certificates for Hillsborough for 14 years prior to the disaster.

Given previous incidents at Leppings lane, the Local Authority are particularly culpable together with the Police and also the fans who turned up in numbers without tickets with the intent of getting in for nowt.
Reply
#15
(11-30-2019, 12:48 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Thatchers government were vile, nothing ridiculous about that. They treated the working class like rats. It was a regime totally lacking compassion or basic human decency.
I agree all clubs had scum fans, and still do, but hooligans, past reputation etc is utter bullshit in the story of Hillsborough.
Tragedies bring great change and 30 years on I believe grounds are far better places, but that’s no comfort to the families of the dead, who have had their lives ruined.

I wasn't implying that Thatcher's Government wasn't vile, I was saying it was ridiculous to say that Hillsborough was directly attributable to them. Was every news worthy tragedy that happened during that period entirely attributable to them?

The cover-up is the most damning aspect of the Police and Government actions IMO.
Reply
#16
(11-30-2019, 01:52 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(11-30-2019, 12:48 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Thatchers government were vile, nothing ridiculous about that. They treated the working class like rats. It was a regime totally lacking compassion or basic human decency.
I agree all clubs had scum fans, and still do, but hooligans, past reputation etc is utter bullshit in the story of Hillsborough.
Tragedies bring great change and 30 years on I believe grounds are far better places, but that’s no comfort to the families of the dead, who have had their lives ruined.

There was already legislation in place to control safety.

The Safety of Sports Grounds Act 1975, introduced under Harold Wilson,  brought about the introduction of the safety certificate.  Local Authorities are responsible for both issuing and enforcing a safety certificate in respect of sports grounds designated by the Secretary of State.   So the relevant local authority issued safety certificates for Hillsborough for 14 years prior to the disaster.

Given previous incidents at Leppings lane, the Local Authority are particularly culpable together with the Police and also the fans who turned up in numbers without tickets with the intent of getting in for nowt.

A myth which was dispelled as far back as 1990, by the Lord Justice Taylor report when he stated categorically that "fans' behaviour played no part in the disaster". And this myth was laid to rest 26 years later at the inquests, which the authorities tried so hard to prevent taking place, when the jury stated The behaviour of Liverpool supporters did not cause or contribute to the dangerous situation at the Leppings Lane turnstiles. And yet the myth persists.
Reply
#17
All the above. Some excellent posts here
And state collusion?
Seeing the videos again reminds me of the iniquitous fencing. Caging us like animals led to a lot of those deaths.
Look at those poor buggers trying to get on to the pitch in order to live.
Wasn't this the same government which wanted us to be id's for being... football fans!
Reply
#18
(11-30-2019, 11:59 AM)cornishbaggie Wrote:
(11-30-2019, 09:10 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: I think most of a certain age know the story of what happened.  

The newspaper reporting and how the police lied etc (especially after the crush post 3.15) is shocking and needed exposing.  

It has to be taken in the context of the times - the police under the thatcher government had been used as a tool for imposing many things and probably felt untouchable.  Lying and cover-ups were part of the culture.

The thing I think that gets people’s backs up is the idea that the fans played no part in what happened, whether on this specific day or their past reputation.

Liverpool fans were known for being one of the worst sets of hooligans in the country, their rioting had led to the deaths of 39 at Heysel and were also known for jibbing into grounds.  They did it in Athens in 2005 ffs.

I’m sure many were late due to the traffic, but many also left it until the last minute and they weren’t exactly politely queuing and waiting their turn outside the ground.  With their penchant for violence and pushing through you can understand why the decision was made to open the gate.  The fact they weren’t properly directed thereafter is a safety issue that the stewards/police ARE answerable for and what ultimately led to the crush.

In those days kick offs weren’t delayed for congestion etc, you just missed the start, it was this tragedy that has led to delayed kick offs.

I think if the Liverpool fans acknowledged that their past behaviour (and late arrival, not all were in traffic) played a part in influencing the decision making they’d get a lot more sympathy instead of painting them all as innocent angels.  The innocent were already in the ground.

Someone on the other thread mentioned the reaction at the hawthorn’s that day.  From memory the HT tannoy was that the match was delayed due to crowd disturbances so no HT score.  Typical scousers was the general feeling.

Again a reply ignoring the facts, Liverpool had 7 turnstiles to admit 10,100 fans into Leppings lane, who can say anyone arrived late, in fact Liverpool had 23 turnstiles for access that day, Forest had 60. Every fact that we now know about that day, proves one thing above all, it was a disaster waiting to happen and happen it would to any well supported team.
The line of " past behavior and reputation " is oft trotted out on this subject, so it seems the whole world and it's mother were aware of this, except those in charge that day.

We know there were a number of issues with the ground and we know there was a late of arrival of fans.  The late arrival is fact, what caused this is open to debate - I would argue there was the usual late arrivals on top of the lateness caused by traffic issues.  This would have exacerbated the issue - were the police aware of the travel disruptions?

I'm also aware fans of previous clubs had had issues at the ground and there was the potential of a crush if the fans weren't filtered through properly and this was a big issue. 

The lies about Liverpool fans kicking the gate down etc. and the newspaper reports based on police lies needed exposing as did the suitability of the ground in general.  It was era of cover-ups and the police (with the support of the state i.e. Thatcher's Government) acted as if they were the law rather than merely implementing the law. I'm not sure we're quite there with the highlighted bit just yet.

I do though think it's wrong to say that the past behaviour of football fans, and Liverpool in particular, didn't have an affect on the decisions made at the time (remember this was only 3 years after Heysel when walls collapsed from crowd surges and pushing and 39 died).  The opening of the gate wouldn't allow more fans in than had tickets (unless we're accepting that fans were trying to jib in) but did result in letting in too many in too quickly.  Once in they should have been funnelled to the sides.  

Decisions were, now clearly incorrectly, made based on this and they decided it was better to let them in than have the chaos that was happening with crowds outside trying to get in for the kick off.  It's said that "On match day, radio and television advised fans without tickets not to attend. Rather than establishing crowd safety as the priority, clubs, local authorities and the police viewed their roles and responsibilities through the 'lens of hooliganism'". 

The 96 innocent died because of the police actions.  My point was that certain police actions on the day would have been mindful of the history of Liverpool fans past behaviour and therefore influence decisions.  

Would they have opened the gate for other fans?  I guess we'll never know.

Yes the police need to take responsibility, as do the FA and the board of Sheffield Wednesday who never did reduce capacity as advised (by the police). 

I suspect that most people who were the hawthorn's that day when the HT announcement was made that there had been crowd disturbances jumped to a conclusion of Liverpool fans causing trouble again.  I did and so did everyone around me.
Reply
#19
Excellent OP.
I lived in Liverpool for 8 years and never saw anyone light a candle or dip into a bin, btw. If anyone can prove otherwise, feel free.
Reply
#20
(11-30-2019, 03:07 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(11-30-2019, 11:59 AM)cornishbaggie Wrote:
(11-30-2019, 09:10 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: I think most of a certain age know the story of what happened.  

The newspaper reporting and how the police lied etc (especially after the crush post 3.15) is shocking and needed exposing.  

It has to be taken in the context of the times - the police under the thatcher government had been used as a tool for imposing many things and probably felt untouchable.  Lying and cover-ups were part of the culture.

The thing I think that gets people’s backs up is the idea that the fans played no part in what happened, whether on this specific day or their past reputation.

Liverpool fans were known for being one of the worst sets of hooligans in the country, their rioting had led to the deaths of 39 at Heysel and were also known for jibbing into grounds.  They did it in Athens in 2005 ffs.

I’m sure many were late due to the traffic, but many also left it until the last minute and they weren’t exactly politely queuing and waiting their turn outside the ground.  With their penchant for violence and pushing through you can understand why the decision was made to open the gate.  The fact they weren’t properly directed thereafter is a safety issue that the stewards/police ARE answerable for and what ultimately led to the crush.

In those days kick offs weren’t delayed for congestion etc, you just missed the start, it was this tragedy that has led to delayed kick offs.

I think if the Liverpool fans acknowledged that their past behaviour (and late arrival, not all were in traffic) played a part in influencing the decision making they’d get a lot more sympathy instead of painting them all as innocent angels.  The innocent were already in the ground.

Someone on the other thread mentioned the reaction at the hawthorn’s that day.  From memory the HT tannoy was that the match was delayed due to crowd disturbances so no HT score.  Typical scousers was the general feeling.

Again a reply ignoring the facts, Liverpool had 7 turnstiles to admit 10,100 fans into Leppings lane, who can say anyone arrived late, in fact Liverpool had 23 turnstiles for access that day, Forest had 60. Every fact that we now know about that day, proves one thing above all, it was a disaster waiting to happen and happen it would to any well supported team.
The line of " past behavior and reputation " is oft trotted out on this subject, so it seems the whole world and it's mother were aware of this, except those in charge that day.

We know there were a number of issues with the ground and we know there was a late of arrival of fans.  The late arrival is fact, what caused this is open to debate - I would argue there was the usual late arrivals on top of the lateness caused by traffic issues.  This would have exacerbated the issue - were the police aware of the travel disruptions?

I'm also aware fans of previous clubs had had issues at the ground and there was the potential of a crush if the fans weren't filtered through properly and this was a big issue. 

The lies about Liverpool fans kicking the gate down etc. and the newspaper reports based on police lies needed exposing as did the suitability of the ground in general.  It was era of cover-ups and the police (with the support of the state i.e. Thatcher's Government) acted as if they were the law rather than merely implementing the law. I'm not sure we're quite there with the highlighted bit just yet.

I do though think it's wrong to say that the past behaviour of football fans, and Liverpool in particular, didn't have an affect on the decisions made at the time (remember this was only 3 years after Heysel when walls collapsed from crowd surges and pushing and 39 died).  The opening of the gate wouldn't allow more fans in than had tickets (unless we're accepting that fans were trying to jib in) but did result in letting in too many in too quickly.  Once in they should have been funnelled to the sides.  

Decisions were, now clearly incorrectly, made based on this and they decided it was better to let them in than have the chaos that was happening with crowds outside trying to get in for the kick off.  It's said that "On match day, radio and television advised fans without tickets not to attend. Rather than establishing crowd safety as the priority, clubs, local authorities and the police viewed their roles and responsibilities through the 'lens of hooliganism'". 

The 96 innocent died because of the police actions.  My point was that certain police actions on the day would have been mindful of the history of Liverpool fans past behaviour and therefore influence decisions.  

Would they have opened the gate for other fans?  I guess we'll never know.

Yes the police need to take responsibility, as do the FA and the board of Sheffield Wednesday who never did reduce capacity as advised (by the police). 

I suspect that most people who were the hawthorn's that day when the HT announcement was made that there had been crowd disturbances jumped to a conclusion of Liverpool fans causing trouble again.  I did and so did everyone around me.

Have you heard the panicked radio comms. requesting control room to open the gate?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)