St Greta
#11
(09-24-2019, 10:05 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-24-2019, 10:00 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(09-24-2019, 09:49 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(09-24-2019, 09:18 AM)billybassett Wrote: https://spectator.us/the-apotheosis-of-st-greta/

Phew  - not just me then thinking this

Vociferous critics include...

Trump
Banks
Hopkins
Julia Hartley-Brewer
Farage

[Image: 8ubGFLt.gif]

Agreed and many more on that list too. I'm not an advocate of the article but and advocate of actually thinking about solving the problem and putting policies in place. Whilst it may all be white rightist propaganda the real solutions to the problem go undiscussed whilst a laudable but somewhat ideas challenged Greta sails the ocean on a wave of twitter and instagram. And maybe it will provide column inches and motivate some but the real solutions lie in a much wider collaboration that needs discussion.

We won't be talking about some of the stuff Labour put put today about trying to deal with the future (or whether it will or not) but some legal bollox and Boris Johnson, Greta's holiday tour and backward looking Brexit. Jeez

Fair enough and thank you for not taking umbrage with me Billy I don't think Greta is doing anything but good for the cause but that's where we will have to agree to differ.

Your probably right and I'm not sure we're disagreeing. I'm not sure after a year of her cause shouting at the UN is the best option. If someone could harness the conversation now great but I'm not seeing that from her cause right now and that is a shame. She needs some good advice..
Reply
#12
She doesn't need to do anything other than what she's doing. It is not upon her to legislate it is upon the governments of the world. She is making a loud noise and rallying people to the cause which in turn puts pressure on governments the same way protesting about any other topic would. They now know that climate change is an important subject to large swathes of the electorate.

Yes, China and India are by far the producers of the most carbon but "they're worse than us so we shouldn't bother" is not an argument that sways me.

Also, with respect, I don't think you can say "phew - not just me thinking this" and link an article then backtrack to say you're not advocating the opinion contained therein.
Reply
#13
(09-24-2019, 10:16 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: She doesn't need to do anything other than what she's doing. It is not upon her to legislate it is upon the governments of the world. She is making a loud noise and rallying people to the cause which in turn puts pressure on governments the same way protesting about any other topic would. They now know that climate change is an important subject to large swathes of the electorate.

Yes, China and India are by far the producers of the most carbon but "they're worse than us so we shouldn't bother" is not an argument that sways me.

Also, with respect, I don't think you can say "phew - not just me thinking this" and link an article then backtrack to say you're not advocating the opinion contained therein.

With respect I can so get off your high horse. Perhaps the 3 sec one liner wasn't an indepth review of my thoughts it was just to stimulate debate. Your third sentence attributes an argument to me that I've not made. I'm not backtracking as you actually don't know what my beliefs are. Perhaps you just read stuff on your FB wall that reinforces your own world view - I don't know and would not presume to pigeon hole you. That's probably where we are different. 

I tend to look further afield to read different views and consider them more widely. I laud what she's doing and yes the more voices the better. Maybe we can label some of the wider points as whitist and rightist but if you can't put that aside and consider some of the other points (right or wrong) then what's the point of this debate? Sounds like you're already locked in to a particular view? I don't know. If you are then you're like millions of others who use the internet and social media to actually close down debate and ideas and thought.
Reply
#14
The US edition of The Spectator has been broadly pro-Trump and climate sceptic since its launch. All but a handful of contributors seem to toe the editorial line; perhaps they have no choice.

Not that the UK version is a whole lot different.
Reply
#15
(09-24-2019, 10:35 AM)Ossian Wrote: The US edition of The Spectator has been broadly pro-Trump and climate sceptic since its launch. All but a handful of contributors seem to toe the editorial line; perhaps they have no choice.

Not that the UK version is a whole lot different.

Yes and plenty of industry lobbyists in the US peddle heavily behind the scenes. Easy to see through that mind as people like Freddy Gray are openly neo-conservative and have wide ranging right links.
Reply
#16
(09-24-2019, 10:32 AM)billybassett Wrote: With respect I can so get off your high horse. Perhaps the 3 sec one liner wasn't an indepth review of my thoughts it was just to stimulate debate. Your third sentence attributes an argument to me that I've not made. I'm not backtracking as you actually don't know what my beliefs are. Perhaps you just read stuff on your FB wall that reinforces your own world view - I don't know and would not presume to pigeon hole you. That's probably where we are different. 

I tend to look further afield to read different views and consider them more widely. I laud what she's doing and yes the more voices the better. Maybe we can label some of the wider points as whitist and rightist but if you can't put that aside and consider some of the other points (right or wrong) then what's the point of this debate? Sounds like you're already locked in to a particular view? I don't know. If you are then you're like millions of others who use the internet and social media to actually close down debate and ideas and thought.

 I'm not on a high horse, I just think its's nonsense to post something and literally say "this is what I think" and then backtrack saying "oh it wasn't an in depth review of my thoughts" and "you don't know my beliefs". If you'd like to retract your support of the article and say you hadn't read it thoroughly then do that.

No idea where you get the idea I'm trying to close down debate? Or that I just read stuff on my FB wall? Seems like you've just pulled those out of thin air. To be honest I'm struggling to discern a point in the stream of consciousness above.

FWIW - my view is that man made climate change is clearly real and upon us. Activists like Greta are important as they pressure governments to act (declaring climate emergencies and setting carbon-neutral targets are a start). And I agree that the governments of Europe should be putting immense pressure on the likes of China and India to reduce their carbon footprint even if it may seem like a hopeless task.
Reply
#17
(09-24-2019, 10:53 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote:
(09-24-2019, 10:32 AM)billybassett Wrote: With respect I can so get off your high horse. Perhaps the 3 sec one liner wasn't an indepth review of my thoughts it was just to stimulate debate. Your third sentence attributes an argument to me that I've not made. I'm not backtracking as you actually don't know what my beliefs are. Perhaps you just read stuff on your FB wall that reinforces your own world view - I don't know and would not presume to pigeon hole you. That's probably where we are different. 

I tend to look further afield to read different views and consider them more widely. I laud what she's doing and yes the more voices the better. Maybe we can label some of the wider points as whitist and rightist but if you can't put that aside and consider some of the other points (right or wrong) then what's the point of this debate? Sounds like you're already locked in to a particular view? I don't know. If you are then you're like millions of others who use the internet and social media to actually close down debate and ideas and thought.

 I'm not on a high horse, I just think its's nonsense to post something and literally say "this is what I think" and then backtrack saying "oh it wasn't an in depth review of my thoughts" and "you don't know my beliefs". If you'd like to retract your support of the article and say you hadn't read it thoroughly then do that.

No idea where you get the idea I'm trying to close down debate? Or that I just read stuff on my FB wall? Seems like you've just pulled those out of thin air. To be honest I'm struggling to discern a point in the stream of consciousness above.

FWIW - my view is that man made climate change is clearly real and upon us. Activists like Greta are important as they pressure governments to act (declaring climate emergencies and setting carbon-neutral targets are a start). And I agree that the governments of Europe should be putting immense pressure on the likes of China and India to reduce their carbon footprint even if it may seem like a hopeless task.

I agree with your last para.

As for the first 2 I guess we'll just have to disagree - if you don't think you're closing down debate when it's obvious from my view then we're never going to meet. Next time I'll make sure I adhere to the board rules and post an indepth analysis of an article posted to encourage debate of the issues. But I don't think I'll bother as clearly people are more interested in how it's posted rather than discussing this issues.
Reply
#18
The world has been aware of global warming ever since the hole in the ozone layer was discovered in the 80s but the world has mostly pussyfooted around the problem for 30 years. I've no faith in politicians stepping up to the mark, so as far as I'm concerned, on a day when the Guardian reported only 1/5 of companies are on track to meet the Paris Agreement targets, there's nothing to lose in getting behind a 16 year old gobbing off at the UN. Something needs to spark governments into real action.
Reply
#19
I've said this on another forum, and I'll say it here. You can debate her message all you want, but for or against you have to admit that the situation seems very dodgy.


Here is a young girl with a mental health issue, being thrust forward as some kind of saviour of humanity, but it does appear she's being used. Her mother even wrote in a book that Greta can see the colourless and odourless CO2.

I'm sorry, but it looks to me that she's been taught a very poisonous mindset, has no defence against it, and nobody is actually looking out for her welfare.
"I'm not a nerd Bart. Nerds are smart"
Reply
#20
What a truly vile, smug article.
Says much about you BertieBassett- I bet you boo Johnstone too!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: