Luke Dowling
#11
(07-14-2019, 10:17 PM)Super_Slav Wrote: CL on Dowling:

Absolutely no surprise. The stuff going on with the academy proves that in Dowling we have another McDonough in our midst. Worrying times indeed.

Stuff going on with Dowling - he's out-Jenkinsed Jenkins for popularity. It'll come out in the wash. We are in serious shite I'm afraid if things don't change quickly.

And I know people might say: 'Well it's only the academy'. But this permeates throughout. It isn't healthy. Forest couldn't wait to get rid of the bloke. Yet we took him on.  Hope we know what we're doing.

Above all else, recall issues we had under McDonough. Needed a massive overhaul behind the scenes by absent owner. JP just about wrestled the club back onto the straight and narrow. Will Lai & his associates know any of this? Everything I hear about Dowling smacks of McDonough

Big issues. Academy staff marginalised, not allowed to use same entrance or canteen as first-team staff. Kids being told they're not important, crass language in front of visitors/agents/parents/female staff. I'm really not sure Dowling is the bloke we want as Tech Director #wba

I think I preferred your Wardy persona on the Zome Chris.
Reply
#12
(07-15-2019, 06:56 AM)Noibla Wrote: Jury is still out on Dowling but this is the same bloke who spent 4 years at Watford, and Forest  didnt just "get rid" as CL puts it, he made his choice to come to what he saw as a better opportunity. I think CL knows fuck all and is bitter and will find any reason to have a pop because he is not employed by WBA anymore.

This.

CL the massive cock!
Reply
#13
Chris has been slagging off Dowling ever since he was appointed.

Very strange..he comes across extremely bitter when back in the day he used to talk common sense.
Reply
#14
He does seem very bitter ( maybe he has a just case to ?).
However, what does Dowling actually bring to the club? What are his strengths ? Seriously, I have no idea so far ?
Reply
#15
(07-15-2019, 11:19 AM)EastMidsBaggie Wrote: He does seem very bitter ( maybe he has a just case to ?).
However, what does Dowling actually bring to the club? What are his strengths ?  Seriously, I have no idea so far ?

I have been heavily criticised for having a go at Dowling. But his record is appalling - he missed the Window last summer fair enough, but on the other hand this left him with no credit for Gayle and Barnes loans. But he had the Jan window to help address immediate and up and coming issues. The Holgate signing was a great piece of business although I wish we had purchased him. The other 3 loan signings were poor to say the least. I along with other expected him to bring us at least one or two hidden gems in or even guys with potential. Especially looking at the rebuild required in the summer. IMO he failed and failed miserably on the loan front and on purchases. His part in the handling of Big D was stupidity at the time and having no one signed and ready to take over was almost unforgivable. Now the window has been open since the 16th of May and he has got Windsor in from Cirencester and Filip I credit to Bilic. Looking at the size of the task (20 players leaving), his role and responsibility in resolving our issues - he doesn't need criticising he needs the sack immediately along with his team of 12 recruitment staff. 
Our beloved Darren got Gayle and Barnes in - tell me one! anyone player Dowling has got in that compares? How long did Darren get and how much longer can Dowling expect to be given to delliver.
Reply
#16
Where are the naysayers now? Burying there hand in the sand? Dave Bowler - the heart and soul of WBA looks to be off too
Reply
#17
(07-15-2019, 05:34 AM)Black Lake Victoria Wrote: I don't know about the journalist, what I do know is that we are in the ......., I'll give Bilic 3 months before he walks!

He won't stick around 3 months, I'll give him til a week. 

I did tell you about Dowling from the first interview!  The guy is a megalomaniac.  

He's alienated Slav already, I reckon Slav is laying the path to walk, why else would he say anything in public like he has - he could have said we're working hard behind the scenes to get the right players and it's taking longer than we anticipated.  He's effectively hung Dowling out to dry and left him in a very difficult position.    Sounds untenable to me.  

So what if no signings this week -  cos let's face it we're not going to make 4/5 in a week -  then what happens?  

Only at WBA!!
Reply
#18
I have to say in words and deeds I have not been impressed by Luke Dowling.

That said any reasonable employer should give them enough time to get to grips with the job in hand - 10 months is not enough time.
Reply
#19
(07-15-2019, 12:47 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I have to say in words and deeds I have not been impressed by Luke Dowling.

That said any reasonable employer should give them enough time to get to grips with the job in hand - 10 months is not enough time.

I really struggle to see how we continue to make this role so hard. His job is to coordinate scouting, transfers and youth and also our medical facilities.

I remember seeing a documentary where David Moyes showed a locked room in the training ground which was covered in whiteboards. One board for each position, with a list of targets, current expected value/demands, and it was updated every week or so, and colour coded for how easy it would be to sign them. There were then other boards with the current team, and how it was expected to evolve including youth players / potential transfers for the next 4 years. Obviously the current squad weren't allowed in!

I've seen another interview with Monchi where he said their approach is simple. He has a team of trusted people who spend 3-4 months watching football. They watch game after game on TV, each specialising in various leagues, and they just write lists and lists of players that impress them. If the name repeats, they start to monitor, and before you know it you have a massive list of targets... this is when you use technology to track and analyse.

It really cannot be hard to scout, monitor and sign players.
Reply
#20
(07-15-2019, 12:31 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(07-15-2019, 05:34 AM)Black Lake Victoria Wrote: I don't know about the journalist, what I do know is that we are in the ......., I'll give Bilic 3 months before he walks!

He won't stick around 3 months, I'll give him til a week. 

I did tell you about Dowling from the first interview!  The guy is a megalomaniac.  

He's alienated Slav already, I reckon Slav is laying the path to walk, why else would he say anything in public like he has - he could have said we're working hard behind the scenes to get the right players and it's taking longer than we anticipated.  He's effectively hung Dowling out to dry and left him in a very difficult position.    Sounds untenable to me.  

So what if no signings this week -  cos let's face it we're not going to make 4/5 in a week -  then what happens?  

Only at WBA!!

I dunno if Dowling is a megalomaniac and I don't care, but he is not astute and has failed in his role.
I for one are glad Slav has cleared up where the issues lie, I think the blame game started a week or so ago 
when Dowling said he was waiting for Slav? That was a terrible thing to say about your newly appointed manager. 
Pontius Pilate comes to mind. 
Sadly none of this helps us as move forward as a club.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: