Chris Kavanagh - ref on Tuesday
#11
(05-19-2019, 08:17 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote:
(05-19-2019, 07:44 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: I didn't really have a problem with the ref at Villa Park. The Holgate pen was blatant, I thought it was a pen in real time, but other than that he was OK. 

I didn't have any argument over the Gayle red, and although Grealish looked to have dived, you can only really tell via a slow mo replay. In real time it looked a pen.

I have a huge issue with him. He was a homer from start to finish. Cost us a place at Wembley. Holgate pen and it ends 2-2. Gayle never a sending off.

Saturday’s ref was undoubtedly shite and allowed himself to be swayed by the home crowd. Athers’ original post was about Tuesday’s though, who was fine.
Reply
#12
There is an argument that Kavanagh made as many mistakes as Scott.

Missed 2 good shouts for penalties, the El Ghazi handball and then one by Dawson in extra time.

Missed a foul by Rodriguez on Mings in the build up to our goal. I don't have much sympathy for Villa as there was a sufficient lapse in time between mistake and goal for it not to be that relevant. But if Villa had gone out I think we would have heard about it for some time.

Also did he miss a stamp by Brunt on McGinn in the first half. I don't think it was deliberate, but he may have easily taken a different view, assuming he didn't see it.

Kavanagh gets away with less criticism because he was more even handed in his mistakes/potential mistakes, because Villa went through and why protest about things that don't matter, and because so many of us watched the game at the ground, and these incidents were difficult to spot without the aid of tv replays.
Reply
#13
(05-19-2019, 06:54 AM)4-hero Wrote:
(05-18-2019, 11:25 AM)Hopalong Wrote: 4th official at the play-off final. 

Doesn't quite feel right?

Why?? He only has to hold a board up with a number on it ffs

That kinds of reflects your general knowledge about the game.  Big Grin

Just a personal view but I don't think officials involved in play off semi-final games should be involved in the final. 

It's dead easy to have a four person team who've reffed neither team in the play-offs and preferably this season as their could be 'history'/unconscious bias towards one team or another. 

That's all.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)