Nat Phillips
#11
Had a decent enough game. He'll put his body on the line, and head a brick for you all day long, but aside from that he's not very good, especially positionally. That's a massive worry for me.

He's not great with the ball, either, but that's not his game, so keep the ball away from him if you can, and only ask him to make very basic passes to negate that.

I feel more comfortable with Mepham and Campbell as the centre half pairing, but Phillips was fine yesterday, no major complaints. Not that Millwall offered much threat other than long balls - bread and butter for Nat. But he can only deal with what the opposition throws at him, and he did it well enough.
Reply
#12
(11-08-2026, 10:46 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(11-08-2026, 10:42 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: A side going for automatic doesn’t want situations where they are taking a chance on someone “doing a job”

We also have a very much finite budget. And more pace in wide areas/up top is more important at this stage I think. Dupont, Mohammed and Maughan and Pinnington are / have been all really highly rated. We need to give them a pathway and being 4th choice CB is just the job. If, 2 of the main men got significant injuries between now and Jan I would agree mind.

That’s the issue for me, we could gamble and then be left with a massive problem for 4 months. We just don’t know enough about those you refer to there to be sure they’d handle the kind of cooker we will be in. CT for very short bursts fine, definitely don’t want to pull Diakité out of where he is and TC med o crisps. I’m not sure it has to be a big strain on the budget if we do it right. As someone said elsewhere, we are rotating 16-18 without quality loss and I’d be focusing on plugging the only potential gap in that. 

Also not sure that it’s true we lack pace.
Raw Sausage
Reply
#13
(11-08-2026, 11:02 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Also not sure that it’s true we lack pace.

Sorry I should have added more meat on those bones. Not just pace in terms of top speed running. I mean ball carrying and the ability to beat a man 1v1. MJ can do it. Tunde showed signs yesterday. But we need 1 up top who can do that too at least.

Re the CB issue. I am not sure we can risk 10/15k a week just incase we have major injuries at the same time. But share the concern.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#14
(11-08-2026, 11:20 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(11-08-2026, 11:02 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Also not sure that it’s true we lack pace.

Sorry I should have added more meat on those bones. Not just pace in terms of top speed running. I mean ball carrying and the ability to beat a man 1v1. MJ can do it. Tunde showed signs yesterday. But we need 1 up top who can do that too at least.

Re the CB issue. I am not sure we can risk 10/15k a week just incase we have major injuries at the same time. But share the concern.
Trickery yes. JJ to a degree too, as pulling the shape out is the overall point and I agree with that.
Raw Sausage
Reply
#15
(11-08-2026, 10:06 AM)Dumbo Wrote: Has come in for some recent criticism recently but I thought he was superb yesterday. 

Some would argue Millwall is the right game for him, as heading and battling is his game. Regardless, I thought he was brilliant.

Best game I’ve seen him have for us quite possibly. If not, certainly among them. Didn’t for a second look panicked and marshalled the line brilliantly.

(11-08-2026, 11:20 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(11-08-2026, 11:02 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Also not sure that it’s true we lack pace.

Sorry I should have added more meat on those bones. Not just pace in terms of top speed running. I mean ball carrying and the ability to beat a man 1v1. MJ can do it. Tunde showed signs yesterday. But we need 1 up top who can do that too at least.

Re the CB issue. I am not sure we can risk 10/15k a week just incase we have major injuries at the same time. But share the concern.

We are one man down up top. My hope is that senior management recognise this. Because as much as Barney’s attitude can’t be faulted, he ain’t getting us promoted. 

I’d hope there are plans afoot to land a coup in January to bolster the attack.
Reply
#16
(11-08-2026, 10:18 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: We definitely need a decent calibre 4th in the window. Given we are likely to have a lot of young players going into a promotion battle of some sort, an old head would be ideal on a short term.
How about a loan move for Kipre from Ipswich? Not getting much game time for them this season. Good, solid defensively and good at bringing the ball out.
Reply
#17
Would be absolutely ideal WB

(11-08-2026, 12:17 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote:
(11-08-2026, 10:06 AM)Dumbo Wrote: Has come in for some recent criticism recently but I thought he was superb yesterday. 

Some would argue Millwall is the right game for him, as heading and battling is his game. Regardless, I thought he was brilliant.

Best game I’ve seen him have for us quite possibly. If not, certainly among them. Didn’t for a second look panicked and marshalled the line brilliantly.

(11-08-2026, 11:20 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(11-08-2026, 11:02 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Also not sure that it’s true we lack pace.

Sorry I should have added more meat on those bones. Not just pace in terms of top speed running. I mean ball carrying and the ability to beat a man 1v1. MJ can do it. Tunde showed signs yesterday. But we need 1 up top who can do that too at least.

Re the CB issue. I am not sure we can risk 10/15k a week just incase we have major injuries at the same time. But share the concern.

We are one man down up top. My hope is that senior management recognise this. Because as much as Barney’s attitude can’t be faulted, he ain’t getting us promoted. 

I’d hope there are plans afoot to land a coup in January to bolster the attack.

Ten goals in the last 4 is it? I’m not concerned about that end
Raw Sausage
Reply
#18
Horse for courses in this league ready made game for him yesterday but if GC is fit for Swansea I'd play him as Swansea tend to play football along the floor so will need GC extra pace .
Reply
#19
First half they had two nailed on chances when players were left unmarked inside the 6 yard box. Not all on Phillips, but if we'd have been up against opposition employing footballers rather than carthorses up front it would have been a very different game. Other than his part in that I thought he did alright, nothing fancy and put his foot through it when required. Perfectly adequate for a team aiming for the playoffs.
Reply
#20
We've scored in every game bar two (Wolves away and Blue at home), and have scored more than once in a game on eight separate occasions this season, including four of the six games in our current unbeaten run.

I couldn't give a toss what the stats and records tell me, but this isn't a team that struggles to create chances or find the back of the net. When I watch us this season, I don't get that feeling of 'we're never going to score' that I so often had under CC, as good as we were under him.

It's the other end of the pitch that concerns me far more. Yesterday was only our third clean sheet of the season, and even then, it was far from a convincing defensive display. The first half in particular was worrying, with them hitting the post and missing a couple of gilt edged chances, on both occasions having players left unmarked.

Despite a reasonably solid second half performance, that defensive fragility remains a real concern for me.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: