Jesus de Miguel
#11
(11-03-2026, 10:09 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(11-03-2026, 09:34 AM)wba13 Wrote: RIP Jesus.
It was a bloody ridiculous challenge he just wiped him out chest high, if that’s not dangerous what is. Why in the fuck was he going in that high with his knee, absolutely ridiculous.

He's gone up to head the ball, hasn't he? From his point of view he either has to win the header or take the player out, otherwise it's a goal. It's a tragic situation, but I think there's a danger of criminalising a genuine football challenge.

It's awful, but sometimes there's no one or nothing to blame for these things.

I will not change my mind, it was reckless and highly dangerous, his knee pommels him in the chest at full speed. Agreed he would not have known the outcome, but you do know you cannot make challenges like that.
Reply
#12
Just something he'll have to live with. Similar to the Aussie quick Sean Abbott who bowled the ball that killed Phillip Hughes.

A very sad outcome.
Reply
#13
(11-03-2026, 10:23 AM)Jacko Wrote: Just something he'll have to live with. Similar to the Aussie quick Sean Abbott who bowled the ball that killed Phillip Hughes.

A very sad outcome.

Your point about the outcome is somewhat valid, but the Philip Hughes situation was completely accidental, Abbott didn't bowl anything out of the ordinary.

This tackle was absolutely dreadful and shows a flagrant disregard for the health of the player he was hitting. Granted he clearly wouldn't have known he would kill him, but it's a pretty egregious tackle.
Reply
#14
(11-03-2026, 10:28 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(11-03-2026, 10:23 AM)Jacko Wrote: Just something he'll have to live with. Similar to the Aussie quick Sean Abbott who bowled the ball that killed Phillip Hughes.

A very sad outcome.

Your point about the outcome is somewhat valid, but the Philip Hughes situation was completely accidental, Abbott didn't bowl anything out of the ordinary.

This tackle was absolutely dreadful and shows a flagrant disregard for the health of the player he was hitting. Granted he clearly wouldn't have known he would kill him, but it's a pretty egregious tackle.

I’m with you on this my thoughts exactly.
Reply
#15
Not here to change minds, just commenting on how I see it. As I said in my original post, I'm not arguing against those who hold that view - I can understand why. I don't agree, and that's the point I've tried to put across. Apologies.

Ultimately, a young lad has lost his life. His family, friends, and teammates will be devastated, as will the opposition that witnessed it, and of course, the GK. It's really a tragic situation.
Reply
#16
The closest example I can think of is the Nottingham ice hockey player who was stabbed in the neck with a skate blade. Equally reckless behaviour but the CPS ruled there was no realistic prospect of conviction:

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cly2wkl17d7o
Reply
#17
It's a difficult one, the challenge doesn't look a great deal different from Diakite's last week, but Oussie pulls out in time. There but for the grace of god and all that.

Regards my comparison with Hughes, Abbott deliberately bowled a bouncer (within the laws), but it hit Hughes on the neck, this guy deliberately challenged for a high ball (within the laws) but cleared out the man. Neither expected the tragic outcome and that's why I don't feel there is any legal liability on the goalkeeper.

If Materazzi has a cardiac arrest after the Zidane headbutt that is a different story I guess, due to the nature of it.

Edit. Just seen Squid's post, I don't think they are similar, that incident didn't quite meet the legal threshold for a conviction whereas this one shouldn't even be considered in those terms.
Reply
#18
(11-03-2026, 10:56 AM)Jacko Wrote: It's a difficult one, the challenge doesn't look a great deal different from Diakite's last week, but Oussie pulls out in time. There but for the grace of god and all that.

Regards my comparison with Hughes, Abbott deliberately bowled a bouncer (within the laws), but it hit Hughes on the neck, this guy deliberately challenged for a high ball (within the laws) but cleared out the man. Neither expected the tragic outcome and that's why I don't feel there is any legal liability on the goalkeeper.

If Materazzi has a cardiac arrest after the Zidane headbutt that is a different story I guess, due to the nature of it.

Edit. Just seen Squid's post, I don't think they are similar, that incident didn't quite meet the legal threshold for a conviction whereas this one shouldn't even be considered in those terms.

Momentum is a huge factor, you've got two players running at each other at pace.
Reply
#19
(11-03-2026, 10:56 AM)Jacko Wrote: It's a difficult one, the challenge doesn't look a great deal different from Diakite's last week, but Oussie pulls out in time. There but for the grace of god and all that.

Regards my comparison with Hughes, Abbott deliberately bowled a bouncer (within the laws), but it hit Hughes on the neck, this guy deliberately challenged for a high ball (within the laws) but cleared out the man. Neither expected the tragic outcome and that's why I don't feel there is any legal liability on the goalkeeper.

If Materazzi has a cardiac arrest after the Zidane headbutt that is a different story I guess, due to the nature of it.

Edit. Just seen Squid's post, I don't think they are similar, that incident didn't quite meet the legal threshold for a conviction whereas this one shouldn't even be considered in those terms.

A bouncer isn't considered a "foul" in cricket. This tackle surely would be considered one in football.

That's my only contention, otherwise nothing to add.
Reply
#20
(11-03-2026, 10:58 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-03-2026, 10:56 AM)Jacko Wrote: It's a difficult one, the challenge doesn't look a great deal different from Diakite's last week, but Oussie pulls out in time. There but for the grace of god and all that.

Regards my comparison with Hughes, Abbott deliberately bowled a bouncer (within the laws), but it hit Hughes on the neck, this guy deliberately challenged for a high ball (within the laws) but cleared out the man. Neither expected the tragic outcome and that's why I don't feel there is any legal liability on the goalkeeper.

If Materazzi has a cardiac arrest after the Zidane headbutt that is a different story I guess, due to the nature of it.

Edit. Just seen Squid's post, I don't think they are similar, that incident didn't quite meet the legal threshold for a conviction whereas this one shouldn't even be considered in those terms.

Momentum is a huge factor, you've got two players running at each other at pace.

Agree with that BB.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: