In pastures green YouTube pod
#11
(10-27-2026, 08:54 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
  • We should be giving our young players opportunities to play
  • We should reduce the age of the squad
  • We never have players with resale value
  • We need young players with something to prove
One or two indifferent games later… terrible, lightweight, not good enough, should be dropped, poor, and those are the nicer/more polite things people say. Either fans want to see a young team progress and get better or they don’t. In reality many want almost robotic consistency of performance. Anything else ‘justifies a fan’s criticism’.

Anyway it sounds like the YouTube bollocks has done its job and people are clicking!

He was poor against Blackburn and Wrexham - there’s been a noticeable dip in form, and I think it’s reasonable to point that out.

That’s not to say he should be written off, which I don’t think anyone here has done (though morons on Facebook or Twatter probably have, mind).

What’s the point of a place like this if you can’t critically analyse performances? Most of the time people (myself included) talk bollocks, overreact, or are just wrong, but the whole point of a discussion forum is to debate the match, the season, what’s going well, what isn’t, and how things can be improved.

I don’t think people should be criticised for being critical, as long as it’s not abusive or utterly ridiculous. Most people know Whitwell is young, isn't a robot, and will have ups and downs while developing, but there's nothing wrong with saying he's in a dip - especially when it's accurate.
Reply
#12
(10-27-2026, 09:56 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-27-2026, 09:37 AM)BertieTheBaggie Wrote:
(10-27-2026, 08:54 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
  • We should be giving our young players opportunities to play
  • We should reduce the age of the squad
  • We never have players with resale value
  • We need young players with something to prove
One or two indifferent games later… terrible, lightweight, not good enough, should be dropped, poor, and those are the nicer/more polite things people say. Either fans want to see a young team progress and get better or they don’t. In reality many want almost robotic consistency of performance. Anything else ‘justifies a fan’s criticism’.

Anyway it sounds like the YouTube bollocks has done its job and people are clicking!

It's a thing called opinions about football. It happened 50 years ago when Tony Butler told people to 'get on yer bike.'
Unless people are abusive, especially at the ground, I don't let it bother me.

Yes but opinions need to have some logic behind them. You can’t start moaning when young players inevitably have a dip in form and then moan when younger players don’t play regularly. I mean you can but it makes absolutely no fugging sense.

I think you're being a shade pompous. There often isn't logic. Check the 15 minutes of so we were behind at Wrexham. These people had different opinions at full time.

You can't take football too seriously and you have to stay humble. I've got it dramatically wrong about players before and held my hands up and said they proved me wrong. Managers have got it wrong. there was one bloke who managed a club to be Champions of England and then came here and flogged a 21-year-old lad to our deadliest rivals as he didn't rate him. That raw lad went on to have a stand at Molineux named after him.

I just think support the team, give your opinions, but don't be too invested in them. Your online reputation as someone removed from your actual name doesn't carry that much weight.
Reply
#13
I'd like to think the irony isn't lost on anyone of the biggest whinger on here now whingeing about people whingeing.
Reply
#14
Just listened to the podcast. Well 10 minutes of it as I couldn't take any more negativity.

Crikey, what a thoroughly depressing listen. Anyone listening in without knowing where we were in the league would assume we were bottom not 5th after taking 7 points in 9.
Reply
#15
(10-27-2026, 08:26 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(10-27-2026, 07:38 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I think it's fair to be critical of Whitwell's recent performances, they have certainly dipped. But be respectful about it. There's a difference between saying someone isn't playing well, and being personal & disrespectful.

He's young, this is his first full season as a regular, he'll blow hot and cold, he's human FFS.

I must live a very sheltered life, as I’ve seen or heard no direct abuse. The beauty of not doing social media I guess, apart from this dump obviously. 
Whitwell had a poor game which was observed and called out, didn’t see anything ott, as was the case with Heggebo a few weeks ago.

If Whitwell comes on and scores the winner against West Ham, it would be a fantastic reaction, but would not make the criticism of his performance against Preston wrong or idiotic. 

As you say Josh, criticism and abuse are different things and need to be treated as such. There is very little of the latter on here.

Same here. I avoid Podcasts for the most part too as I just don't have the patience to wait for them to say something of interest.
Reply
#16
(10-27-2026, 10:41 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Just listened to the podcast. Well 10 minutes of it as I couldn't take any more negativity.

Crikey, what a thoroughly depressing listen. Anyone listening in without knowing where we were in the league would assume we were bottom not 5th after taking 7 points in 9.

Glad for your review Rich, I can safely avoid this steaming pile of turd then.
Reply
#17
Sounds so miserable and depressing that it must be hosted by Derek, Shirley?
Reply
#18
(10-27-2026, 07:38 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I think it's fair to be critical of Whitwell's recent performances, they have certainly dipped. But be respectful about it. There's a difference between saying someone isn't playing well, and being personal & disrespectful.

He's young, this is his first full season as a regular, he'll blow hot and cold, he's human FFS.

He's  obviously got a talent, but as  someone  on here said recently he needs taking out of the firing line for a while to get himself sorted.
Reply
#19
Thanks to this thread, I spent more time than is healthy looking at that YT episode. 

Such a lazy and negative format!

Start with a comment on Twitter, where we all know posts are made by intellectual inadequate who, when posting about football, find that the best way to get the attention they crave is to write some 'controversial' bilge.

Then get 4 blokes to chat about that comment without pointing out that it is a load of blocks posted by Billy Nomates from his bedroom in his Mum's house. The poster probably ruined into the episode with a sock handy for when his post is discussed.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)