Genuine question re. In game changes.
#11
Oh no, it absolutely isn't, and it's very hard to say for sure what to do, hindsight is great for a reason.
Reply
#12
(09-20-2026, 05:29 PM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(09-20-2026, 05:13 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: My sort of general rule in thinking is this.

No tactical subs first half unless clearly obviously necessary.
If first half didn't go well, one, two at a push half time subs.
Always make a change around 60 minutes, and this is a sub that could have been planned midweek.
From 60 minutes, sub if any player is exhausted or a sub has something to offer the team is missing.

How I would manage subs if I was a manager.

Today fwiw, at half time Molumby would have come off, he wasn't offering us anything of value. Collyer would have been on.

But how and when would you deviate? How would you decide that? 

Not being a dick, just think it's interesting to see things from outside my POV. 

It's so easy for me to say Heggebø is having a shit game, change him. But it's not that easy, is it?

It really is that easy... As I have said before, just because people don't make early changes doesn't mean we shouldn't. 

The game has changed now with 5 subs being available. If there's an obvious issue after 10 mins that can't be fixed with a tactical or positional tweak on the pitch. Fix it from the bench. Fwiw. It's rare that a well set up team needs to make such changes after 10 mins. The fact is today, as has been done to death, we were poorly set up from minute one so it was obvious early on.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#13
(09-20-2026, 05:33 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Oh no, it absolutely isn't, and it's very hard to say for sure what to do, hindsight is great for a reason.

Would you be more cautious or proactive?
Reply
#14
(09-20-2026, 05:36 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(09-20-2026, 05:29 PM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(09-20-2026, 05:13 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: My sort of general rule in thinking is this.

No tactical subs first half unless clearly obviously necessary.
If first half didn't go well, one, two at a push half time subs.
Always make a change around 60 minutes, and this is a sub that could have been planned midweek.
From 60 minutes, sub if any player is exhausted or a sub has something to offer the team is missing.

How I would manage subs if I was a manager.

Today fwiw, at half time Molumby would have come off, he wasn't offering us anything of value. Collyer would have been on.

But how and when would you deviate? How would you decide that? 

Not being a dick, just think it's interesting to see things from outside my POV. 

It's so easy for me to say Heggebø is having a shit game, change him. But it's not that easy, is it?

It really is that easy... As I have said before, just because people don't make early changes doesn't mean we shouldn't. 

The game has changed now with 5 subs being available. If there's an obvious issue after 10 mins that can't be fixed with a tactical or positional tweak on the pitch. Fix it from the bench. Fwiw. It's rare that a well set up team needs to make such changes after 10 mins.

The fact is today, as has been done to death, we were poorly set up from minute one so it was obvious early on.
Re that last line, we were over run and should have diffused the situation by not being so predictable playing out. Having got to HT, change the mf and remove Heggebo who played like he was carrying someone on his shoulders.
Reply
#15
Lads, stick or twist at HT, it ay ard.
Reply
#16
(09-20-2026, 05:41 PM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(09-20-2026, 05:33 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Oh no, it absolutely isn't, and it's very hard to say for sure what to do, hindsight is great for a reason.

Would you be more cautious or proactive?

Proactive for sure, it's something that has been documented as a fault with English coaching for so, so long, were very reactive, rarely do English coaches try to change a game with subs. The first English coach that shakes that fear off, will be future England manager and possibly the first Englishman to win the Premier League, a truly embarrassing fact that none has yet.
Reply
#17
I'd have 100% subbed Molumby at half time today, maybe even Whitwell since he really struggled. Collyer and Rabby would have been on.
Reply
#18
I think it's easy to say, I don't take this the wrong way.

I was screaming out for a change after 15 mins Big Grin
Reply
#19
(09-20-2026, 06:01 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I'd have 100% subbed Molumby at half time today, maybe even Whitwell since he really struggled. Collyer and Rabby would have been on.

Collyer for Jayse certainly.  Whitwell offered something. He was brave enough to put himself about when he had no options or outlets. 1st half he was directly in front of where I was and offered more than most but with no effect.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)