Big keepers/small keepers
#11
Being referenced as a nice lad has genuinely warmed my heart.

Marc Bolan (born Marc Feld) lead singer of T. Rex.

T-Rex apparently had short arms.

Incidentally, Pickford made some great saves during this tournament and I wouldn't hold him to account for what happened v. *********. Ze German just called it wrong.
Reply
#12
Peter Bonneti was 5ft 10inches and a brilliant keeper for Chelsea and played 7 times for England. 

He would have got more games but he was second fiddle to Gordon Banks who was the best keeper I have ever seen live by a country mile.
Reply
#13
(07-17-2026, 06:54 PM)Old Fart Wrote: Peter Bonneti was 5ft 10inches and a brilliant keeper for Chelsea and played 7 times for England. 

He would have got more games but he was second fiddle to Gordon Banks who was the best keeper I have ever seen live by a country mile.

I have a sticker album from 1976 and half of the keepers are below the 6ft mark. Guys like Burridge, Rimmer, Clemence, Stepney, Keelan.
By the way Godden was certainly over 6ft, maybe 6 1. I met him a couple of times. He had a strange blocky frame that made him look shorter.
Reply
#14
(07-17-2026, 07:44 PM)BertieTheBaggie Wrote:
(07-17-2026, 06:54 PM)Old Fart Wrote: Peter Bonneti was 5ft 10inches and a brilliant keeper for Chelsea and played 7 times for England. 

He would have got more games but he was second fiddle to Gordon Banks who was the best keeper I have ever seen live by a country mile.

I have a sticker album from 1976 and half of the keepers are below the 6ft mark. Guys like Burridge, Rimmer, Clemence, Stepney, Keelan.
By the way Godden was certainly over 6ft, maybe 6 1. I met him a couple of times. He had a strange blocky frame that made him look shorter.

Kevin Fucking Keelan, 571 appearances for Norwich.  Every game at the Hawthorns we would hammer Norwich for 89 minutes. Keelan would make a dozen world class saves to keep the score at 0-0.  And then two minutes from the end, they would lob a cross to the far post and Martin Peters would appear as if by magic to nod it home for the winner. Year after fucking year Keelan would defy all of the odds and keep a clean sheet after an 89 minute battering from our forwards.   

It was infuriating, but he was a great keeper.  

While I am in memory mode, one of the best keepers I have ever seen after Gordon Banks, was Colin Withers who played 146 games for Villa.  Villa were spectacularly shyte at that time and Withers  and their centre half John Sleeuwenhoek (born in Wednesfield) - a John Wile type centre half,  were instrumental in preventing them being relegated for several seasons.  If Withers had played for a London club he would have been an England regular.  

At that time my best mate was a Villa fan. We had an agreement that we would go to each of our home games together which we did for several seasons. As Villa were particularly crap at the time and bankrupt, it was great fun.  Even to this day the pleasure of watching Villa lose is almost on a par with watching us win.
Reply
#15
Pickford was fucking dreadful at this World Cup. Had a decent game in Mexico and was fucking useless for the rest.

He should’ve saved the following:
1st Croatia goal
1st Congo goal
1st Argentina goal

That is an utterly unforgivable record. He must be dropped.
Reply
#16
Should he saved the first? That seems harsh to me. He made some excellent saves on Wednesday, and had an overall good game.
Reply
#17
(07-18-2026, 12:42 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: Pickford was fucking dreadful at this World Cup. Had a decent game in Mexico and was fucking useless for the rest.

He should’ve saved the following:
1st Croatia goal
1st Congo goal
1st Argentina goal

That is an utterly unforgivable record. He must be dropped.

And that's a typical bored over-reaction. We do love a spacegoat on 'ere  Big Grin
Reply
#18
(07-17-2026, 06:54 PM)Old Fart Wrote: Peter Bonneti was 5ft 10inches and a brilliant keeper for Chelsea and played 7 times for England. 

He would have got more games but he was second fiddle to Gordon Banks who was the best keeper I have ever seen live by a country mile.

You're not wrong re. more games but when he took Banks's place (after the great one, acknowledged as the best keeper in the world at the time) was mysteriously (?!) poisoned before the 1970 World Cup match versus West Germany, Shilton had a nightmare and we lost 3-2. Mind you Ramsey subbing Bobby Charlton when we were 2-0 up to save him for the semi-final didn't help. I never thought Bonetti was that good tbh - but then I didn't like Chelsea much either.
Reply
#19
(07-17-2026, 10:22 PM)Old Fart Wrote:
(07-17-2026, 07:44 PM)BertieTheBaggie Wrote:
(07-17-2026, 06:54 PM)Old Fart Wrote: Peter Bonneti was 5ft 10inches and a brilliant keeper for Chelsea and played 7 times for England. 

He would have got more games but he was second fiddle to Gordon Banks who was the best keeper I have ever seen live by a country mile.

I have a sticker album from 1976 and half of the keepers are below the 6ft mark. Guys like Burridge, Rimmer, Clemence, Stepney, Keelan.
By the way Godden was certainly over 6ft, maybe 6 1. I met him a couple of times. He had a strange blocky frame that made him look shorter.

Kevin Fucking Keelan, 571 appearances for Norwich.  Every game at the Hawthorns we would hammer Norwich for 89 minutes. Keelan would make a dozen world class saves to keep the score at 0-0.  And then two minutes from the end, they would lob a cross to the far post and Martin Peters would appear as if by magic to nod it home for the winner. Year after fucking year Keelan would defy all of the odds and keep a clean sheet after an 89 minute battering from our forwards.   

It was infuriating, but he was a great keeper.  

While I am in memory mode, one of the best keepers I have ever seen after Gordon Banks, was Colin Withers who played 146 games for Villa.  Villa were spectacularly shyte at that time and Withers  and their centre half John Sleeuwenhoek (born in Wednesfield) - a John Wile type centre half,  were instrumental in preventing them being relegated for several seasons.  If Withers had played for a London club he would have been an England regular.  

At that time my best mate was a Villa fan. We had an agreement that we would go to each of our home games together which we did for several seasons. As Villa were particularly crap at the time and bankrupt, it was great fun.  Even to this day the pleasure of watching Villa lose is almost on a par with watching us win.
Keelan is probably the greatest ever Indian player
Reply
#20
(07-18-2026, 08:28 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Should he saved the first? That seems harsh to me. He made some excellent saves on Wednesday, and had an overall good game.

It went in about 4 yards from the post. The corner that led to it came from a shot he tipped over that was going a yard over the bar. He also had some scary moments with his feet. He did make one decent save though
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)