Time wasting / Tactical breaks
#11
(04-28-2026, 12:34 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(04-28-2026, 10:01 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(04-28-2026, 08:58 AM)SmethwickEnd Wrote: Why do they have to complicate everything.

Time the game. They will instantly stop all the time wasting when wasting ten seconds gets ten seconds added on.

I never understand why football couldn't adopt the rugby time. 

When the ball is out of play, or there's a stoppage. The ref stop his watch. HT and FT ends on 45 and 90 mins respectively. 

It's so simple and would solve so many issues. But the authorities won't allow something that would stop officials ability to play on until the fancied team scores a vital goal, will they.

The 90 minutes was never meant to be 90 of ball in play. It allowed for natural stoppages.

And even if the clock was stopped, players would still waste time to get breath back, annoy the opposition, break up the flow, reorganise etc, and they’d have the excuse that the clock was stopped. Then a 3pm kick off would finish at 6pm. No thanks.

This.

According to Claude (who could only find PL data), this season the ball has been in play for an average of exactly 55 minutes per match this includes added time at the end of each half. Games typically last around 100 minutes give or take. Extrapolating for a stopped watch system 90 minute matches would take around 165 minutes (2 hours and 45 minutes) plus half time.
Reply
#12
(04-28-2026, 01:47 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(04-28-2026, 12:34 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(04-28-2026, 10:01 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(04-28-2026, 08:58 AM)SmethwickEnd Wrote: Why do they have to complicate everything.

Time the game. They will instantly stop all the time wasting when wasting ten seconds gets ten seconds added on.

I never understand why football couldn't adopt the rugby time. 

When the ball is out of play, or there's a stoppage. The ref stop his watch. HT and FT ends on 45 and 90 mins respectively. 

It's so simple and would solve so many issues. But the authorities won't allow something that would stop officials ability to play on until the fancied team scores a vital goal, will they.

The 90 minutes was never meant to be 90 of ball in play. It allowed for natural stoppages.

And even if the clock was stopped, players would still waste time to get breath back, annoy the opposition, break up the flow, reorganise etc, and they’d have the excuse that the clock was stopped. Then a 3pm kick off would finish at 6pm. No thanks.

This.

According to Claude (who could only find PL data), this season the ball has been in play for an average of exactly 55 minutes per match this includes added time at the end of each half. Games typically last around 100 minutes give or take. Extrapolating for a stopped watch system 90 minute matches would take around 165 minutes (2 hours and 45 minutes) plus half time.
 
I think we'd all agree that if a player goes down injured, requiring the medical / physio staff to come on to the pitch that time should be added on. That is different to player getting tackled / fouled falling over and we have a short (<30 seconds) wait while he gets back up, no time should be added on for this. Obviously no time gets added on for the ball just going out of play. I would put into the rules that of a player gets booked for time wasting a minimum of 2 minutes gets added on to the clock, which I think would eventually solve the problem.
Reply
#13
(04-28-2026, 01:47 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(04-28-2026, 12:34 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(04-28-2026, 10:01 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(04-28-2026, 08:58 AM)SmethwickEnd Wrote: Why do they have to complicate everything.

Time the game. They will instantly stop all the time wasting when wasting ten seconds gets ten seconds added on.

I never understand why football couldn't adopt the rugby time. 

When the ball is out of play, or there's a stoppage. The ref stop his watch. HT and FT ends on 45 and 90 mins respectively. 

It's so simple and would solve so many issues. But the authorities won't allow something that would stop officials ability to play on until the fancied team scores a vital goal, will they.

The 90 minutes was never meant to be 90 of ball in play. It allowed for natural stoppages.

And even if the clock was stopped, players would still waste time to get breath back, annoy the opposition, break up the flow, reorganise etc, and they’d have the excuse that the clock was stopped. Then a 3pm kick off would finish at 6pm. No thanks.

This.

According to Claude (who could only find PL data), this season the ball has been in play for an average of exactly 55 minutes per match this includes added time at the end of each half. Games typically last around 100 minutes give or take. Extrapolating for a stopped watch system 90 minute matches would take around 165 minutes (2 hours and 45 minutes) plus half time.

They wouldn’t though would they. The second this was consistently applied the time wasting would stop. Rugby does it, you don’t see their games going wildly over the allotted times
Reply
#14
(04-28-2026, 03:14 PM)SmethwickEnd Wrote:
(04-28-2026, 01:47 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(04-28-2026, 12:34 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(04-28-2026, 10:01 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(04-28-2026, 08:58 AM)SmethwickEnd Wrote: Why do they have to complicate everything.

Time the game. They will instantly stop all the time wasting when wasting ten seconds gets ten seconds added on.

I never understand why football couldn't adopt the rugby time. 

When the ball is out of play, or there's a stoppage. The ref stop his watch. HT and FT ends on 45 and 90 mins respectively. 

It's so simple and would solve so many issues. But the authorities won't allow something that would stop officials ability to play on until the fancied team scores a vital goal, will they.

The 90 minutes was never meant to be 90 of ball in play. It allowed for natural stoppages.

And even if the clock was stopped, players would still waste time to get breath back, annoy the opposition, break up the flow, reorganise etc, and they’d have the excuse that the clock was stopped. Then a 3pm kick off would finish at 6pm. No thanks.

This.

According to Claude (who could only find PL data), this season the ball has been in play for an average of exactly 55 minutes per match this includes added time at the end of each half. Games typically last around 100 minutes give or take. Extrapolating for a stopped watch system 90 minute matches would take around 165 minutes (2 hours and 45 minutes) plus half time.

They wouldn’t though would they. The second this was consistently applied the time wasting would stop. Rugby does it, you don’t see their games going wildly over the allotted times

I think they would still waste time, for the reasons given above.

The goalie is going down, and the time is getting added on. Yet still they do it, not for time wasting reasons, but for team talks, re-organisation, getting breath back, killing the flow of the game, all sorts of reasons. To me, this actually shows that stopping the clock will not stop time wasting, as the clock is stopped for the goalie going down injured effectively, by adding the time.

The clock doesn't stop when the ball goes dead in rugby as far as I know (only for injuries, VAR, certain discussions between ref and players/coaches at their discretion). Its not stopped for scrums and lineouts and kicks.
Reply
#15
Rugby is a game of 80 minutes but can often extend to the best part of two hours. The ref is not a doctor so may have to stop the play for an injury but if that player is up and running within seconds you should be allowed to give a yellow. I also think that retrospective cautions should be allowed when the same happens. Not ideal as it doesn't benefit the opposition who have been wronged but all the same some kind of deterrent needs to happen here.
Reply
#16
In terms of time wasting there's been a solution to goalkeepers keeping hold of the ball for too long - award a corner. The same should apply to goal kicks, which should just be taken from the side the ball went out. Cut out the slow 10 yeard walk to fetch the ball, talking to the defender, strolling across to the other side of goal, putting the ball down, feigning to take a short one (with zero intention of doing so), walking back and kicking the boots against the post and then finally taking the goal kick. I've started looking at the clock when the ball goes dead and a goal kick reguraly takes 45-60 seconds. There's multi balls now, you don't need to wait, 30 seconds max and if it's not been taken a corner is awarded. If the oppo player hasn't left the penalty area and is delaying the goal kick then book them.

Same with throw-ins, point out where from and you've got 20 seconds to take it. Wrong place or too long then just give the opposition the throw-in.

If the ref awards a foul you shouldn't have to leave the field if injured. No foul and the player just goes down injured, then you automatically have a 30 second delay on returning, apart from keepers. Maybe the sub-keeper should have come on until the next stop in play or minimum time period? Apart from a penalty award in which case the keeper stays on or if past substitutions allow is subbed for the rest of the game.

Ref's watches should be linked up to a stadium clock and additional time mounting up shown, that way everyone can see how much time is being added as we go along. 30 seconds per sub, either 30 seconds or 1 min for a goal (depending how long the restart has been delayed), VAR stoppages and stoppages for injuries. Much more transparent and if everyone can see the time is being added as we go along, teams are less likely to waste it.

Having said all that we don't want to remove all shithousery from the game, it's partly why we're all addicted to it.

One last thing, any players that rolls back onto the pitch for treatment should firstly be booked and then bummed up the bumhole. If they stay off the pitch they don't need to wait the 30 seconds as the game as carried on and can enter the field of play without permission, but only from where they left the pitch. If that means playing someone on-side then tough.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#17
Doesn’t matter what you do with the rules unless they are enforced fairly and consistently. That ship, sadly, sailed long ago, so the whole issue is moot. IMO.
Reply
#18
Why are we suggesting Rugby rules to be implemented into football laws? Makes no sense, different sports entirely.
Reply
#19
(04-28-2026, 05:46 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Doesn’t matter what you do with the rules unless they are enforced fairly and consistently. That ship, sadly, sailed long ago, so the whole issue is moot. IMO.

But it does or can happen if they insist on it at the start of the season, like how long a goalie keeps the ball in hand.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)