Trendy young Championship managers
#11
(04-22-2026, 08:34 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-22-2026, 08:21 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(04-22-2026, 08:08 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Can we avoid more Ramsay’s please, they are what happens when you start believing a game where you essentially chase a bag of wind around a field in various patterns is a science rather than a sport. I shudder at the syllable laden shite that we had to listen to pre and post match under him. Morrison on the other hand talks normally and isn’t trying to desperately prove himself, which is breath of fresh air as is the way he’s set us up and how we are playing.

Seeking advice from ‘dinosaurs’ such as Pulis and others may not be trendy but it seems to work better than a degree from Loughborough Universities Sports Science syllabus. I’m certainly not against higher education in sport but the management speak, drivel makes it very hard to take seriously, not least because it’s not particularly astute or clever to complicate a game, when many of those trying to carry out your instructions at a practical level require simple repetitive instructions.

That's what the top managers can do.

They can take the complexity, and break it down to simple, repetitive drills and coaching sessions that mean the players know what they need to do. That's what Pulis and Roy do so well. It's what CC did, but you need the players with you, Ramsey never had the players on board, Mason did but fucked himself up by choosing to ignore most of the squad.

Morrison has done excellently because he's taken advice from experienced managers who know what position we were in and how to get out of it, and then hired a skilled, knowledgeable coach as his number 2 to help get training right. It's not difficult really, but ego gets in the way of many.

I don’t think it’s as complicated game as some do, however I completely agree with you that the two skills that seem to be needed most is the ability to gain the trust and respect of those playing and to give them clear instructions.

Tactics, data analysis, sports science, fitness are all important and can be helped by having a great team around you, but if no one listens or understands what you as a manager wants from them, you’re doomed to failure. It was pretty clear that many of our players didn’t understand what they were meant to do under Ramsay and that they sceptical of his credentials. If I had to listen to him painfully trying to sound like he knew what he was doing, I’d have switched too.

As I always say, if it's not complicated, go do it. I've studied for coaching and attended coaching seminars and such, yes some like to over complicate with absurd phrases and names for things already named. But like all games, it's far more complicated than the sum of it's parts. In fact, part of game theory, the more simple the basis of a game, the more complex mastering it becomes. Games with loads of complex rules and positions, like Rugby, or American Football become simpler to coach, football is very complex in that way.

But yes, like all leadership roles, getting people to listen to, and follow you is key.
Reply
#12
(04-22-2026, 05:36 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Mousinho, Skubala (from next season), Hellberg, Matos.

There's profile of manager we were looking at does exist, clearly we're just shit at choosing them. Which is why we just give the job to Mozza now.

Interesting to see if you do give it him. Can’t say he doesn’t deserve it. Shows how the game is far simpler than some make it.
Reply
#13
(04-22-2026, 08:21 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(04-22-2026, 08:08 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Can we avoid more Ramsay’s please, they are what happens when you start believing a game where you essentially chase a bag of wind around a field in various patterns is a science rather than a sport. I shudder at the syllable laden shite that we had to listen to pre and post match under him. Morrison on the other hand talks normally and isn’t trying to desperately prove himself, which is breath of fresh air as is the way he’s set us up and how we are playing.

Seeking advice from ‘dinosaurs’ such as Pulis and others may not be trendy but it seems to work better than a degree from Loughborough Universities Sports Science syllabus. I’m certainly not against higher education in sport but the management speak, drivel makes it very hard to take seriously, not least because it’s not particularly astute or clever to complicate a game, when many of those trying to carry out your instructions at a practical level require simple repetitive instructions.

That's what the top managers can do.

They can take the complexity, and break it down to simple, repetitive drills and coaching sessions that mean the players know what they need to do. That's what Pulis and Roy do so well. It's what CC did, but you need the players with you, Ramsey never had the players on board, Mason did but fucked himself up by choosing to ignore most of the squad.

Morrison has done excellently because he's taken advice from experienced managers who know what position we were in and how to get out of it, and then hired a skilled, knowledgeable coach as his number 2 to help get training right. It's not difficult really, but ego gets in the way of many.

Yep, I think the influence of Matt Gill tends to be overlooked in our recent resurgence. The assistant head coach is the man leading training. Ramsay had Dennis Lawrence. Mason had Nigel Gibbs. Michael Hefele was reckoned to be a very positive interface between CC and the players and it seems he was missed when he moved on. So Matt Gill has probably changed the training routines completely, introduced a much more positive vibe (let's face it, couldn't be worse than in the brief Ramsay era) and made the players want to play and win. I see little risk in giving the job to Mozza with Gill as his assistant at the end of the season.

I know society should avoid being ageist - in "intellectual" jobs you soon find yourself working for a young rising star and you have to get on with it. But in an environment full of gung-ho 20-somethings at the peak of their profession, it takes a very special personality to be the manager when you are younger than some of the players. It's human nature to bitch about the boss when things go badly, but we are programmed to respect older people. I can imagine Mason and Ramsay having absolutely nothing to offer the players as the bad results piled up, nothing to make them believe that they could improve. Even being shouted at by Alex Ferguson or Alan Buckley is more effective than hearing bullshit from an apparent schoolboy.
Reply
#14
One thing Morrison has at the club, when dealing with those gung ho 20-somethings, look at the wall, look at this clubs recent history, look for you, look for my name, then come talking to me with that attitude.

Apparently that was very much part of the very hot headed conversations after the Oxford game
Reply
#15
(04-22-2026, 08:52 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: One thing Morrison has at the club, when dealing with those gung ho 20-somethings, look at the wall, look at this clubs recent history, look for you, look for my name, then come talking to me with that attitude.

Apparently that was very much part of the very hot headed conversations after the Oxford game

I reckon he's got that photo of himself leaning against the post in front of the South Bank on the desk in his office, first sign of any trouble and out it comes.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)