Even the really shit teams win..
#11
(02-23-2026, 08:35 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(02-23-2026, 08:20 AM)MrBater Wrote: Eh we've had 2 totally inexperienced managers, I don't know what they teach them on their licence lessons, but it certainly isn't how to get the best out of their footballers.

Serious question, is there any newb, inexperienced manager like Mason or ramsay in charge of a team in England that is doing well?

Keith Andrews isn't doing too badly.

I'm not sure I buy the experienced/rookie excuses. I've said since the summer we've been left with a disaster of a squad. We have no RB, two midfielders (one of which has to play out of position because we didn't replace either of our departing attacking midfielders), one winger and one striker who's never played anywhere near this level before.

All of that results in us only being able to play a flat back four, two holding midfielders, we're so easy to play against as all we can do is sit in, try and be organised (I think there have been some signs of improvement) and hope we score a screamer on the break. Is it really any wonder we aren't winning games? Names like Warnock, Rowett and even Megson have been mentioned. They'd set us up in exactly this manner, end of the day the players we've been left with by Nestor as a squad are not good enough.

For all the faults of Mason and now Ramsay, it is a lack of quality or even options in key areas of the pitch that has put us in this mess. Some of us have been saying this since September and it's tiring now.
I agree Ted, but I think you have to factor in the choice of managers into the naivety of the new owners, add in the lack of a DoF and it's clear that their ignorance of this league is a major issue. The plan to reduce the age of the squad was a good one, but just bringing in young players, in the hope of making profit, doesn't work if the players are not fit for this league, just not fit, or leave the squad unbalanced.
Whatever league we are in come August, we need genuine football people in place making squad decisions.
Reply
#12
Le Bris 2 years at Rennes and a host of experience running youth teams in Europe before Sunderland.
Hellberg had 4 years of experience managing in Scandi clubs
bryan barry-murphy several years experience of management in the lower leagues before going to cardiff. (109 games in charge of Rochdale), then did 3 years at Man City's Elite Development Squad...
Martin Paterson - 7 years assisting in USA, 16 months as manager at Burton before Notts County.
lee Bell served his time (5 years) as assistant at lower league level then took over the same club as manager, and hasn't done very well.

Only Davies is comparable with the level of experience of our two experiments. One wonders how he'd have done without all the money.
Reply
#13
(02-23-2026, 09:14 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(02-23-2026, 08:35 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(02-23-2026, 08:20 AM)MrBater Wrote: Eh we've had 2 totally inexperienced managers, I don't know what they teach them on their licence lessons, but it certainly isn't how to get the best out of their footballers.

Serious question, is there any newb, inexperienced manager like Mason or ramsay in charge of a team in England that is doing well?

Keith Andrews isn't doing too badly.

I'm not sure I buy the experienced/rookie excuses. I've said since the summer we've been left with a disaster of a squad. We have no RB, two midfielders (one of which has to play out of position because we didn't replace either of our departing attacking midfielders), one winger and one striker who's never played anywhere near this level before.

All of that results in us only being able to play a flat back four, two holding midfielders, we're so easy to play against as all we can do is sit in, try and be organised (I think there have been some signs of improvement) and hope we score a screamer on the break. Is it really any wonder we aren't winning games? Names like Warnock, Rowett and even Megson have been mentioned. They'd set us up in exactly this manner, end of the day the players we've been left with by Nestor as a squad are not good enough.

For all the faults of Mason and now Ramsay, it is a lack of quality or even options in key areas of the pitch that has put us in this mess. Some of us have been saying this since September and it's tiring now.
I agree Ted, but I think you have to factor in the choice of managers into the naivety of the new owners, add in the lack of a DoF and it's clear that their ignorance of this league is a major issue. The plan to reduce the age of the squad was a good one, but just bringing in young players, in the hope of making profit, doesn't work if the players are not fit for this league, just not fit, or leave the squad unbalanced.
Whatever league we are in come August, we need genuine football people in place making squad decisions.

I think one hand is fighting the other.

If we'd have replaced Fellows and Furlong with like for like profiles i.e. a right back capable of offering an overlap and a winger of any description not an U21 LB from the Villa then we'd be in a far better position than we are now. Likewise if we could have found a more reliable '10' to allow Price to play alongside Mowatt. Those are minor, obvious changes that Nestor should have seen that would have kept us well away from trouble this season. 

If we accept in our last season of real PSR strife that it was always about bottoming out and finishing somewhere between 8th and 21st (a bit close for comfort at the moment), I see no reason with the coaching experience that Mason and Ramsay have that they couldn't have guided even a slightly more balanced squad to midtable obscurity. They could have.

Nestor abandoning all reason and signing really niche players for absolutely key positions and compounding that with a rookie manager has left us in shit creek, we've not even got a boat never mind a paddle.
Reply
#14
As ever it’s not one thing in isolation. Nestor has built a squad of individuals because there’s not a distinctive style or pattern of play.

Some of the signings and ideas were disastrous. You can’t replace Fellows with that Villa twat, who is supposedly a LWB. Yes a right winger as replaced with a left back/left wing back.

And to top it all off we took on a rookie manager who made so many bad in game decisions he lost points that could be the difference.

Even then we had a chance of redemption and we’ve gone for ER. He might have been ok if signed in the summer, but not now.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#15
(02-23-2026, 09:15 AM)MrBater Wrote: Le Bris 2 years at Rennes and a host of experience running youth teams in Europe before Sunderland.
So the same number of years in the hotseat as ER? 

Hellberg had 4 years of experience managing in Scandi clubs
Is the Swedish league really any better/more conpetetive than the MLS?

Bryan Barry-Murphy several years experience of management in the lower leagues before going to cardiff. (109 games in charge of Rochdale), then did 3 years at Man City's Elite Development Squad...
2 years in league one and 1 at league 2 after a relegation before going back to academy football. 

Martin Paterson - 7 years assisting in USA, 16 months as manager at Burton before Notts County.
20 matches for Burton on a temp contract.

lee Bell served his time (5 years) as assistant at lower league level then took over the same club as manager, and hasn't done very well.
Less experience as a number 2 at a much lower level than Mason, took over after a devastating relegation and has developed a really good brand of football again at Crewe and are now challenging for playoffs again. 


Only Davies is comparable with the level of experience of our two experiments. One wonders how he'd have done without all the money.
Bruce had one of the biggest budgets in the championship and had 20 years experience and less experience than ER.


Mason- 5 years youth development experience in the Prem followed by 5 years experince as a number 2 to Conte and Big Ange in teh prem. 15 games in teh hotseat in the prem. 

ER - 8 Years youth development at Shrewsbury Swansea and Chelsea. First team coach at Man Utd for over 100 games under Ole, Eric Ten Haag and Carrick. 2 years as an assistant at international level with Wales along side his work at Utd. 81 games in the hotseat at Minnesota where he massively over achieved with a struggling team both financially and in terms of the playing side. 

This is where I think blinkers/agendas come into play somewhat. So whilst some of the above had another year or so than I thought they are hardly seasoned pros, who frankly, had they come to us, and we were in our position, people would be saying the same about "experience". Even though we've had our fill of shit merry-go-rounders who have had all the "experience" in the world. Mason was a bigger risk than ER and frankly had we got ER in the summer instead I don't think we would be where we are now. 

The fact is, sadly, we will never know how good or bad ER is because of the mess we have got ourselves into with Mason/Nestor in the summer and through the first half of the year. I have my concerns over ER being too "flexible" and going back to what has failed personnel wise, even though our shape in reality is different to Mason as he is trying to get us to be more aggressive but our players have no confidence in themselves compete 1v1.

If we do in fact go down, we should absolutely leave ER in charge as that would probably been his most logical next step in the English game anyway.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#16
There’s a whole bunch of intangibles that it’s difficult to factor into data driven models like gravitas, presence, charisma, personal impact, communication etc Mason and Ramsay strike me as being identikit managers, trusting in process and doing stuff by numbers, straight out of a manual. If you look at the best leaders in football, likes of Clough, Ferguson, Mourinho, Guardiola and dare I say Megson with us all have a presence, they’re interesting unique personalities, the opposite of the identikit models adopted by Mason and Ramsay. Just hope we get the next appointment right, because the personality is every bit as important as the data.
Reply
#17
(02-23-2026, 01:12 PM)Vinebaggie Wrote: There’s a whole bunch of intangibles that it’s difficult to factor into data driven models like gravitas, presence, charisma, personal impact, communication etc Mason and Ramsay strike me as being identikit managers, trusting in process and doing stuff by numbers, straight out of a manual. If you look at the best leaders in football, likes of Clough, Ferguson, Mourinho, Guardiola and dare I say Megson with us all have a presence, they’re interesting unique personalities, the opposite of the identikit models adopted by Mason and Ramsay. Just hope we get the next appointment right, because the personality is every bit as important as the data.

It's like you want a manager who manages people... not someone who trots out fancy powerpoints on styles of play and suchlike... who'dda ever thunk it??! Big Grin
Reply
#18
(02-23-2026, 12:36 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-23-2026, 09:15 AM)MrBater Wrote: Le Bris 2 years at Rennes and a host of experience running youth teams in Europe before Sunderland.
So the same number of years in the hotseat as ER? 

Hellberg had 4 years of experience managing in Scandi clubs
Is the Swedish league really any better/more conpetetive than the MLS?

Bryan Barry-Murphy several years experience of management in the lower leagues before going to cardiff. (109 games in charge of Rochdale), then did 3 years at Man City's Elite Development Squad...
2 years in league one and 1 at league 2 after a relegation before going back to academy football. 

Martin Paterson - 7 years assisting in USA, 16 months as manager at Burton before Notts County.
20 matches for Burton on a temp contract.

lee Bell served his time (5 years) as assistant at lower league level then took over the same club as manager, and hasn't done very well.
Less experience as a number 2 at a much lower level than Mason, took over after a devastating relegation and has developed a really good brand of football again at Crewe and are now challenging for playoffs again. 


Only Davies is comparable with the level of experience of our two experiments. One wonders how he'd have done without all the money.
Bruce had one of the biggest budgets in the championship and had 20 years experience and less experience than ER.


Mason- 5 years youth development experience in the Prem followed by 5 years experince as a number 2 to Conte and Big Ange in teh prem. 15 games in teh hotseat in the prem. 

ER - 8 Years youth development at Shrewsbury Swansea and Chelsea. First team coach at Man Utd for over 100 games under Ole, Eric Ten Haag and Carrick. 2 years as an assistant at international level with Wales along side his work at Utd. 81 games in the hotseat at Minnesota where he massively over achieved with a struggling team both financially and in terms of the playing side. 

This is where I think blinkers/agendas come into play somewhat. So whilst some of the above had another year or so than I thought they are hardly seasoned pros, who frankly, had they come to us, and we were in our position, people would be saying the same about "experience". Even though we've had our fill of shit merry-go-rounders who have had all the "experience" in the world. Mason was a bigger risk than ER and frankly had we got ER in the summer instead I don't think we would be where we are now. 

The fact is, sadly, we will never know how good or bad ER is because of the mess we have got ourselves into with Mason/Nestor in the summer and through the first half of the year. I have my concerns over ER being too "flexible" and going back to what has failed personnel wise, even though our shape in reality is different to Mason as he is trying to get us to be more aggressive but our players have no confidence in themselves compete 1v1.

If we do in fact go down, we should absolutely leave ER in charge as that would probably been his most logical next step in the English game anyway.

Whilst you are correct, our fanbase has decided it's a no for Ramsay and if he's got anything about him he'll leave at the end of the season regardless of what league we're in.

We can then focus on appointing someone with grey hair who gets the lads to put a shift in.
Reply
#19
(02-23-2026, 01:14 PM)MrBater Wrote:
(02-23-2026, 01:12 PM)Vinebaggie Wrote: There’s a whole bunch of intangibles that it’s difficult to factor into data driven models like gravitas, presence, charisma, personal impact, communication etc  Mason and Ramsay strike me as being identikit managers, trusting in process and doing stuff by numbers, straight out of a manual.  If you look at the best leaders in football, likes of Clough, Ferguson, Mourinho, Guardiola and dare I say Megson with us all have a presence, they’re interesting unique personalities, the opposite of the identikit models adopted by Mason and Ramsay.  Just hope we get the next appointment right, because the personality is every bit as important as the data.

It's like you want a manager who manages people... not someone who trots out fancy powerpoints on styles of play and suchlike... who'dda ever thunk it??! Big Grin

As always it's not one of the other. You need a staff with bits of everything. Clough I won't talk about because his time was before football became a truly professional sport if that what you want to go back to I suggest watching non league. As it's still the same there, and enjoyable it is at times too. 

But Ferguson had top class coaches and analysts who did all the actual football work for him. Mourinho was massive into data and finding performance away from the obvious and Pep has only managed at the top level with the most cutting edge facilities and staff in the world. 

Its not the fact that we have a well educated footballing professional in charge which is holding us back. It's the fact that over the last off season and season to date we haven't developed a true footballing identity and had a coach who's biggest weakness was in game management who h has led to us having no confidence and/or momentum.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#20
(02-23-2026, 12:36 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-23-2026, 09:15 AM)MrBater Wrote: Le Bris 2 years at Rennes and a host of experience running youth teams in Europe before Sunderland.
So the same number of years in the hotseat as ER? 

Hellberg had 4 years of experience managing in Scandi clubs
Is the Swedish league really any better/more conpetetive than the MLS?

Bryan Barry-Murphy several years experience of management in the lower leagues before going to cardiff. (109 games in charge of Rochdale), then did 3 years at Man City's Elite Development Squad...
2 years in league one and 1 at league 2 after a relegation before going back to academy football. 

Martin Paterson - 7 years assisting in USA, 16 months as manager at Burton before Notts County.
20 matches for Burton on a temp contract.

lee Bell served his time (5 years) as assistant at lower league level then took over the same club as manager, and hasn't done very well.
Less experience as a number 2 at a much lower level than Mason, took over after a devastating relegation and has developed a really good brand of football again at Crewe and are now challenging for playoffs again. 


Only Davies is comparable with the level of experience of our two experiments. One wonders how he'd have done without all the money.
Bruce had one of the biggest budgets in the championship and had 20 years experience and less experience than ER.


Mason- 5 years youth development experience in the Prem followed by 5 years experince as a number 2 to Conte and Big Ange in teh prem. 15 games in teh hotseat in the prem. 

ER - 8 Years youth development at Shrewsbury Swansea and Chelsea. First team coach at Man Utd for over 100 games under Ole, Eric Ten Haag and Carrick. 2 years as an assistant at international level with Wales along side his work at Utd. 81 games in the hotseat at Minnesota where he massively over achieved with a struggling team both financially and in terms of the playing side. 

This is where I think blinkers/agendas come into play somewhat. So whilst some of the above had another year or so than I thought they are hardly seasoned pros, who frankly, had they come to us, and we were in our position, people would be saying the same about "experience". Even though we've had our fill of shit merry-go-rounders who have had all the "experience" in the world. Mason was a bigger risk than ER and frankly had we got ER in the summer instead I don't think we would be where we are now. 

The fact is, sadly, we will never know how good or bad ER is because of the mess we have got ourselves into with Mason/Nestor in the summer and through the first half of the year. I have my concerns over ER being too "flexible" and going back to what has failed personnel wise, even though our shape in reality is different to Mason as he is trying to get us to be more aggressive but our players have no confidence in themselves compete 1v1.

If we do in fact go down, we should absolutely leave ER in charge as that would probably been his most logical next step in the English game anyway.

If we go down, leave him in charge? Reward failure?

There’s some strange stuff on this board these days!

He won’t last til the end of the season if we look like going down anyway. If we don’t win tomorrow, he might not last til Wednesday.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)