Team for Friday
#11
I'd go with that 11 too, back to basics and let players do what they are good at. It doesn't matter what 11 we start with though if we do not compete, football does not change in that you have to earn the right to play, and we didn't compete tonight which is unforgivable!
Reply
#12
(01-20-2026, 11:51 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I can't believe people want to go back to a team sheet and shape that has failed so badly all year.

We have to find a NEW solution or we're going down.

I sort of agree with the essence of what you're arguing but the tried and tested team and shape will actually do enough to keep us up. From what we saw tonight, trying to force our players into a formation that we don't have the right players for will really drag us into the mire.

Tonight was more than just a defeat to a relegation rival. It was an absolute thumping which will have completely knocked the stuffing out of the players, has turned the crowd against the team and eroded a lot of early goodwill towards Ramsay.

We need 'back to basics' stuff for these upcoming games. We similar don't have the time or the tools to be trying something else.
Reply
#13
(01-21-2026, 12:01 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(01-20-2026, 11:51 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I can't believe people want to go back to a team sheet and shape that has failed so badly all year.

We have to find a NEW solution or we're going down.

I sort of agree with the essence of what you're arguing but the tried and tested team and shape will actually do enough to keep us up. From what we saw tonight, trying to force our players into a formation that we don't have the right players for will really drag us into the mire.

Tonight was more than just a defeat to a relegation rival. It was an absolute thumping which will have completely knocked the stuffing out of the players, has turned the crowd against the team and eroded a lot of early goodwill towards Ramsay.

We need 'back to basics' stuff for these upcoming games. We similar don't have the time or the tools to be trying something else.

Back to Basics - It's a mentality more than a shape or set of tactics for me and should be independent.

Head stuff, kick stuff, challenge hard, run hard, win duels, stay compact, take few risks, get shots off as quickly as possible.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#14
I'm happy to stick with it but...

Griffiths

Campbell
Phillips
Bielik

Williams
Price
Mowatt
Styles
SIJ

Johnston

Dike/Heggebø

I think Maja has shown in the last 4 days he's currently better off the bench.

I've seen enough of Mepham, Taylor, Grant and Molumby for a while thanks.
Reply
#15
(01-20-2026, 11:51 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I can't believe people want to go back to a team sheet and shape that has failed so badly all year.

We have to find a NEW solution or we're going down.

We ain’t been shit all year due to the formation.
Reply
#16
(01-21-2026, 12:23 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(01-20-2026, 11:51 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I can't believe people want to go back to a team sheet and shape that has failed so badly all year.

We have to find a NEW solution or we're going down.

We ain’t been shit all year due to the formation.

That's why I said team sheet AND shape. The lack of balance has caused us to fail. Fwiw, I put both a back 3 and back 4 suggestion on this Fred as I don't think it necessarily the shape that's most important. It's the balance and having the right profiles of players across the XI.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#17
(01-20-2026, 11:51 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I can't believe people want to go back to a team sheet and shape that has failed so badly all year.

We have to find a NEW solution or we're going down.

WALOB. We weren’t getting twatted every week. 

This change of formation - and resultant placing of square pegs in round holes - has been akin to giving a lung transplant to someone who’s gone to the doctors with a cough. 

Also, the first 11 in the OP hasn’t started a single game this season. We’ve only started 2 games with a team (outfield only) that is one change removed from the suggested team in the OP - record of W1 L1 GS3 GC2. 

Leicester away (Mepham instead of Bielik)
Sheffield Utd home (Diakite instead of Mowatt)

It’s hardly some failed system like you seem to be making out.
Reply
#18
‘This change of formation - and resultant placing of square pegs in round holes - has been akin to giving a lung transplant to someone who’s gone to the doctors with a cough.’

Absolutely fucking brilliant. We have appointed Dr Nick from the Simpsons.
Reply
#19
If it's a change of shape then it has to go back to the Carlos method.

Griffiths

Gilchrist
Campbell
Phillips
Styles

Bielik

Johnston
Styles
Mowatt
SIJ

Heggebo

Five attackers, fiver defenders.
Reply
#20
(01-21-2026, 12:23 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(01-20-2026, 11:51 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I can't believe people want to go back to a team sheet and shape that has failed so badly all year.

We have to find a NEW solution or we're going down.

We ain’t been shit all year due to the formation.

That's because we haven't been shit all year.
We've not been good either.

Of the games we have played this season, only 4 have seen a margin of victory of 2 or more goals. That suggests that we are competitive in most games, tight games that could go either way..

They tend to go the oppositions way, because we are poor at taking our chances  we are  poor at shooting from distance, we are prone to defensive howlers, and lady luck has not been on our side much in this season.

There are games we have played very badly in, Sheff Wed being a prime example.
But there have been also a number of games where we have been better than the opposition, but have contrived to lose or draw. Hull away being a prime example.

I was never quite sure how a new coach was going to solve our primary weaknesses. But this was never going to be it.

The team AJ suggested is probably our strongest 11.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: