Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
It probably depends on what the discussion is about. If you’ve played at a decent level you will recognise some of the non-obvious signs when a player is struggling with confidence and needs to be rested rather than him being shite. You can probably relate a bit better to what is happening on the pitch. You’ll also understand a bit more about when to criticise someone for a mistake over something they had no way of dealing with - I still smile at someone in the Brummie bollocking a player for not controlling the ball and somebody else pointing out that controlling it around nostril height isn’t to be expected.
Generally it won’t be a big advantage but it does give you a bit more empathy with the player if you’ve been in similar situations.
Posts: 7,711
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
You only have to listen to one Andy Johnson co comms to know absolutely not.
Posts: 1,801
Threads: 27
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation:
7
Colin was a chiropodist, Mourinho was a linguist both did OK, then there’s an endless procession of world class players who were crap as managers. So no for me.
Posts: 8,079
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
12-29-2025, 06:20 PM
(This post was last modified: 12-29-2025, 06:21 PM by HawkingsHalfpint.)
I think what matters most is that you are a ‘Football Man’.
According to Merse at least. And Wrighty. And other associated no-marks like Chappers. I mean, Lovejoy built a career on it all, if you really want to drag it through the mire.
Posts: 27,981
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
The best programme on telly for football punditry and analysis was BT’s Champions League show which was staffed exclusively by James Richardson and his crew of Guardian journos.
Not one of them had kicked a ball at any level but being actual journalists they were able to deliver articulate, insightful and intelligent analysis every time.