No leadership, no fight...
#11
(11-22-2025, 02:56 PM)sickParrot Wrote:
(11-22-2025, 02:54 PM)Jacko Wrote: Every other manager in the 4 divisions makes a substitution immediately following the red card. This guy is clueless.

Didn’t react to the red or the equaliser, waited until we were behind to make the changes that should’ve made when Jase walked.

(11-22-2025, 02:54 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(11-22-2025, 02:50 PM)CIM Wrote: For all the good in the 1st half why did Mason take MJ off? And why only respond with subs when we were 3-2 down? Poor game management becoming a consistent theme

MJ must have been injured. Not even Mason is that tactically incompetent.

He just confirmed it and his interview.

He confirmed it was tactical (not injury)
Reply
#12
(11-22-2025, 02:57 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: After years of piss poor off-field strategy we are, unfortunately, paying the price for that. We were pretty much forced to sell our best player (for whom we had no back-up), not long after selling our best ‘keeper (for whom we thankfully did), before offloading two or three experienced defenders for cut-price replacements. The current manager is a (hoped-to-be) promising young hit-and-hope, appointed after we failed with another dinosaur; who couldn’t strengthen the attack because of the number of forward players in the treatment room. Thankfully, a lot of the underperforming big earners are now gone, but when you’ve continuously spunked quite so much cash on other players who just haven’t delivered sufficiently there simply isn’t a lot to work with. I wish some of us would wake up to the fact that we simply aren’t very good anymore.

The last time we were shit and the internet was a thing, at least being shit was all we had known. This time around it seems a hundred times worse, because for some reason people seem to think that it’s as easy as picking their fantasy league team with an unlimited budget. Yes let’s sack the manager, drop the moron, ignore PSR, etc. - that’s brilliant. But what is actually workable?

Today was very unlucky, and a limited player (who unfortunately we can’t afford better than) let us down. But seriously, what can be done about it, at this stage of the season and with 23 other teams who aren’t all that much better or worse than us being more than - or at least equally as - competitive?

I’m as pissed off with hindsight experts as I am with the team, which is all pointless really. Because the true blame lies with the era before this one. It’s probably better to just accept that we don’t have a divine right to succeed anymore, and that wholesale scapegoating won’t change very much.

Bring on next week and chalk this one down to a bad day at the office. As someone said somewhere else, at least there were - for 45 minutes at least - signs of progress, and we managed to keep the scoreline respectable against the media-adored team running away with it.

Can't really argue with this, all very true.
Reply
#13
(11-22-2025, 02:57 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: After years of piss poor off-field strategy we are, unfortunately, paying the price for that. We were pretty much forced to sell our best player (for whom we had no back-up), not long after selling our best ‘keeper (for whom we thankfully did), before offloading two or three experienced defenders for cut-price replacements. The current manager is a (hoped-to-be) promising young hit-and-hope, appointed after we failed with another dinosaur; who couldn’t strengthen the attack because of the number of forward players in the treatment room. Thankfully, a lot of the underperforming big earners are now gone, but when you’ve continuously spunked quite so much cash on other players who just haven’t delivered sufficiently there simply isn’t a lot to work with. I wish some of us would wake up to the fact that we simply aren’t very good anymore.

The last time we were shit and the internet was a thing, at least being shit was all we had known. This time around it seems a hundred times worse, because for some reason people seem to think that it’s as easy as picking their fantasy league team with an unlimited budget. Yes let’s sack the manager, drop the moron, ignore PSR, etc. - that’s brilliant. But what is actually workable?

Today was very unlucky, and a limited player (who unfortunately we can’t afford better than) let us down. But seriously, what can be done about it, at this stage of the season and with 23 other teams who aren’t all that much better or worse than us being more than - or at least equally as - competitive?

I’m as pissed off with hindsight experts as I am with the team, which is all pointless really. Because the true blame lies with the era before this one. It’s probably better to just accept that we don’t have a divine right to succeed anymore, and that wholesale scapegoating won’t change very much.

Bring on next week and chalk this one down to a bad day at the office. As someone said somewhere else, at least there were - for 45 minutes at least - signs of progress, and we managed to keep the scoreline respectable against the media-adored team running away with it.

Absoulute nail on head. Best post on here for ages
Reply
#14
I am not sure the "cut price" argument holds up and of course cannot prove this without seeing the contracts.
In terms of both wages and transfer fees Gilchrist, Phillips, Mepham, Bielik, Heggebo, Price and Bany would not have been cheap. A few of these would have been on Premier League wages.
I suspect quite few clubs in the Championship have spent less than we have.
Reply
#15
Why would a load of championship players, a Scandinavian and one from League one be in Premier Laegue wages? As you say, unless we know the details we can’t really speculate.

I agree that perhaps not enough attention was paid to the midfield in the summer, and the Heggebø fee was significant. But none of the are particularly massive signings.
Reply
#16
(11-22-2025, 02:57 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: After years of piss poor off-field strategy we are, unfortunately, paying the price for that. We were pretty much forced to sell our best player (for whom we had no back-up), not long after selling our best ‘keeper (for whom we thankfully did), before offloading two or three experienced defenders for cut-price replacements. The current manager is a (hoped-to-be) promising young hit-and-hope, appointed after we failed with another dinosaur; who couldn’t strengthen the attack because of the number of forward players in the treatment room. Thankfully, a lot of the underperforming big earners are now gone, but when you’ve continuously spunked quite so much cash on other players who just haven’t delivered sufficiently there simply isn’t a lot to work with. I wish some of us would wake up to the fact that we simply aren’t very good anymore.

The last time we were shit and the internet was a thing, at least being shit was all we had known. This time around it seems a hundred times worse, because for some reason people seem to think that it’s as easy as picking their fantasy league team with an unlimited budget. Yes let’s sack the manager, drop the moron, ignore PSR, etc. - that’s brilliant. But what is actually workable?

Today was very unlucky, and a limited player (who unfortunately we can’t afford better than) let us down. But seriously, what can be done about it, at this stage of the season and with 23 other teams who aren’t all that much better or worse than us being more than - or at least equally as - competitive?

I’m as pissed off with hindsight experts as I am with the team, which is all pointless really. Because the true blame lies with the era before this one. It’s probably better to just accept that we don’t have a divine right to succeed anymore, and that wholesale scapegoating won’t change very much.

Bring on next week and chalk this one down to a bad day at the office. As someone said somewhere else, at least there were - for 45 minutes at least - signs of progress, and we managed to keep the scoreline respectable against the media-adored team running away with it.

But that progress was very much spearheaded by MJ, who Mason removed for “tactical “ reasons. Whereas Molumby remains despite his idiotic yellow card just before the break and was a red in waiting. If he’d made no halftime changes, as per usual, he may have been able to justify it but to hook MJ and leave Molumby was just potty.
That’s not hindsight or spacegoating it’s just a fair point surely?

Mason is either really unlucky or on some kind of suicide mission.
Or he’s just not up to this level.
Reply
#17
(11-22-2025, 03:16 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(11-22-2025, 02:57 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: After years of piss poor off-field strategy we are, unfortunately, paying the price for that. We were pretty much forced to sell our best player (for whom we had no back-up), not long after selling our best ‘keeper (for whom we thankfully did), before offloading two or three experienced defenders for cut-price replacements. The current manager is a (hoped-to-be) promising young hit-and-hope, appointed after we failed with another dinosaur; who couldn’t strengthen the attack because of the number of forward players in the treatment room. Thankfully, a lot of the underperforming big earners are now gone, but when you’ve continuously spunked quite so much cash on other players who just haven’t delivered sufficiently there simply isn’t a lot to work with. I wish some of us would wake up to the fact that we simply aren’t very good anymore.

The last time we were shit and the internet was a thing, at least being shit was all we had known. This time around it seems a hundred times worse, because for some reason people seem to think that it’s as easy as picking their fantasy league team with an unlimited budget. Yes let’s sack the manager, drop the moron, ignore PSR, etc. - that’s brilliant. But what is actually workable?

Today was very unlucky, and a limited player (who unfortunately we can’t afford better than) let us down. But seriously, what can be done about it, at this stage of the season and with 23 other teams who aren’t all that much better or worse than us being more than - or at least equally as - competitive?

I’m as pissed off with hindsight experts as I am with the team, which is all pointless really. Because the true blame lies with the era before this one. It’s probably better to just accept that we don’t have a divine right to succeed anymore, and that wholesale scapegoating won’t change very much.

Bring on next week and chalk this one down to a bad day at the office. As someone said somewhere else, at least there were - for 45 minutes at least - signs of progress, and we managed to keep the scoreline respectable against the media-adored team running away with it.

But that progress was very much spearheaded by MJ, who Mason removed for “tactical “ reasons. Whereas Molumby remains despite his idiotic yellow card just before the break and was a red in waiting. If he’d made no halftime changes, as per usual, he may have been able to justify it but to hook MJ and leave Molumby was just potty.
That’s not hindsight or spacegoating it’s just a fair point surely?

Mason is either really unlucky or on some kind of suicide mission.
Or he’s just not up to this level.

I agree with pretty much everything you’ve said Hawks, and I don’t think anyone expects us to get promoted this year, but you have to see progress or reasons to be optimistic and under Mason there are none. We have a clown in the dug out who is failing to get a tune out of a limited but competent set of players.
Reply
#18
(11-22-2025, 03:13 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Why would a load of championship players, a Scandinavian and one from League one be in Premier Laegue wages? As you say, unless we know the details we can’t really speculate.

I agree that perhaps not enough attention was paid to the midfield in the summer, and the Heggebø fee was significant. But none of the are particularly massive signings.

Gilchrist, Mepham and Philips were all signed from Premier League clubs, hence my comment about Premier Leage wages
Reply
#19
I’m under-impressed with RM, both, after what looked like a very positive start. I’m not saying he’s the one to lead us back to greatness. However I can’t really see how he can be blamed for not being able to see into the future, and being able to predict Molumby’s red. The player himself should know better (even though at least one on here called it). Perhaps he should have called it, but to me there was no coincidence either that JM was part of a midfield that was competing, after weeks of having one that wasn’t. It’s very true that he’s naive, but it’s equally true to say that - for the first half today - it was going well. 

I agree that the MJ decision was odd. But see out the erstwhile result with XI on the pitch and it isn’t even a talking point. All what-ifs. 

But even the much-revered CC found it difficult. This time last year we couldn’t seem to buy a win. And besides being light up top, he almost had too many options.

I harbour as many doubts about RM as anyone. But I still think just sacking him isn’t the answer, yet. Today was a difficult game even with XI, and there really isn’t anyone out there I think could be doing much better. He has to start getting some more wins on the board; that is an absolute must. But calling for his head today… I don’t think we’re quite there just yet.

(11-22-2025, 03:28 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote:
(11-22-2025, 03:13 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Why would a load of championship players, a Scandinavian and one from League one be in Premier Laegue wages? As you say, unless we know the details we can’t really speculate.

I agree that perhaps not enough attention was paid to the midfield in the summer, and the Heggebø fee was significant. But none of the are particularly massive signings.

Gilchrist, Mepham and Philips were all signed from Premier League clubs, hence my comment about Premier Leage wages

True, but I doubt any are breaking the bank.
Reply
#20
(11-22-2025, 02:54 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(11-22-2025, 02:50 PM)CIM Wrote: For all the good in the 1st half why did Mason take MJ off? And why only respond with subs when we were 3-2 down? Poor game management becoming a consistent theme

MJ must have been injured? Not even Mason is that tactically incompetent.

I thought it was great tactics - For Lampard!  Angry
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: