Big Dave
#11
Jones an easy scapegoat. Are people blaming Gibbs this season? Did people blame Bruce's assistant? Or Vals?
I didn't say Big Dave did a bad job for us. I just don't think he's a great manager.
But I guess we can all pick the bones out of that.
Reply
#12
He signed Bartley and tried to turn him into John Stones.
Reply
#13
Big Dave can always pull irons out of the fire. Just ask Peterborough. He would have done it with us in the PL if there were just 2 or 3 more games remaining before the trapdoor opened.

He motivates players and plays football to win the game. I think vale should remain patient. Didn't they give him a massive length contract anyway?

His weaknesses were playing to the nuances of G.Jones 'pissing about at the back' and a lack of detail and insight and meaningful info in interviews. However, if you contrast that with the ideological bollockology of T.Mowbray, the vanilla responses of R.Mason and the 'roll wor sleeves up, I've managed 1000 games dontcha know' from captain steak bake then he's he's not alone in that weakness!

I wish him the very best at PV.
Reply
#14
(11-09-2025, 04:16 PM)CIM Wrote: Jones an easy scapegoat. Are people blaming Gibbs this season? Did people blame Bruce's assistant? Or Vals?
I didn't say Big Dave did a bad job for us. I just don't think he's a great manager.
But I guess we can all pick the bones out of that.

There were plenty of rumblings at the time about the players not being happy about the system and it being very much Jones’ doing - Moore left a lot of the game play to Jones, as he has Shan previously. It was fairly well publicised that prior to his sacking Moore was given the option to remove Jones and he didn’t.

That hasn’t happened with other managers, that’s why they’re not given the same excuse.
Reply
#15
(11-09-2025, 02:48 PM)CIM Wrote:
(11-09-2025, 02:45 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(11-09-2025, 02:41 PM)CIM Wrote: Love Big Dave. But he really isn’t a very good manager

Based on what?
He did a brilliant job at Wednesday.
And IMO for us too.
He also got Vale promoted a few months ago.

Failed to get a side with Barnes, Gayle, J Rod etc promoted. Slav had a weaker side the following season. Ask what Huddersfield fans think 

Don't agree with this.

Moore didn't have a midfield fit for purpose, too many old injury prone players, and an illustration disciplined Livermore(that season) and some inexperienced academy players.

Barnes was outstanding, but he left half way through season. Bilic at least had Pereria throughout the season.
Reply
#16
Huddersfield are now in League One and show no signs of being promoted any time soon: they are not a well-run club. Everywhere else he's managed, he's left in a better state then when he started and yes, I include us in that category because we were in a terrible, terrible mess when he took over and it is entirely fair to say we would have been like Stoke without his work and connections.

He's not a big talker in post-match interviews and people mistake that for a lack of football intelligence and coaching nous.
Reply
#17
(11-09-2025, 02:41 PM)CIM Wrote: Love Big Dave. But he really isn’t a very good manager

He's got a managerial career win rate of over 43% and that's come from managing a lot of basket case clubs. It's actually higher than Corberan's and Rob Edwards, both of whom are highly regarded. so not sure what you're basing your thought on?
Reply
#18
(11-09-2025, 05:54 PM)MrBater Wrote:
(11-09-2025, 02:41 PM)CIM Wrote: Love Big Dave. But he really isn’t a very good manager

He's got a managerial career win rate of over 43% and that's come from managing a lot of basket case clubs. It's actually higher than Corberan's and Rob Edwards, both of whom are highly regarded. so not sure what you're basing your thought on?

That's interesting. I don't think he is a bad manager, but I I'm surprised his win rate is that high. It feels like he has failed at a few clubs, and is sacked relatively quickly after being appointed, but that's just the modern game and most managers end up being sacked, don't they!
Reply
#19
(11-09-2025, 06:12 PM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(11-09-2025, 05:54 PM)MrBater Wrote:
(11-09-2025, 02:41 PM)CIM Wrote: Love Big Dave. But he really isn’t a very good manager

He's got a managerial career win rate of over 43% and that's come from managing a lot of basket case clubs. It's actually higher than Corberan's and Rob Edwards, both of whom are highly regarded. so not sure what you're basing your thought on?

That's interesting. I don't think he is a bad manager, but I I'm surprised his win rate is that high. It feels like he has failed at a few clubs, and is sacked relatively quickly after being appointed, but that's just the modern game and most managers end up being sacked, don't they!

He somehow got a 51% win ratio with Wednesday! Which does skew his number up a fair bit...think he was over 40% with us too.
Reply
#20
He left Wednesday having just got them up because their owner was a barmpot. He did poorly at Huddersfield but then they've only got worse since and he's done OK at Vale. They've taken a couple of thumpings but it's their first season in a new league. His record is better than loads of managers who are considered highly competent.

His tendency to trade in meaningless aphorisms in interviews means he doesn't come across all that well but by any stretch he's at least in the 50th percentile of league managers.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: