10-23-2025, 10:14 AM
Must admit I thought Gilchrist did ok for his first match, he also never let his overlapping player reach the byline like his replacement did. My MoM was Mowatt but no one was anywhere near there best.
|
Ray Tings
|
|
10-23-2025, 10:14 AM
Must admit I thought Gilchrist did ok for his first match, he also never let his overlapping player reach the byline like his replacement did. My MoM was Mowatt but no one was anywhere near there best.
10-23-2025, 10:26 AM
Mine as follows, tbh I thought we were lucky to get away with just the odd goal defeat particularly in the 2nd half, it really was that bad
Griff - 6 Gilchrist - 4 Phillips - 5 Mepham - 5 Styles - 5 Mowatt - 6 Diakite - 6.5 SIJ - 4 Price - 5 Mikey - 7 Heggebo - 4 Grant - 3 Dike - 5 Maja - 5 Taylor - 4 Campbell - 2
10-23-2025, 10:48 AM
Only players who came out with any credit for me were Johnstone who at least tried all game to make things happen, Price for that finish and Griffiths who couldn't really be faulted for either goal.
Rest were varying levels of shite.
10-23-2025, 10:53 AM
I'm just thinking about individual performances, and I'm struggling to match individual performances to the team performance. In my head not one player was atrociously poor, lots of average performances, but nothing too bad. Yet the team performance was abysmal from 20mins onwards.
I know that's a bit weird to say, but that's how I'm reflecting on the performance.
10-23-2025, 10:57 AM
(10-23-2025, 10:53 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I'm just thinking about individual performances, and I'm struggling to match individual performances to the team performance. In my head not one player was atrociously poor, lots of average performances, but nothing too bad. Yet the team performance was abysmal from 20mins onwards. Exactly the thought I had when I was doing the scores. I’d give the overall team performance a 4 tops
Raw Sausage
10-23-2025, 11:00 AM
(10-23-2025, 10:53 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I'm just thinking about individual performances, and I'm struggling to match individual performances to the team performance. In my head not one player was atrociously poor, lots of average performances, but nothing too bad. Yet the team performance was abysmal from 20mins onwards. I see where you're coming from but also depends on how to mark player. Generally they will gain or lose marks by individual moments let's say. However, a striker might get a low mark because of lack of shots on goal/goals but if they make a run 10 times and don't get it once they can't gain anything in that scenario. In my mind those runs were not made last night in a number of areas (and subsequent runs off them) which means that even if a player was steady enough in possession or defensively sound they might get a decent mark but actually should be marked down because they didn't contribute enough offesively. I think.
10-23-2025, 11:05 AM
(10-23-2025, 11:00 AM)Fido Wrote:(10-23-2025, 10:53 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I'm just thinking about individual performances, and I'm struggling to match individual performances to the team performance. In my head not one player was atrociously poor, lots of average performances, but nothing too bad. Yet the team performance was abysmal from 20mins onwards. We were so static when in possession it was painful. Johnstone and Mowatt constantly having to hold onto the ball because simple runs to create passing options weren’t being made. That aspect was just appalling
Raw Sausage
10-23-2025, 11:16 AM
Griffiths 7
Gilchrist 4 Phillips 5 Mepham 5 Styles 5 Diakite 6.5 Mowatt 6 SIJ 5 Price 6 MJ 7 Heggebø 4 Campbell 4 Grant 3 Maja 5 Dike 6 Taylor 4
10-23-2025, 11:26 AM
(10-23-2025, 10:48 AM)Duffers Wrote: Only players who came out with any credit for me were Johnstone who at least tried all game to make things happen, Price for that finish and Griffiths who couldn't really be faulted for either goal. Personally thought Diakite did ok
10-23-2025, 11:48 AM
(This post was last modified: 10-23-2025, 11:49 AM by richbaggie.)
Pretty much how I saw it TGD. Probably had Diakite just about man of match but it was a low bar 35 minutes onwards.
I have seen Gilchrist get some stick and I am not sure why. He shanked a couple of passes down the line but I thought he defended ok until he went over on his ankle and I thought he looked assured and worth sticking with if and when fit again. My own onions Griffiths 6 Gilchrist 6 Styles 5.5 Mepham 5 Phillips 5 Mowatt 6.5 Daikite 6.6 He was very good first half, tailed off 2nd like the rest. SIJ 4 DVB mode Price 6 (5 but for the moment of magic) Heggebo - 4 His worst game for us. I like the lad but if he doesn't put a shift in, he offers nothing. For the 1st time, I didn't see him put a shift in last night. Johnston 6 - Tried but Watford didn't give him the same space that Preston did and he was less effective as a result Subs Grant - 1 just for tying his shoelaces up correctly. Absolutely shocking lack of care and effort. Maja - 4 something just not right with him. A shadow of this time last year. Dike - 5 Plenty of effort but little service that suits him Campbell - 3 Oh dear. I actually feel for him as he would have made a decent CH back up but I think fans have washed their hands of him because Mason has exposed him for too long in a position that clearly doesn't suit him. Taylor - 5 When is Alex Williams fit again? |
|
« Next Oldest | Next Newest »
|