This needs to be the routine response
#11
10 year plan says

"Deconstruct block contracts - paid irrespective of how many patients are seen or how good care is - with the intention of realigning the activity delivered and funding being provided by an ICB. Payment for poor-quality care will be withheld and high-quality care will attract a bonus"
Reply
#12
(07-03-2025, 11:29 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote: Maybe it might focus their attention somewhat?

I am not picking on NHS here. I've posted this before.

Mmm accountability?
Post Office, Blood, Windrush.....that's just recently.

1966 Aberfan 116 children 28 adults died no charges no convictions
1972 Battersea big dipper 5 deaths 2 charges of manslaughter no convictions
1981 stardust fire 48 deaths no charges no convictions
1985 Bradford City fire 56 deaths no charges no convictions
1987 zeebrugge ferry 193 deaths 7 people charged with negligence, company charged with corporate manslaughter. No convictions
1988 piper alpha 167 deaths. No charges no convictions
1989 marchioness 51 deaths 1 charge no convictions
1989 Hillsborough 96 deaths 6 charges 35 years later, no convictions
2004 stockline explosion 9 deaths no charges no convictions
2017 grenfell 72 deaths no convictions



Yet there have been massive health and safety improvements in all those sectors, as the fact that all of your listed events except two took place over 35 years ago indicates.

Having people working in a high-pressure environment such as healthcare, where all registered professionals already have the sanction of being barred from practice against them, now facing the risk of being sent to prison...the only minds it might focus is deciding to work elsewhere.

And no, that won't mean that only the brightest and best are left in the profession. It means you will be left with the mediocre. Which is clearly already happening in mental health, judging from the case you linked. Unit Managers should be the best of the best and recruitment should very competitive, that such impressive individuals are operating at that level will not be remedied by the threat of imprisonment.
Reply
#13
Grenfell , post office, blood, windrush weren't 35 years ago
My point is that nothing changes because we don't hold people accountable as a society. We will inevitably see more inquiries into the deaths of children. Proth, of course, will blame the social workers who he so despises but it is much bigger than that. It's almost engrained in UK culture that some scandal happens and society goes "oh well". it took a tv programme on the post office before anyone was bothered. And now they are making only glacial progress in paying people out, same with blood.
As ever, you make a very considered and thoughtful post. Maybe my way wouldn't work. But the current status quo is simply unacceptable.
Reply
#14
You are not comparing like with like. The infected blood scandal is concerning events that happened in the 70s to early 90s.

Windrush was not a health and safety issue, it was a government
eager to boost their deportation figures.

How can you look at the average football stadium and say "nothing ever changes". Society does not say "oh well". To pretend that everything is the same until the 1970s is nonsense.

Interesting you mention social workers, but you seem to think that they should be spared prison, whereas people that that work in hospitals deserve to see the inside of a prison cell.
Reply
#15
I'm rather mystified as although I started off on the abject paucity of NHS accountability, I have explained that it is bigger than this and I'm not just getting at NHS staff. If extend it to the whole of public and private sectors. It isn't me looking through a lens of health of safety either....it is about accountability. If, in the course of your work -whatever that work is - you are negligent, incompetent, incapable, asleep on the job, etc. that you cause death to people then imo you should be accountable for that. Misconduct in public office would be one route, corporate manslaughter another, gross negligence manslaughter another.

Registered health professionals are accountable through their bodies in the NHS as you say but many NHS managers are not registered at all, because they don't need to be and didn't come up through that route.

Here's another example of where the right conclusion was reached.

https://news.sky.com/story/summer-grant-...h-11358274


As for the blood scandal, you are right it has been kicking around for decades now. And people still aren't being paid out. Which adds weight to my point that the government dont give a damn.

An i mentioned social workers because they always get the blame, when inquiries usually say that the police, health visitors, probation, teachers, GPs, etc  all had chances to do something.

There have been 40 prosecutions for corporate manslaughter in England between 2011 and 2023, of these 29 resulted in guilty verdicts.
The bar is much too high. The mediocrity that you fear is already here.

I've enjoyed discussing this with you but realise I am now at risk of being a member of the hang em and flog em brigade. So I won't dig in any further lest I start reading the Daily Express. My basic point is, once you take the role, the status, the pay, you also have to take the responsibility and accountability. Too many happy to take the first 3 but not the last 2.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)