Horrific stats
#11
(04-26-2025, 08:14 PM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: The most important thing is the end of the season allows a reset.
This season was always going to be tough.
Selling Fellows and reinvestment in the squad with a fired up coach allows some optimism despite the crap of the past few weeks.
If we’d not had that good start we could be looking at relegation.
Most of us knew promotion was unlikely so we start again with hope come August.

Not really much hope as things stand.
Selling our best players potentially weakens us further unless we get lucky with recruitment.
We will still be left a lot of average champ players.
Also, we hope that Styles will be a top championships left back but he’s looks like a headless chicken in too many games, shocking today again.
Also, concerns about two of our great new hopes.
Diakate looks very hit and miss but needs games.
Price can look very good and clueless in a single game and needs some real coaching and guidance to settle into a stable position.
Never wanted an Albion player to succeed with us as much as Dike but have real doubts he can be the goalscoring striker we are desperate for.
Reply
#12
(04-26-2025, 09:42 PM)EastMidsBaggie Wrote:
(04-26-2025, 08:14 PM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: The most important thing is the end of the season allows a reset.
This season was always going to be tough.
Selling Fellows and reinvestment in the squad with a fired up coach allows some optimism despite the crap of the past few weeks.
If we’d not had that good start we could be looking at relegation.
Most of us knew promotion was unlikely so we start again with hope come August.

Not really much hope as things stand.
Selling our best players potentially weakens us further unless we get lucky with recruitment.
We will still be left a lot of average champ players.
Also, we hope that Styles will be a top championships left back but he’s looks like a headless chicken in too many games, shocking today again.
Also, concerns about two of our great new hopes.
Diakate looks very hit and miss but needs games.
Price can look very good and clueless in a single game and needs some real coaching and guidance to settle into a stable position.
Never wanted an Albion player to succeed with us as much as Dike but have real doubts he can be the goalscoring striker we are desperate for.
Things don’t stand. Never have done. Life changes. Keep the faith.
Reply
#13
(04-26-2025, 08:52 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(04-26-2025, 07:37 PM)Albionmad Wrote: So TM was abject. I think CC is getting a free pass here.
He was what we needed after Bruce no question.

He was great in making us hard to beat and the players knew their roles.
However we turned wins into draws all too often.

He's a great coach under adversity as he's currently proving with Valencia.

I'm not convinced that we'd have been promoted if he'd stayed.
Along with others I wanted him to release the handbrake somewhat.

There's no such thing as 'releasing the handbrake' in football, it's another lazy phrase said by pundits paid too much to say too little 

The first rule of football tactics is stop goals going in, prevent opposition playing unless you are significantly better than they are, we aren't that level, our job will always be to stop the opposition, then see if we can score goals. 

Under CC we had hit a really weird place where we could pretty much stop the opposition bar a lapse in judgment or a fluke, but we could never score more than one ourselves, no matter how how much we played in the oppositions third. Since even with his coaching our defence would have a brainfart or we'd be unlucky and a fluke would go in.

I've said a few times, we always looked far more likely to turn draws into wins, which is why I never turned against him, he was painfully unlucky in a lot of ways. Had he just decided to give up the shape, chances are we'd have conceded more without scoring more, so lost games.

We had started to turn a corner his last few games, we have lost a lot less and won far more under him had he stayed, I'm certain of it.

I agree with most of that, particularly the last bit.
Reply
#14
I find the notion that we wouldn't have made the play offs under CC illogical. People like to focus on the 3 wins in 16 stat but ignore the results in the last 8 of those. 3 wins, 4 draws and 1 defeat in a difficult run of games including draws with Sunderland away, Sheff utd at home and comfortable wins against Bristol and Cov. We may have been 7th when he fucked off but on equal points with 6th and 3 points off 5th.

The trajectory was forward. He was finding a way. He would have dealt better with the Maja injury, not mishandled the keeper situation so badly and benefited from the window.

There's not a cat in hells chance we'd have collapsed and become an absolute state of a club like we have done. It wouldn't have been pretty. People will have moaned, but we would have taken on 5 or 6 more points at least and finished the job next week.

Why am I so certain? Because CC is a bloody good coach. Every bit of evidence we've seen in his career so far has shown that.
Reply
#15
(04-27-2025, 07:54 AM)richbaggie Wrote: I find the notion that we wouldn't have made the play offs under CC illogical. People like to focus on the 3 wins in 16 stat but ignore the results in the last 8 of those. 3 wins, 4 draws and 1 defeat in a difficult run of games including draws with Sunderland away, Sheff utd at home and comfortable wins against Bristol and Cov. We may have been 7th when he fucked off but on equal points with 6th and 3 points off 5th.

The trajectory was forward. He was finding a way. He would have dealt better with the Maja injury, not mishandled the keeper situation so badly and benefited from the window.

There's not a cat in hells chance we'd have collapsed and become an absolute state of a club like we have done. It wouldn't have been pretty. People will have moaned, but we would have taken on 5 or 6 more points at least  and finished the job next week.

Why am I so certain? Because CC is a bloody good coach. Every bit of evidence we've seen in his career so far has shown that.

It's all irrelevant - he fucked off. The relevant bit is replacing him with a disaster
Reply
#16
It becomes logical when you consider the cult of Mowbray is strong with some on here. Easier to just think it’s because the squad is lazy, and poor than it is question their belief TM wasn’t the quality of manager they thought he was,
Reply
#17
(04-27-2025, 07:57 AM)strawman Wrote:
(04-27-2025, 07:54 AM)richbaggie Wrote: I find the notion that we wouldn't have made the play offs under CC illogical. People like to focus on the 3 wins in 16 stat but ignore the results in the last 8 of those. 3 wins, 4 draws and 1 defeat in a difficult run of games including draws with Sunderland away, Sheff utd at home and comfortable wins against Bristol and Cov. We may have been 7th when he fucked off but on equal points with 6th and 3 points off 5th.

The trajectory was forward. He was finding a way. He would have dealt better with the Maja injury, not mishandled the keeper situation so badly and benefited from the window.

There's not a cat in hells chance we'd have collapsed and become an absolute state of a club like we have done. It wouldn't have been pretty. People will have moaned, but we would have taken on 5 or 6 more points at least  and finished the job next week.

Why am I so certain? Because CC is a bloody good coach. Every bit of evidence we've seen in his career so far has shown that.

It's all irrelevant - he fucked off. The relevant bit is replacing him with a disaster

It's a debate around the squad and whether it's good enough, so not irrelevant at all.
Reply
#18
(04-27-2025, 08:05 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(04-27-2025, 07:57 AM)strawman Wrote:
(04-27-2025, 07:54 AM)richbaggie Wrote: I find the notion that we wouldn't have made the play offs under CC illogical. People like to focus on the 3 wins in 16 stat but ignore the results in the last 8 of those. 3 wins, 4 draws and 1 defeat in a difficult run of games including draws with Sunderland away, Sheff utd at home and comfortable wins against Bristol and Cov. We may have been 7th when he fucked off but on equal points with 6th and 3 points off 5th.

The trajectory was forward. He was finding a way. He would have dealt better with the Maja injury, not mishandled the keeper situation so badly and benefited from the window.

There's not a cat in hells chance we'd have collapsed and become an absolute state of a club like we have done. It wouldn't have been pretty. People will have moaned, but we would have taken on 5 or 6 more points at least  and finished the job next week.

Why am I so certain? Because CC is a bloody good coach. Every bit of evidence we've seen in his career so far has shown that.

It's all irrelevant - he fucked off. The relevant bit is replacing him with a disaster

It's a debate around the squad and whether it's good enough, so not irrelevant at all.

But the stat about Corberan is irrelevant, because no one will ever know if Corberan would have kept us up.
As strawman says he fucked off.
Reply
#19
(04-27-2025, 08:47 AM)wba13 Wrote:
(04-27-2025, 08:05 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(04-27-2025, 07:57 AM)strawman Wrote:
(04-27-2025, 07:54 AM)richbaggie Wrote: I find the notion that we wouldn't have made the play offs under CC illogical. People like to focus on the 3 wins in 16 stat but ignore the results in the last 8 of those. 3 wins, 4 draws and 1 defeat in a difficult run of games including draws with Sunderland away, Sheff utd at home and comfortable wins against Bristol and Cov. We may have been 7th when he fucked off but on equal points with 6th and 3 points off 5th.

The trajectory was forward. He was finding a way. He would have dealt better with the Maja injury, not mishandled the keeper situation so badly and benefited from the window.

There's not a cat in hells chance we'd have collapsed and become an absolute state of a club like we have done. It wouldn't have been pretty. People will have moaned, but we would have taken on 5 or 6 more points at least  and finished the job next week.

Why am I so certain? Because CC is a bloody good coach. Every bit of evidence we've seen in his career so far has shown that.

It's all irrelevant - he fucked off. The relevant bit is replacing him with a disaster

It's a debate around the squad and whether it's good enough, so not irrelevant at all.

But the stat about Corberan is irrelevant, because no one will ever know if Corberan would have kept us up.
As strawman says he fucked off.

The debate is around if this squad is good enough for a play off place. Looking at stats when he was in charge compared to TM are complete relevant when assessing if a squad was capable or not. It ay rocket science.
Reply
#20
Would CC have got us into or won the playoffs, i'm not sure we will never know but he would have undoubtedly made a better fist of it from new year than TM did. What i am sure of is the drop off in form of some off our players has been nothing short of astounding and this isnt down to just poor coaching its a mental attitude thing and until we start to get players in that have something to prove or trying to make a name for themselves and get some leaders on the pitch and change the mind set we will continue to go around in ever decreasing circles, also  as has been said a good coach who takes no crap and who's methods the players buy into helps enormously as given half a chance some players will slack off continually as has been proved imho.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: