What was the plan?
#11
(03-31-2025, 11:53 AM)Jerry Wrote: Let’s take into account the fact that Norwich switch to a back three, played in a defensive formation with players behind the balls and relying on a quick break to nick a goal. They even kept fast players to bring on at the end. This was a major difference to there normal play where they score and concede goals. If fully fit MJ and Price should have played with us being more direct. Norwich game plan worked and they mugged us, that is football.

What, you mean the opposition have their own game plan, and don't roll over and let us take all 3 points? Ridiculous.
Reply
#12
(03-31-2025, 11:50 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(03-31-2025, 09:53 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Theres been quite a widespread condemnation of the tactical performance of ToMo on Saturday. But there are still a substantial number in his corner. A question to those people if you please? 

What was the plan v Norwich for us to score goals? What was the tactical approach?

Can anybody enlighten those of us who are scratching our heads?

To say there wasn't a plan is incorrect. We controlled the game. I believe the tactics was to pass, pass, pass, maintain possession and draw Norwich out and then utilise that space to create chances. 

It may not have worked like that, but I can at least see organisation and some form of tactics in recent weeks. Compare how we played Saturday, and how we've been playing since Leeds away to TM's first few games and it's night and day. Those first 5/6 games were a complete shambles, a disorganised mess, and frankly unacceptable. We've improved a lot since then. 

I get the disappointment of defeat but let's not say there were no tactics and it was a poor performance. It wasn't poor.

With you on this Josh. Throughout the stream I watched, the Norwich commentators were constantly stating thar we had controlled the game and were the better team. That's pretty much how I saw it. We didn't deserve to lose, but didn't really do enough to win. This is the story for quite a few games this season, hence the higher number of draws.

The big issue on Saturday was the lack of a goal threat. That for me is down to the continued selection of Armstrong who is just not doing enough at present, and needs to be benched. If we are to play with two wide men, then give them something to try and hit.

I still don't think we're too far away, but Mowbray does need to make a couple of attacking calls around the number 9 and 10 positions. Armstrong and Swift are not the answer at the moment.
Reply
#13
(03-31-2025, 12:41 PM)ElbowGrease1973 II Wrote:
(03-31-2025, 11:50 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(03-31-2025, 09:53 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Theres been quite a widespread condemnation of the tactical performance of ToMo on Saturday. But there are still a substantial number in his corner. A question to those people if you please? 

What was the plan v Norwich for us to score goals? What was the tactical approach?

Can anybody enlighten those of us who are scratching our heads?

To say there wasn't a plan is incorrect. We controlled the game. I believe the tactics was to pass, pass, pass, maintain possession and draw Norwich out and then utilise that space to create chances. 

It may not have worked like that, but I can at least see organisation and some form of tactics in recent weeks. Compare how we played Saturday, and how we've been playing since Leeds away to TM's first few games and it's night and day. Those first 5/6 games were a complete shambles, a disorganised mess, and frankly unacceptable. We've improved a lot since then. 

I get the disappointment of defeat but let's not say there were no tactics and it was a poor performance. It wasn't poor.

With you on this Josh. Throughout the stream I watched, the Norwich commentators were constantly stating thar we had controlled the game and were the better team. That's pretty much how I saw it. We didn't deserve to lose, but didn't really do enough to win. This is the story for quite a few games this season, hence the higher number of draws.

The big issue on Saturday was the lack of a goal threat. That for me is down to the continued selection of Armstrong who is just not doing enough at present, and needs to be benched. If we are to play with two wide men, then give them something to try and hit.

I still don't think we're too far away, but Mowbray does need to make a couple of attacking calls around the number 9 and 10 positions. Armstrong and Swift are not the answer at the moment.
Exactly, the plan was clearly to keep possession and protect the defence, which we did very well, restricting Norwich to very few chances. The problem is, and has been since way before TM arrived, to do this we need someone who can pick a pass and we still don't. Neither Swift nor Mowatt can do it on a regular basis, so the forwards become starved and the ball goes side to side.
I'm happy to criticise TM for the lack of reaction and some strange subs, but to say there is no plan is just plain wrong and verging on childish now. If I could be bothered, I'm sure I could find a game that played out identically for CC and also for Cov, Bristol City, Boro, Blackburn or, indeed, Norwich. 
If we had got a point, it would have been a solid, pragmatic performance and, in the context of other results, a very valuable one. As it was we were hit with a sucker punch because Swift gave away a lazy ball.

I'm no happy clapper and am happy to criticise, and read the criticism of others, but it's just getting a bit silly now with it turning into a character assassination of Mowbray, which, with 8 games to go serves no purpose. Other than to maybe boost a few egos.

What some need to remember is the goal, and that is promotion, so, if we get to Wembley and win, despite not playing that great, will you be screaming "Fuck yes" or "Well that was still shit"? There's 11 games maximum to go so I just want us to get over the line. therefore find these threads a bit daft. 

There'll be more than enough time for these conversations if we don't make it, trust me.
Reply
#14
(03-31-2025, 10:17 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(03-31-2025, 10:08 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(03-31-2025, 09:53 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Theres been quite a widespread condemnation of the tactical performance of ToMo on Saturday. But there are still a substantial number in his corner. A question to those people if you please? 

What was the plan v Norwich for us to score goals? What was the tactical approach?

Can anybody enlighten those of us who are scratching our heads?

Why would any true Albion fan not be in his corner? FFS Sake.

Poorly worded... Fair cop. I meant a substantial number of fans who still think he's doing a decent job. 

The questions still remains though  Big Grin
I’m out of the loop compared to you lot, but hadn’t you been on a decent run and if he wasn’t doing an ok job why do these threads appear after a defeat?
Reply
#15
(03-31-2025, 01:24 PM)KRO Wrote:
(03-31-2025, 10:17 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(03-31-2025, 10:08 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(03-31-2025, 09:53 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Theres been quite a widespread condemnation of the tactical performance of ToMo on Saturday. But there are still a substantial number in his corner. A question to those people if you please? 

What was the plan v Norwich for us to score goals? What was the tactical approach?

Can anybody enlighten those of us who are scratching our heads?

Why would any true Albion fan not be in his corner? FFS Sake.

Poorly worded... Fair cop. I meant a substantial number of fans who still think he's doing a decent job. 

The questions still remains though  Big Grin
I’m out of the loop compared to you lot, but hadn’t you been on a decent run and if he wasn’t doing an ok job why do these threads appear after a defeat?

I think my opinions on ToMo have been pretty consistent to be fair, KRO. But, posting negative things when we've won is even more poorly received than when we've lost  Big Grin
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#16
(03-31-2025, 09:53 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Theres been quite a widespread condemnation of the tactical performance of ToMo on Saturday. But there are still a substantial number in his corner. A question to those people if you please? 

What was the plan v Norwich for us to score goals? What was the tactical approach?

Can anybody enlighten those of us who are scratching our heads?

Lurk, you present yourself as the stats guru - your analyses are presented as fact not opinion and tbf it can get boring. But your new persona, challenging posters "in Mowbray's corner" to tell you something you don't already know is even more daft.

Most people watch the games, hope for good results, grumble, criticize or just generally express their views when results aren't good, then wait for the next match. There's no need to be "in a corner" with the manager or against him. What difference does it make whether we've convinced ourselves that he's failing? We'll only know if he's succeeded at the end of the season.

The risk you take is that folk will think you want Mowbray (and the Albion) to fail so you can be proved right. it's not a good look.
Reply
#17
(03-31-2025, 01:34 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(03-31-2025, 01:24 PM)KRO Wrote:
(03-31-2025, 10:17 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(03-31-2025, 10:08 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(03-31-2025, 09:53 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Theres been quite a widespread condemnation of the tactical performance of ToMo on Saturday. But there are still a substantial number in his corner. A question to those people if you please? 

What was the plan v Norwich for us to score goals? What was the tactical approach?

Can anybody enlighten those of us who are scratching our heads?

Why would any true Albion fan not be in his corner? FFS Sake.

Poorly worded... Fair cop. I meant a substantial number of fans who still think he's doing a decent job. 

The questions still remains though  Big Grin
I’m out of the loop compared to you lot, but hadn’t you been on a decent run and if he wasn’t doing an ok job why do these threads appear after a defeat?

I think my opinions on ToMo have been pretty consistent to be fair, KRO. But, posting negative things when we've won is even more poorly received than when we've lost  Big Grin

Haha. GPWM
Reply
#18
(03-31-2025, 01:37 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(03-31-2025, 09:53 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Theres been quite a widespread condemnation of the tactical performance of ToMo on Saturday. But there are still a substantial number in his corner. A question to those people if you please? 

What was the plan v Norwich for us to score goals? What was the tactical approach?

Can anybody enlighten those of us who are scratching our heads?

Lurk, you present yourself as the stats guru - your analyses are presented as fact not opinion and tbf it can get boring. But your new persona, challenging posters "in Mowbray's corner" to tell you something you don't already know is even more daft.

Most people watch the games, hope for good results, grumble, criticize or just generally express their views when results aren't good, then wait for the next match. There's no need to be "in a corner" with the manager or against him. What difference does it make whether we've convinced ourselves that he's failing? We'll only know if he's succeeded at the end of the season.

The risk you take is that folk will think you want Mowbray (and the Albion) to fail so you can be proved right. it's not a good look.

Fair enough, Chesh. FWIW, I don't try and present myself as anything intentionally, I just try discuss the game in a way that explains the lens I view it through, that might be different to most, and if you, or others find it boring I wont take it personally if nobody engages. 

This fred, and the, perhaps clumsily asked question was a genuine attempt to get peoples insights and opinions. I have consistently said since he returned that I like ToMo personally, he is also in my top 3 managers from my time watching us, so there is no case of me being against him, I just happen to think he's doing a shit job. I was hoping somebody could point me towards something to be positive about, and to do that I had to direct the question to those who think he's doing well.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#19
(03-31-2025, 01:18 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(03-31-2025, 12:41 PM)ElbowGrease1973 II Wrote:
(03-31-2025, 11:50 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(03-31-2025, 09:53 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Theres been quite a widespread condemnation of the tactical performance of ToMo on Saturday. But there are still a substantial number in his corner. A question to those people if you please? 

What was the plan v Norwich for us to score goals? What was the tactical approach?

Can anybody enlighten those of us who are scratching our heads?

To say there wasn't a plan is incorrect. We controlled the game. I believe the tactics was to pass, pass, pass, maintain possession and draw Norwich out and then utilise that space to create chances. 

It may not have worked like that, but I can at least see organisation and some form of tactics in recent weeks. Compare how we played Saturday, and how we've been playing since Leeds away to TM's first few games and it's night and day. Those first 5/6 games were a complete shambles, a disorganised mess, and frankly unacceptable. We've improved a lot since then. 

I get the disappointment of defeat but let's not say there were no tactics and it was a poor performance. It wasn't poor.

With you on this Josh. Throughout the stream I watched, the Norwich commentators were constantly stating thar we had controlled the game and were the better team. That's pretty much how I saw it. We didn't deserve to lose, but didn't really do enough to win. This is the story for quite a few games this season, hence the higher number of draws.

The big issue on Saturday was the lack of a goal threat. That for me is down to the continued selection of Armstrong who is just not doing enough at present, and needs to be benched. If we are to play with two wide men, then give them something to try and hit.

I still don't think we're too far away, but Mowbray does need to make a couple of attacking calls around the number 9 and 10 positions. Armstrong and Swift are not the answer at the moment.
Exactly, the plan was clearly to keep possession and protect the defence, which we did very well, restricting Norwich to very few chances. The problem is, and has been since way before TM arrived, to do this we need someone who can pick a pass and we still don't. Neither Swift nor Mowatt can do it on a regular basis, so the forwards become starved and the ball goes side to side.
I'm happy to criticise TM for the lack of reaction and some strange subs, but to say there is no plan is just plain wrong and verging on childish now. If I could be bothered, I'm sure I could find a game that played out identically for CC and also for Cov, Bristol City, Boro, Blackburn or, indeed, Norwich. 
If we had got a point, it would have been a solid, pragmatic performance and, in the context of other results, a very valuable one. As it was we were hit with a sucker punch because Swift gave away a lazy ball.

I'm no happy clapper and am happy to criticise, and read the criticism of others, but it's just getting a bit silly now with it turning into a character assassination of Mowbray, which, with 8 games to go serves no purpose. Other than to maybe boost a few egos.

What some need to remember is the goal, and that is promotion, so, if we get to Wembley and win, despite not playing that great, will you be screaming "Fuck yes" or "Well that was still shit"? There's 11 games maximum to go so I just want us to get over the line. therefore find these threads a bit daft. 

There'll be more than enough time for these conversations if we don't make it, trust me.

Josh, Bob and EG agree entirely. 
Football wise it was a decent performance. Don't know why Dike wasn't on earlier or even starting, especially the amount of crosses we put in.
Reply
#20
(03-31-2025, 11:50 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(03-31-2025, 09:53 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Theres been quite a widespread condemnation of the tactical performance of ToMo on Saturday. But there are still a substantial number in his corner. A question to those people if you please? 

What was the plan v Norwich for us to score goals? What was the tactical approach?

Can anybody enlighten those of us who are scratching our heads?

To say there wasn't a plan is incorrect. We controlled the game. I believe the tactics was to pass, pass, pass, maintain possession and draw Norwich out and then utilise that space to create chances. 

It may not have worked like that, but I can at least see organisation and some form of tactics in recent weeks. Compare how we played Saturday, and how we've been playing since Leeds away to TM's first few games and it's night and day. Those first 5/6 games were a complete shambles, a disorganised mess, and frankly unacceptable. We've improved a lot since then. 

I get the disappointment of defeat but let's not say there were no tactics and it was a poor performance. It wasn't poor.

(03-31-2025, 03:00 PM)1952 Wrote:
(03-31-2025, 01:18 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(03-31-2025, 12:41 PM)ElbowGrease1973 II Wrote:
(03-31-2025, 11:50 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(03-31-2025, 09:53 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Theres been quite a widespread condemnation of the tactical performance of ToMo on Saturday. But there are still a substantial number in his corner. A question to those people if you please? 

What was the plan v Norwich for us to score goals? What was the tactical approach?

Can anybody enlighten those of us who are scratching our heads?

To say there wasn't a plan is incorrect. We controlled the game. I believe the tactics was to pass, pass, pass, maintain possession and draw Norwich out and then utilise that space to create chances. 

It may not have worked like that, but I can at least see organisation and some form of tactics in recent weeks. Compare how we played Saturday, and how we've been playing since Leeds away to TM's first few games and it's night and day. Those first 5/6 games were a complete shambles, a disorganised mess, and frankly unacceptable. We've improved a lot since then. 

I get the disappointment of defeat but let's not say there were no tactics and it was a poor performance. It wasn't poor.

With you on this Josh. Throughout the stream I watched, the Norwich commentators were constantly stating thar we had controlled the game and were the better team. That's pretty much how I saw it. We didn't deserve to lose, but didn't really do enough to win. This is the story for quite a few games this season, hence the higher number of draws.

The big issue on Saturday was the lack of a goal threat. That for me is down to the continued selection of Armstrong who is just not doing enough at present, and needs to be benched. If we are to play with two wide men, then give them something to try and hit.

I still don't think we're too far away, but Mowbray does need to make a couple of attacking calls around the number 9 and 10 positions. Armstrong and Swift are not the answer at the moment.
Exactly, the plan was clearly to keep possession and protect the defence, which we did very well, restricting Norwich to very few chances. The problem is, and has been since way before TM arrived, to do this we need someone who can pick a pass and we still don't. Neither Swift nor Mowatt can do it on a regular basis, so the forwards become starved and the ball goes side to side.
I'm happy to criticise TM for the lack of reaction and some strange subs, but to say there is no plan is just plain wrong and verging on childish now. If I could be bothered, I'm sure I could find a game that played out identically for CC and also for Cov, Bristol City, Boro, Blackburn or, indeed, Norwich. 
If we had got a point, it would have been a solid, pragmatic performance and, in the context of other results, a very valuable one. As it was we were hit with a sucker punch because Swift gave away a lazy ball.

I'm no happy clapper and am happy to criticise, and read the criticism of others, but it's just getting a bit silly now with it turning into a character assassination of Mowbray, which, with 8 games to go serves no purpose. Other than to maybe boost a few egos.

What some need to remember is the goal, and that is promotion, so, if we get to Wembley and win, despite not playing that great, will you be screaming "Fuck yes" or "Well that was still shit"? There's 11 games maximum to go so I just want us to get over the line. therefore find these threads a bit daft. 

There'll be more than enough time for these conversations if we don't make it, trust me.

Josh, Bob and EG agree entirely. 
Football wise it was a decent performance. Don't know why Dike wasn't on earlier or even starting, especially the amount of crosses we put in.

I also don't think it was a 'poor' performance, I said as much on the match thread, however the approach in the the last 30-35 minutes was baffling. My opinion would be no different if it had finished 0-0. To be in control but creating so little and to then play with so little urgency and not utilise a stacked bench until so late in the game was angering. I don't 'expect' us to win against any side in this league, particularly away, but considering what was at stake the last 30 minutes were half-arsed at best. Hopefully it's just a blip!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: