Palmer - Adequate or Incredible?
#11
(02-05-2025, 08:18 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-05-2025, 08:14 AM)MrBater Wrote: No keeper is any good over a number of matches if their defence is bad... oh look Palmer let goals in when our defence was bad... shocker.

However a good keeper gives the defence confidence and an extra pair of wider eyes, which in turn feeds into the defence being good.  I'm afraid we'll see that drop if josh comes back in, unless he's improved dramatically. Equally a dodgy keeper gives their defence worries and feeds into them making mistakes.

Palmer was the best keeper we had, since button got dropped and fucked off. He wasn't amazing, but you knew the howlers would reduce massively, which in turn feeds into the defensive unit's confidence and belief.

The great thing about psxg is that you can see, regardless of the headline figure which is as you correctly point out a team issue, whether or not the keeper has performed well individually. 

A keeper can be superb, but a team still let a shit ton of goals in. On the other hand a keeper can be below average but a good team structure can protect them.

I'm one of those, even if the keeper has a stormer and keeps out 8 shots, but lets in 4 then I'm not overly impressed... I'd rather they saved their barnstorming appearance for a match that it helps us win.

Palmer wasn't ever amazing, steady and reliable, I don't recall seeing anyone say he was amazing, he should have bought in a lot more than 2+2+1 though
Reply
#12
Palmer was one of the best keepers in the division and is going to be a tough act to follow.
Reply
#13
(02-05-2025, 08:18 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-05-2025, 08:14 AM)MrBater Wrote: No keeper is any good over a number of matches if their defence is bad... oh look Palmer let goals in when our defence was bad... shocker.

However a good keeper gives the defence confidence and an extra pair of wider eyes, which in turn feeds into the defence being good.  I'm afraid we'll see that drop if josh comes back in, unless he's improved dramatically. Equally a dodgy keeper gives their defence worries and feeds into them making mistakes.

Palmer was the best keeper we had, since button got dropped and fucked off. He wasn't amazing, but you knew the howlers would reduce massively, which in turn feeds into the defensive unit's confidence and belief.

The great thing about psxg is that you can see, regardless of the headline figure which is as you correctly point out a team issue, whether or not the keeper has performed well individually. 

A keeper can be superb, but a team still let a shit ton of goals in. On the other hand a keeper can be below average but a good team structure can protect them.

FFS Lurker, did you really need the stats to work that out. Wink 

Team that plays defensively lets in less goals than team that plays open attacking football.

Palmer was an excellent keeper for us. It’ shouldn’t really be up for question.
Reply
#14
(02-05-2025, 08:24 AM)Duffers Wrote: Palmer was one of the best keepers in the division and is going to be a tough act to follow.

Which is all that's really needed to say about it.
Reply
#15
(02-05-2025, 07:34 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Interesting to hear everyone's opinions. I agree that his communication and presence, especially after Benjamin contributed hugely to the teams defensive performance.

Sliced - I think post shot xG is a really valuable goal keeping statistic, because it only focusses on shots that he's had to save rather than taking into consideration the ones blocked etc which is the biggest weakness of xG more widely.

I have done a bit of a deeper dive into the his performances this year. I have looked for results which have been tight and he has had a +/- psxg of; under/over 0.5psxg for 1 goal margins. Or +/-1psxg for a result of a 2 goal result swing.

There were 8 points he "gained us" through psxg scores.

But there was also 4 points which his under performance on psxg have "cost us"

Still, on balance he has "won us" 4 points alone on this metric, this season so again good adequate performance.

Sorry if it boring to anyone, but a abit more info regarding the general, average psxg/game before and after CC to see how our defence has/is protecting the GK.

CC - 0.86
ToMo - 1.06

This indicated a 19% increase in the post shot expected goals against us.

There is also one main statistical outlier/anomaly, the Cov game where we had a psxG against of 2.5, the only time all season where this happened. Which also was Palmer's best performance as it happened as he kept a clean sheet and made numerous great saves. But if I remove that from the sample, as it's so wildly different from the rest of the year the average psxg against during CCs time was in fact 0.76.

Sorry!!! Last addition for balance against decrease in defensive performance. 

Our average attacking psxg stats are;

CC - 1.2
ToMo - 1.6

Which clumsily indicates a 25% increase in attacking threat. So we current sit at. 6% swing improvement  Big Grin

The psxg for is so much more erratic than the psxg against. As after our initial good form and subsequent 2 losses, we had 3 games where we obviously had a "reset" and our psxg was 0.1-0.2.  So one to keep our eye on as the season unfolds with the leash off.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#16
Better than adequate for sure. Sad to see him go but the timing is right. Feels mad that’s he’s 28!
Reply
#17
(02-05-2025, 08:24 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-05-2025, 08:18 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-05-2025, 08:14 AM)MrBater Wrote: No keeper is any good over a number of matches if their defence is bad... oh look Palmer let goals in when our defence was bad... shocker.

However a good keeper gives the defence confidence and an extra pair of wider eyes, which in turn feeds into the defence being good.  I'm afraid we'll see that drop if josh comes back in, unless he's improved dramatically. Equally a dodgy keeper gives their defence worries and feeds into them making mistakes.

Palmer was the best keeper we had, since button got dropped and fucked off. He wasn't amazing, but you knew the howlers would reduce massively, which in turn feeds into the defensive unit's confidence and belief.

The great thing about psxg is that you can see, regardless of the headline figure which is as you correctly point out a team issue, whether or not the keeper has performed well individually. 

A keeper can be superb, but a team still let a shit ton of goals in. On the other hand a keeper can be below average but a good team structure can protect them.

FFS Lurker, did you really need the stats to work that out. Wink 

Team that plays defensively lets in less goals than team that plays open attacking football.

Palmer was an excellent keeper for us. It’ shouldn’t really be up for question.

Arf, no I didn't, but some people seem to correlate goal keeping performance to goals conceded and clean sheets. Which I see a team statistics rather than an individual accomplishment. 

So I was trying to, in my usual ineloquent way, point that out. 

Fwiw. I think Palmer was adequate.  Big Grin
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#18
There's been a fair few people rewriting history and placing Griffiths in the Crichton end of Albion keepers when talking about his few games for us and completely ignored how well he's played this season.
Reply
#19
23 and 150 senior games under his belt. We’ve managed that almost perfectly. Probably in an ideal scenario he would be becoming our senior number one at 25 but we aren’t a club in an ideal scenario. Excited for what he will become for us long term. Patience in the short term.
Reply
#20
(02-05-2025, 08:49 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: 23 and 150 senior games under his belt. We’ve managed that almost perfectly. Probably in an ideal scenario he would be becoming our senior number one at 25 but we aren’t a club in an ideal scenario. Excited for what he will become for us long term. Patience in the short term.

Very much agreed. Meanwhile in the longer term I will be eternally grateful I am not a statistician. There are after all only so many hours in a day  Big Grin .
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: