Posts: 13,256
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
(01-22-2025, 10:51 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote: (01-22-2025, 10:33 AM)Sliced Wrote: From what I'd read his performances were promising when he played. Maybe another League 2 loan at a less strong team would have him playing week in week out. IMO he definitely doesn't need to drop a league
I saw virtually all of his performances for Walsall and there was no promise there at all. He took his goal well against Shrewsbury in the EFL Trophy but in most games he was just a passenger. No real pace or threat and never got in goalscoring positions. Anyone thinking Cleary is the answer is sadly mistaken.
I trust your opinion over mine  I'd only gone off a brief look at social media.
Having said that I wouldn't have advocated for him being able to do a job at the moment.
Posts: 5,201
Threads: 197
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(01-22-2025, 01:15 PM)Atomic Wrote: He couldn't get in the Walsall team how much do people need to learn? Bullying kids with your physique is one thing but when you come up against real men and seasoned pros it's a completely different thing.
He's not going to make it. Please god let it sink in!!
Let this be an end to this tedious ongoing discussion please.
Respectfully, that's horseshit
He doesn't use his physique to bully kids as you put it, he often plays against CH's a lot bigger than him
He's the most naturally gifted finsher I've seen in the youth set up since Saido, whether he makes it or not is always open to debate, as with all youngters
He was highly thoght of at Walsall but they do have an abundance of forward talent at that level, Lowe, Matt, Adomah etc if he goes back to them, if, that answers your question
Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Posts: 13,256
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
(01-22-2025, 01:49 PM)Cuzer Wrote: (01-22-2025, 01:15 PM)Atomic Wrote: He couldn't get in the Walsall team how much do people need to learn? Bullying kids with your physique is one thing but when you come up against real men and seasoned pros it's a completely different thing.
He's not going to make it. Please god let it sink in!!
Let this be an end to this tedious ongoing discussion please.
Respectfully, that's horseshit
He doesn't use his physique to bully kids as you put it, he often plays against CH's a lot bigger than him
He's the most naturally gifted finsher I've seen in the youth set up since Saido, whether he makes it or not is always open to debate, as with all youngters
He was highly thoght of at Walsall but they do have an abundance of forward talent at that level, Lowe, Matt, Adomah etc if he goes back to them, if, that answers your question
Cuzer
Posts: 2,465
Threads: 34
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(01-22-2025, 10:52 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: He'd need to go back to Walsall right? Thought he played for us against Fleetwood
He did. So I presume it would have to be Walsall again, or an overseas club who play in a league that doesn't have the same start and end period as England (i.e. a league whose season runs in a calendar year alone rather than Autumn to Spring).
Posts: 6,454
Threads: 192
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
(01-22-2025, 01:49 PM)Cuzer Wrote: (01-22-2025, 01:15 PM)Atomic Wrote: He couldn't get in the Walsall team how much do people need to learn? Bullying kids with your physique is one thing but when you come up against real men and seasoned pros it's a completely different thing.
He's not going to make it. Please god let it sink in!!
Let this be an end to this tedious ongoing discussion please.
Respectfully, that's horseshit
He doesn't use his physique to bully kids as you put it, he often plays against CH's a lot bigger than him
He's the most naturally gifted finsher I've seen in the youth set up since Saido, whether he makes it or not is always open to debate, as with all youngters
He was highly thoght of at Walsall but they do have an abundance of forward talent at that level, Lowe, Matt, Adomah etc if he goes back to them, if, that answers your question
Cuzer
They don't have Lowe any more. He scored against us Saturday for Stoke. So maybe Walsall will recall him.
You have banged on and on about Cleary. It seems he is not as good as you make out. And that is not my judgement but of many coaches better qualified to give an opinion than anyone on this board. Time to accept he is not good enough instead of looking for excuses.
However, if he does unexpectedly come good I will be more than happy to acknowledge your forthright defence of his abilities.
Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(01-22-2025, 04:45 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: (01-22-2025, 01:49 PM)Cuzer Wrote: (01-22-2025, 01:15 PM)Atomic Wrote: He couldn't get in the Walsall team how much do people need to learn? Bullying kids with your physique is one thing but when you come up against real men and seasoned pros it's a completely different thing.
He's not going to make it. Please god let it sink in!!
Let this be an end to this tedious ongoing discussion please.
Respectfully, that's horseshit
He doesn't use his physique to bully kids as you put it, he often plays against CH's a lot bigger than him
He's the most naturally gifted finsher I've seen in the youth set up since Saido, whether he makes it or not is always open to debate, as with all youngters
He was highly thoght of at Walsall but they do have an abundance of forward talent at that level, Lowe, Matt, Adomah etc if he goes back to them, if, that answers your question
Cuzer
They don't have Lowe any more. He scored against us Saturday for Stoke. So maybe Walsall will recall him.
You have banged on and on about Cleary. It seems he is not as good as you make out. And that is not my judgement but of many coaches better qualified to give an opinion than anyone on this board. Time to accept he is not good enough instead of looking for excuses.
However, if he does unexpectedly come good I will be more than happy to acknowledge your forthright defence of his abilities.
Not sure Cuzer has made out he's a superstar?
I think he has, quite right said he's a fantastic natural finisher, which he undoubtedly is.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 2,465
Threads: 34
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
Yeah, I always take note of Cuzer's posts on the kids to see if they tally with my own views from watching them. Can't recall him going overboard on Cleary.
Cleary has a definite style which is to get the ball on the left of a front three (which is where he is played) and work himself a shooting chance, first and foremost. Sometimes he will lay or pass the ball off, perhaps even work a crossing opportunity, but working the shooting chance is the default position.
He does what Steve Bull used to do when he played for our reserves.
Posts: 2,927
Threads: 44
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation:
7
(01-22-2025, 01:49 PM)Cuzer Wrote: (01-22-2025, 01:15 PM)Atomic Wrote: He couldn't get in the Walsall team how much do people need to learn? Bullying kids with your physique is one thing but when you come up against real men and seasoned pros it's a completely different thing.
He's not going to make it. Please god let it sink in!!
Let this be an end to this tedious ongoing discussion please.
Respectfully, that's horseshit
He doesn't use his physique to bully kids as you put it, he often plays against CH's a lot bigger than him
He's the most naturally gifted finsher I've seen in the youth set up since Saido, whether he makes it or not is always open to debate, as with all youngters
He was highly thoght of at Walsall but they do have an abundance of forward talent at that level, Lowe, Matt, Adomah etc if he goes back to them, if, that answers your question
Cuzer
Out of interest, how much have you seen of him in the last 18 months? He was obviously injured for the large majority of last season. Lowe aside, Walsall don’t (didn’t) have an abundance of striking talent. Sadler has always played with a front two and that isn’t Adomah’s natural position with him featuring there, out of position, above Cleary in the pecking order for most cup games this season. Matt is the classic good pro, and has had an excellent season, but is a real mid 30s lower league/non league journeyman. He was not well thought of by Walsall fans prior to this season. Danny Johnson is another journeyman who Sadler has never fancied and is living off a lot of good will from his original loan spell there. Then you have Josh Gordon who is really just a hard working non-scoring goalscorer. There was a sense of resignation amongst Saddler’s fans when he signed permanently after a not especially inspiring loan spell. The latter three massively struggled to provide the necessary goals last season.
My point being this - as great as Cleary may have looked pre-injury in his teens, it means nothing. If he really had the talent to get anywhere close to being a Championship level striker (or to be honest even a professional level striker) he would have shown something either in his appearances or in training to demonstrate what could do. Instead, he wasn’t even in the squad of 18 for most of period there.
I hope I’m wrong, I’d love to have to eat these words but I’ve seen nothing from him in his several first team football appearances at Walsall which convinces me he will be a professional player in this country.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
Dood claiming he's off to Hartlepool.
Posts: 7,711
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
2 club rule is only for the top 4 tiers I believe.
|