Sam Dingle
#11
(12-09-2024, 11:06 PM)Evenolderfella Wrote:
(12-09-2024, 11:00 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Did you miss the first goal where he watched the ball sail over his head like he’d just smoked a bong? Or the various other mishaps from the season?

No mate I saw it , and I know he is not very good I saw him enough. His distribution however was always good when he was with us, and appears to be now. As regards the particular aspect of distribution, Palmer is piss poor by comparison.
I day say Johnstone was a good keeper now did I?

Yam day day ya 

Rrrrr tek it back cocka
Reply
#12
He watched the first one sail over his head. Poor position and flat footed. The second I would expect an England keeper to save.

If I judged a keeper on distribution I would put Glen Hoddle there, who was also England's emergency keeper
Reply
#13
Does he forget he can use his hands? How many times have we seen that forlorn look following a goal from a cross? Absolutely brilliant that it's now happening to them.

Nearly as good as them not getting that penalty. Even VAR hates the fuckers!
Reply
#14
Bizarre that Baggies Keepers are either loathed or loved. There's no in-between, is there? Big Grin
Reply
#15
(12-10-2024, 09:04 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Bizarre that Baggies Keepers are either loathed or loved. There's no in-between, is there? Big Grin

No, that is full backs, you have your positions mixed up.
Reply
#16
Johnstone is a strange one, sometimes he can look like a world beater, other times he looks like a competition winner plucked out the stands 5 minutes before kick off.

I believe his issues are mental rather than technical, when he feels happy and secure he plays well but it doesn't take much to knock his confidence and that's when the issues start. In my opinion he was prematurely and unfairly maligned with us, especially early days when people seemed to have made their minds up on him instantly (replacing Foster, one of our best ever, didn't help either) and I genuinely believe that contributed to his poor form. No coincidence that his best performances for us were when the ground was shut.
Reply
#17
(12-10-2024, 09:45 AM)Duffers Wrote: Johnstone is a strange one, sometimes he can look like a world beater, other times he looks like a competition winner plucked out the stands 5 minutes before kick off.

I believe his issues are mental rather than technical, when he feels happy and secure he plays well but it doesn't take much to knock his confidence and that's when the issues start. In my opinion he was prematurely and unfairly maligned with us, especially early days when people seemed to have made their minds up on him instantly (replacing Foster, one of our best ever, didn't help either) and I genuinely believe that contributed to his poor form. No coincidence that his best performances for us were when the ground was shut.

IMHO we only paid £5M for him to get one over the Villa. That is where he wanted to go, but they couldn't afford him. 

After that, he was on a loser from day 1. He did get better for us, which coincided with his England caps, but I think he has gone backwards. He was Palace reserve, and by no means first choice for the Dogheads now.
Reply
#18
(12-10-2024, 10:23 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(12-10-2024, 09:45 AM)Duffers Wrote: Johnstone is a strange one, sometimes he can look like a world beater, other times he looks like a competition winner plucked out the stands 5 minutes before kick off.

I believe his issues are mental rather than technical, when he feels happy and secure he plays well but it doesn't take much to knock his confidence and that's when the issues start. In my opinion he was prematurely and unfairly maligned with us, especially early days when people seemed to have made their minds up on him instantly (replacing Foster, one of our best ever, didn't help either) and I genuinely believe that contributed to his poor form. No coincidence that his best performances for us were when the ground was shut.

IMHO we only paid £5M for him to get one over the Villa. That is where he wanted to go, but they couldn't afford him. 

After that, he was on a loser from day 1. He did get better for us, which coincided with his England caps, but I think he has gone backwards. He was Palace reserve, and by no means first choice for the Dogheads now.

Both these posts sum it up, but I would also add he lacked personality, in that he never connected with the crowd. He always looked like that awkward bloke in company that you try to spark up a chat to, but after a few minutes you think it's too much like hard work.
His attitude the night we lost to Preston and he was dropped, when they scored and he liked a tweet, kind of sealed the deal that he had burnt his bridges.
He was a decent keeper though, but probably on par with Palmer, who is turning into a very decent one. if he got his distribution a bit better he'd be England material.
Reply
#19
Palmer is comfortably better than SJ. By some way.
Reply
#20
(12-10-2024, 10:23 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(12-10-2024, 09:45 AM)Duffers Wrote: Johnstone is a strange one, sometimes he can look like a world beater, other times he looks like a competition winner plucked out the stands 5 minutes before kick off.

I believe his issues are mental rather than technical, when he feels happy and secure he plays well but it doesn't take much to knock his confidence and that's when the issues start. In my opinion he was prematurely and unfairly maligned with us, especially early days when people seemed to have made their minds up on him instantly (replacing Foster, one of our best ever, didn't help either) and I genuinely believe that contributed to his poor form. No coincidence that his best performances for us were when the ground was shut.

IMHO we only paid £5M for him to get one over the Villa. That is where he wanted to go, but they couldn't afford him. 

After that, he was on a loser from day 1. He did get better for us, which coincided with his England caps, but I think he has gone backwards. He was Palace reserve, and by no means first choice for the Dogheads now.

Not quite right. SJ had no connection with villa either, he stayed at the Belfry during his spell there. Villa couldn't buy him because of their financial shenanigans so we did. Some of his issues may be down to confidence or replacing BF, but I believe mainly that our style of playing from the back, coupled with us being kamikaze with crosses, led to him having a shake spell.
Agree he played better behind closed doors. And agree with Spandau that tweet finished him here. Overall SJ not developed any rapport with fans anywhere he's been and is only favoured by the dings because unlike Sa, he hasn't gone into the crowd for a row yet.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: