Fellows
#11
(08-17-2024, 07:01 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: If you looked at the game overall today, it was clear which coach outfoxed the other. Whether he could’ve done an even better job of that is open for debate, but I doubt Carlos needs any lessons on why he chose that balance. I think 7/10 times we win the game 1-0 and no one nit picks

Agree.

I was disappointed he didn’t release the shackles a little more as the game was there for the taking IMO, especially as our passiveness gave Leeds the belief they could get something.
Reply
#12
You can't fault the job CC has done at the Albion considering the resources he has got but i do feel he would rather draw 0-0 than win 3-2.

That today was one of the worst games of football i have ever watched. Saying that my team HTFC lost 1-4 at home after not a good day.
Reply
#13
(08-17-2024, 08:17 PM)Yeltzbaggie Wrote: You can't fault the job CC has done at the Albion considering the resources he has got but i do feel he would rather draw 0-0 than win 3-2.

That today was one of the worst games of football i have ever watched. Saying that my team HTFC lost 1-4 at home after not a good day.
At the risk of a whoosh, if that’s the worst game you’ve seen you haven’t seen many Albion games
Reply
#14
We all rightly hold CC very high regard. Saying that first before people think it’s an attack on him, it’s not. Merely an observation.

CC is a caution-first coach, we rarely risk losing a game in an attempt to win it (Leicester aside last season!) and occasionally you get games like this or the odd decision that doesn’t help the team offensively but rather hinders our attacking ability in the name of stopping the opposition.

Not sure if he sees that as a reflection of our ability or just his style. I’d say overall it enables the team to keep picking up points and fight for a play-off position. You do sometimes though get these stinkers, we set-up to minimise their threat and they came with a mind set of ensuring they didn’t lose.

Both teams intent not to lose leaves Fellows playing LWB for longer than he should.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#15
There are two separate aspects to this.

Firstly, was Fellows the best choice to play at LWB to nullify Leeds? Yes, he's an awesome talent and his defensive skills are known to be good, and we obviously want him on the pitch. But couldn't Frabotta play there? Maybe not yet considered match fit?

Secondly, given the selection, maybe CC expected to Fellows to get outside his man more often. Bogle was one slip away from a sending off for three-quarters of the game, but Tom never really looked to pass him the way he does on the right - possibly because he doesn't have as much confidence in his left foot to deliver the cross. If this is going to be a regular game plan, I hope they work on this, as Fellows' crosses are our main weapon.
Reply
#16
(08-18-2024, 08:54 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: There are two separate aspects to this.

Firstly, was Fellows the best choice to play at LWB to nullify Leeds? Yes, he's an awesome talent and his defensive skills are known to be good, and we obviously want him on the pitch. But couldn't Frabotta play there? Maybe not yet considered match fit?

Secondly, given the selection, maybe CC expected to Fellows to get outside his man more often. Bogle was one slip away from a sending off for three-quarters of the game, but Tom never really looked to pass him the way he does on the right - possibly because he doesn't have as much confidence in his left foot to deliver the cross. If this is going to be a regular game plan, I hope they work on this, as Fellows' crosses are our main weapon.

I'm not wholly convinced he actually was a wingback! Certainly not all game anyway. Towards the end he was looking to cross a few times, sadly Maja times his runs into the box late. I'm sure it'll come together enough times over the season. Agree Bogle should have walked though.
Reply
#17
People are right to question our tactics, but the Leeds fans were booing their "backwards and square". No wonder CC turned the gig down, its a poisoned chalice.
Reply
#18
(08-18-2024, 08:54 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: There are two separate aspects to this.

Firstly, was Fellows the best choice to play at LWB to nullify Leeds? Yes, he's an awesome talent and his defensive skills are known to be good, and we obviously want him on the pitch. But couldn't Frabotta play there? Maybe not yet considered match fit?

Secondly, given the selection, maybe CC expected to Fellows to get outside his man more often. Bogle was one slip away from a sending off for three-quarters of the game, but Tom never really looked to pass him the way he does on the right - possibly because he doesn't have as much confidence in his left foot to deliver the cross. If this is going to be a regular game plan, I hope they work on this, as Fellows' crosses are our main weapon.
Not sure CC particularly likes using two full backs as wing backs, so I can see why he didn’t go for Frabotta. Fellows played the same role, albeit on the right, in the play off semi at Saints with Furlong at the right of the 3, and Phillips played that role on the left ahead of Pieters for lots of the early part of last season.

I think he likes having a more attacking player in one wing back slot, with a full back option on that side in the 3 so that we can go to a 4 when we have the ball. It happened a lot yesterday with Heggem stepped out to left back, Fellows pushing higher and Mowatt dropping in to help us play out. You’d lose a bit of that with Frabotta in there.
Reply
#19
(08-18-2024, 11:01 AM)ABBaggie Wrote:
(08-18-2024, 08:54 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: There are two separate aspects to this.

Firstly, was Fellows the best choice to play at LWB to nullify Leeds? Yes, he's an awesome talent and his defensive skills are known to be good, and we obviously want him on the pitch. But couldn't Frabotta play there? Maybe not yet considered match fit?

Secondly, given the selection, maybe CC expected to Fellows to get outside his man more often. Bogle was one slip away from a sending off for three-quarters of the game, but Tom never really looked to pass him the way he does on the right - possibly because he doesn't have as much confidence in his left foot to deliver the cross. If this is going to be a regular game plan, I hope they work on this, as Fellows' crosses are our main weapon.
Not sure CC particularly likes using two full backs as wing backs, so I can see why he didn’t go for Frabotta. Fellows played the same role, albeit on the right, in the play off semi at Saints with Furlong at the right of the 3, and Phillips played that role on the left ahead of Pieters for lots of the early part of last season.

I think he likes having a more attacking player in one wing back slot, with a full back option on that side in the 3 so that we can go to a 4 when we have the ball. It happened a lot yesterday with Heggem stepped out to left back, Fellows pushing higher and Mowatt dropping in to help us play out. You’d lose a bit of that with Frabotta in there.

I guess you could say that Fellows has replaced Phillips in the squad - wide attacking player who can defend as well, capable on both sides. Whereas I'd rather see Fellows starting in Wallace's role wide on the right, which happened a lot last season for various reasons. Whatever system works, eh?
Reply
#20
(08-18-2024, 01:23 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(08-18-2024, 11:01 AM)ABBaggie Wrote:
(08-18-2024, 08:54 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: There are two separate aspects to this.

Firstly, was Fellows the best choice to play at LWB to nullify Leeds? Yes, he's an awesome talent and his defensive skills are known to be good, and we obviously want him on the pitch. But couldn't Frabotta play there? Maybe not yet considered match fit?

Secondly, given the selection, maybe CC expected to Fellows to get outside his man more often. Bogle was one slip away from a sending off for three-quarters of the game, but Tom never really looked to pass him the way he does on the right - possibly because he doesn't have as much confidence in his left foot to deliver the cross. If this is going to be a regular game plan, I hope they work on this, as Fellows' crosses are our main weapon.
Not sure CC particularly likes using two full backs as wing backs, so I can see why he didn’t go for Frabotta. Fellows played the same role, albeit on the right, in the play off semi at Saints with Furlong at the right of the 3, and Phillips played that role on the left ahead of Pieters for lots of the early part of last season.

I think he likes having a more attacking player in one wing back slot, with a full back option on that side in the 3 so that we can go to a 4 when we have the ball. It happened a lot yesterday with Heggem stepped out to left back, Fellows pushing higher and Mowatt dropping in to help us play out. You’d lose a bit of that with Frabotta in there.

I guess you could say that Fellows has replaced Phillips in the squad - wide attacking player who can defend as well, capable on both sides. Whereas I'd rather see Fellows starting in Wallace's role wide on the right, which happened a lot last season for various reasons. Whatever system works, eh?

In fairness it was only in one game and I expect we will see this tactic implemented in games where CC expects to prioritise the draw, but against QPR he had a lot more license to attack and was on his correct side. I’d have preferred to see Fabrotta come over Wallace and Fellows given the last 15-20 in a more attacking role but can see why CC went with the changes he did.

It was a decent point but 24 hours on I still feel like we could have nicked that with a bit more intent as Leeds looked so nervous first half.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)