Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(02-07-2019, 11:15 AM)Sliced Wrote: eh!??!!
Look at the predictions for the start of the season (well, actually you can't now that the board has changed), the majority said that we would finish between 7th and 12th. Most people were rabbiting on about how weak our squad was in the first half of the season.
In fact I distinctly remember one of your posts saying "We aren't good enough to get promoted with this squad". Well the squad has only improved a week ago, and we're just as likely to go up the table as down at this point. So which is it? Are we underachieving with a great squad, or overachieving with a "squad that's not good enough to get promoted"? It can't be both.
Asking "how long does Moore have?" at this point makes no sense. If we lose the next few then we can start to talk about borrowed time, if keep up our average PPG or better than that in the next few games then the question will continue to not make sense, and we review at the end of the season.
Early in the season I didn't believe our squad was strong enough, however as the season has progressed and as I've seen pretty much all the sides in the league live I'm of the opinion that actually we are better than most, and that whilst Leeds, Norwich and Sheff Utd are all playing as a team that is far greater than the sum of their parts, we seem to be nowhere near that level.
I predicted 6th at the start of the season if I remember correctly, as I believed we were better than the average relegated side, and thought we'd probably just about get into the playoffs... however after seeing how much stronger we are player for player than most of the sides around us, I think its fair to revise expectations to anything below 6th being under-performing.
So your answer is review in the summer?
Posts: 903
Threads: 43
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
(02-07-2019, 11:17 AM)MGalea Wrote: He's got the next 10 years for me.
Doing well this season.
Young manager still learning.
Some stability would do wonders for us in the long run.
Spot on, bloke is in his first proper job and yet we sit 4th in table above more experienced managers. Fans are really fickle to want change at the drop of a hat.
Posts: 13,256
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
Haven't we won the most points from losing positions and dropped the least points from winning positions? Certainly until a couple weeks ago that was the case.
The perception of the subs are mainly from people online observing a game and going "well I wouldn't have done that".
As pointed out, he seems reluctant to make changes but it's delusional to expect everything would be perfect given it's his first every managerial job. Asking how long has he got while we sit 4th in the league and the second highest scorers in all 4 divisions is one of the most Villa-esque things I can possibly imagine.
Posts: 1,174
Threads: 94
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
4
(02-07-2019, 11:22 AM)Ed Hopper Wrote: For me the only thing he needs to get better at are his subs-when to use them and who to change. It’s hard to criticise him though as 6 months in to any new job is hard for anyone, but as long as he learns he and we will be fine.
I’d much prefer this scenario to maybe applying a ‘rowett’ Only to find out it’s nit working by Xmas.
THIS
Posts: 13,256
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
(02-07-2019, 11:22 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (02-07-2019, 11:15 AM)Sliced Wrote: eh!??!!
Look at the predictions for the start of the season (well, actually you can't now that the board has changed), the majority said that we would finish between 7th and 12th. Most people were rabbiting on about how weak our squad was in the first half of the season.
In fact I distinctly remember one of your posts saying "We aren't good enough to get promoted with this squad". Well the squad has only improved a week ago, and we're just as likely to go up the table as down at this point. So which is it? Are we underachieving with a great squad, or overachieving with a "squad that's not good enough to get promoted"? It can't be both.
Asking "how long does Moore have?" at this point makes no sense. If we lose the next few then we can start to talk about borrowed time, if keep up our average PPG or better than that in the next few games then the question will continue to not make sense, and we review at the end of the season.
Early in the season I didn't believe our squad was strong enough, however as the season has progressed and as I've seen pretty much all the sides in the league live I'm of the opinion that actually we are better than most, and that whilst Leeds, Norwich and Sheff Utd are all playing as a team that is far greater than the sum of their parts, we seem to be nowhere near that level.
I predicted 6th at the start of the season if I remember correctly, as I believed we were better than the average relegated side, and thought we'd probably just about get into the playoffs... however after seeing how much stronger we are player for player than most of the sides around us, I think its fair to revise expectations to anything below 6th being under-performing.
So your answer is review in the summer?
We're 4 points off Sheff U with a game in hand having beaten them earlier in the season and Leeds have lost 4 of the last 5 in all competitions so I can't agree with that.
Barring a monumentally bad streak which sees us drop to 10-12th Moore will be here until the end of the season and as long as we finish top 6 he'll be there next season too regardless of whether we get promotion.
Posts: 530
Threads: 37
Joined: Jan 2019
Look at how a experienced successful Championship manager in Gary Rowett struggled with Stoke who many agreed had the best squad at the start of the season and blew us away in terms of spending money.
Another successful Championship manager in Steve Bruce struggled to get a Villa side up who their fans would have you believe were the best squad of players outside the PL.
Teams such as Sunderland and Wolves suffered back to back relegations with their fans expecting promotion that season.
We had a very poor season last year and many players had the confidence knocked out of them. We've had to adapt to this division, changing out mentality from a side that looks to contain teams to a side that goes on the attack. We've had to change the mindset created from losing most weeks to winning most weeks.
Mooro is in his first year in management and was thrown in the deep end with no scouting department, left with some players who wanted to leave the club, a squad with very low morale, supporters disillusioned. A much tougher job than some give him credit for and he's doing a bloody good job IMO.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(02-07-2019, 11:29 AM)Sliced Wrote: (02-07-2019, 11:22 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (02-07-2019, 11:15 AM)Sliced Wrote: eh!??!!
Look at the predictions for the start of the season (well, actually you can't now that the board has changed), the majority said that we would finish between 7th and 12th. Most people were rabbiting on about how weak our squad was in the first half of the season.
In fact I distinctly remember one of your posts saying "We aren't good enough to get promoted with this squad". Well the squad has only improved a week ago, and we're just as likely to go up the table as down at this point. So which is it? Are we underachieving with a great squad, or overachieving with a "squad that's not good enough to get promoted"? It can't be both.
Asking "how long does Moore have?" at this point makes no sense. If we lose the next few then we can start to talk about borrowed time, if keep up our average PPG or better than that in the next few games then the question will continue to not make sense, and we review at the end of the season.
Early in the season I didn't believe our squad was strong enough, however as the season has progressed and as I've seen pretty much all the sides in the league live I'm of the opinion that actually we are better than most, and that whilst Leeds, Norwich and Sheff Utd are all playing as a team that is far greater than the sum of their parts, we seem to be nowhere near that level.
I predicted 6th at the start of the season if I remember correctly, as I believed we were better than the average relegated side, and thought we'd probably just about get into the playoffs... however after seeing how much stronger we are player for player than most of the sides around us, I think its fair to revise expectations to anything below 6th being under-performing.
So your answer is review in the summer?
We're 4 points off Sheff U with a game in hand having beaten them earlier in the season and Leeds have lost 4 of the last 5 in all competitions so I can't agree with that.
Barring a monumentally bad streak which sees us drop to 10-12th Moore will be here until the end of the season and as long as we finish top 6 he'll be there next season too regardless of whether we get promotion.
I think you're getting very worked-up over this thread for no reason really - breathe and re-read. There's no need to be defensive, I'm just asking what people's thoughts are, given opinion at the game swings from people who think he should be gone tomorrow to people who think he's infallible.
I don't want him to go because as has been said on this thread, there's more positives than negatives, but I can't help the nagging feeling that we're taking a massive gamble on our future by letting a manager so inexperienced oversee our best chances of promotion.
Posts: 655
Threads: 185
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
Before BD's appointment, I posted, should anyone care to check up, that he had done a great job, galvinising the players, bringing some pride back to the Club, and was imo a strong dressing room personality, and probably great for geeing the lads up etc, and getting the best out of 'em, but at that time not yet managerial material. I believe that he needs this season at least, to hone those necessary skills, we are currently in a comfortable position, and any thoughts of his removal should be put aside. I also wonder whether he really benefits from having Jones around . Just saying like !.
Posts: 7,971
Threads: 254
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(02-07-2019, 11:08 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Not advocating sacking him, more just gauging opinion.
On the positive side, I think he's brought unity and pride back after the mess of last season, and when I look at how Swansea and Stoke are doing, it's far too easy to forget we were as much of a state - if not more in Stoke's case - as both of these clubs, yet we look the most likely to return of all 3. Further, he picked up an unbalanced squad that needed to combine both a change in mentality and style with picking up results, which for the most part he's managed.
The negative is that we're under-achieving. When I look at the sides above and around us, we have far more in the tank. Yes our squad lacked balance, but I still feel we're too reliant on individual moments to win games and that I can count on one hand the number of genuinely quality performances we've put in this season and as the games progress we don't seem to be evolving or progressing any discernible way of playing.
I didn't expect promotion this season, and still don't if I'm honest, so to sack him for not taking us up would be incredibly harsh, but having looked at the standard of sides around us, if we do drop out of the top 6 in the next few weeks, I'd be asking questions.
This sums up my concerns - along with the recent downturn in results. Right now, DM needs to improve results, defending, energy/ fitness and (at home) basic set-up and tactics. 2 home wins in the league in 4 months is fugging pisspoor - however you slice it.
IMO:
top 2/ win the play offs is success,
losing a play off is par;
7th downwards is absolute failure.
Posts: 1,777
Threads: 5
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
4
(02-07-2019, 11:22 AM)Ed Hopper Wrote: For me the only thing he needs to get better at are his subs-when to use them and who to change. It’s hard to criticise him though as 6 months in to any new job is hard for anyone, but as long as he learns he and we will be fine.
I’d much prefer this scenario to maybe applying a ‘rowett’ Only to find out it’s nit working by Xmas.
This - These decisions should improve as he becomes more experienced.
There isn't a Manager in the history of the game that were the finished article after 6 months of experience in the role.
Unless our form is hopeless for the remainder of the season and we drop out of the play-offs, and into mid-table, there's no way we should even consider sacking Big Dave. I've enjoyed this season, and that's been down to the football and approach that the Manager has opted to take.
|