Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(08-14-2024, 07:44 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Not a single nuke is going to be fired; Putin just has to look hard in front of his mates. It really won't get that far.
This is all just war games that conveniently take Russia out of the global picture. Hence the Ukrainians getting such a stiffy over combat aircraft from the late 1970s.
1000 sq. km sounds a lot, but it really isn't much, either. Just hope the man in the grubby green t-shirt hasn't sentenced some of his best to death.
What alternative does he have? Russia have made it clear on several occasions that they don't think Ukraine should exist as a country anymore.
P.S Romania are rapidly expanding their air force and Finland and Romania are now conducting joint training exercises.
It's easy for people sat on the Western side of Europe to say Zelensky should back down. Countries formerly occupied by Russia/sharing a border with Russia feel very differently.
Posts: 1,090
Threads: 72
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
2
All this reminds me of the start of that movie Threads (1984)
Not a film for the faint hearted btw
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(08-14-2024, 02:53 PM)Pipkins Wrote: All this reminds me of the start of that movie Threads (1984)
Not a film for the faint hearted btw
Had to watch that in school, and Schindlers List.
Posts: 8,125
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
08-15-2024, 07:36 AM
(This post was last modified: 08-15-2024, 07:52 AM by HawkingsHalfpint.)
(08-14-2024, 12:59 PM)Squid Wrote: (08-14-2024, 07:44 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Not a single nuke is going to be fired; Putin just has to look hard in front of his mates. It really won't get that far.
This is all just war games that conveniently take Russia out of the global picture. Hence the Ukrainians getting such a stiffy over combat aircraft from the late 1970s.
1000 sq. km sounds a lot, but it really isn't much, either. Just hope the man in the grubby green t-shirt hasn't sentenced some of his best to death.
What alternative does he have? Russia have made it clear on several occasions that they don't think Ukraine should exist as a country anymore.
P.S Romania are rapidly expanding their air force and Finland and Romania are now conducting joint training exercises.
It's easy for people sat on the Western side of Europe to say Zelensky should back down. Countries formerly occupied by Russia/sharing a border with Russia feel very differently.
It's equally easy for President Zelensky to throw his men into the meat grinder. It's a plucky tactic for sure, but it is certainly not without risk, and in any other part of the world this would be viewed as an escalation, which is exactly how Putin will also see it.
Perhaps that is the plan, but - and without wanting to sound like Russel 'sex pest' Brand - this is certainly not all as black and white as the media would have everyone so obediently believe.
(08-14-2024, 12:53 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: (08-14-2024, 07:44 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Not a single nuke is going to be fired; Putin just has to look hard in front of his mates. It really won't get that far.
This is all just war games that conveniently take Russia out of the global picture. Hence the Ukrainians getting such a stiffy over combat aircraft from the late 1970s.
1000 sq. km sounds a lot, but it really isn't much, either. Just hope the man in the grubby green t-shirt hasn't sentenced some of his best to death.
I'm not sure how it will pan out but I don't see how it takes Russia out of the global picture? It's impossible to 2nd guess a maniac but looks to me like Putin is fine with a lengthy attritional war that plays into his one asset of greater manpower. Maybe Zelensky just needed to nudge the battle in a different direction?
Russia is essentially - as a result of its own actions I must stress - bogged down in a proxy war of attrition against NATO. The fact that it is Ukraine defending its sovereignty doesn't really alter the situation that this war is being fought with NATO funding and supply. That cessation of that supply (although at one point uncertain around the turn year when the US congress was dragging its heels) is unlikely to occur any time soon, otherwise it would completely render the 'investment' to date a pointless lost cause (the eventual delivery of the F16s rubber-stamps that somewhat). So, for as long as Russia can keep fighting, NATO can - and will - keep supplying, most likely (as far as I can predict) to a point where Russia simply gives up because it is, in a proxy sense at least, fighting against the world.
The point I was making about Russia is that - up until this miscalculated conflict - Putin's Russia was becoming a problem, and not just in terms of national security. Their influence on the world stage was growing, they had (have) multiple investment/development initiatives in development nations (particularly Africa) and were beginning to demonstrate acts of impunity well beyond any Salisbury poisonings or Crimean incursions. London was awash with Russian money, the Middle East also, and they were cosying up to OPEC and largely able to dictate European gas supply. A lot in the west didn't like this, and some were even mightily afraid of an administration that - yes - was not only capable of killing on UK soil but entirely self-sufficient as well as achieving quite astronomical growth since the commencement of the Putin administration. When he took charge, they had an economy the size of Belgium. It is three or four times greater than that now - Russia was as tiger an economy as you were ever likely to see, and coupled with throwing their weight around many in the west did not like this.
We laid a trap and he fell into it. On top of that, the press-portrayed image of happy Ukrainians in Luhansk/Donbass merrily skipping to work on grain farms or uranium mines really isn't true at all. It was not milk and honey prior to any of this.
Russia is essentially neutralised by this conflict. Whilst I am not entirely sure it is by complete design, it does suit an agenda or two on both sides of the global influential spectra, it is isn't as if NATO hasn't gone back on its 2008 Accord promise by wooing Ukraine with fluttering eyes. Crimea happened after they signalled a willing to explore closer ties with the EU, this after NATO chatter. Russia's most foolish move to date has been falling for it all.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
08-15-2024, 12:03 PM
(This post was last modified: 08-15-2024, 12:04 PM by Tom Joad.)
Hawks. While I agree with much of your post where we differ is that I see no need or validity for Putin's invasion of Ukraine. Of course Donbass was not a land of milk and honey but that does not legitimise the bombing of Kiev and other cities. Further, if Russia's neighbours want to join NATO then that's up to them, much as it might rankle with Russia they would be best off asking themselves why that is?
I'm sure we do see a very pro Ukraine stance in what is reported but that doesn't mean Putin is an innocent party, slighted by an unjust group of countries. He is undoubtedly one of the biggest threats in the world and should have been stopped by hook or crook, many years ago.
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
08-15-2024, 12:24 PM
(This post was last modified: 08-15-2024, 12:25 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
(08-15-2024, 12:03 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Hawks. While I agree with much of your post where we differ is that I see no need or validity for Putin's invasion of Ukraine. Of course Donbass was not a land of milk and honey but that does not legitimise the bombing of Kiev and other cities. Further, if Russia's neighbours want to join NATO then that's up to them, much as it might rankle with Russia they would be best off asking themselves why that is?
I'm sure we do see a very pro Ukraine stance in what is reported but that doesn't mean Putin is an innocent party, slighted by an unjust group of countries. He is undoubtedly one of the biggest threats in the world and should have been stopped by hook or crook, many years ago.
Putin is obsessed with the idea of "Greater Russia", he's an ardent Russian imperialist. NATO expansion is a reaction to that imperialism. Estonia, Lithuania, Latvia, Poland, Finland, Sweden etc. are sovereign nations and they joined NATO as they could see what was happening - western aligned nations like Sweden and Finland put off joining NATO for decades including during the bloody Cold War.
We should have realised what was going to happen in Ukraine after Georgia was invaded, that was the sign of things to come. Ukraine was invaded by Russia 10 years ago and we still tried to tiptoe around Russia while they were interfering in Western elections and trying to assassinate people, including British citizens, on British soil. We were complacent in thinking Russian irredentism was a thing of the 19th century and Georgia, Russia and Moldova are suffering as a result.
Posts: 8,125
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
08-15-2024, 02:38 PM
(This post was last modified: 08-15-2024, 03:05 PM by HawkingsHalfpint.)
(08-15-2024, 12:03 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Hawks. While I agree with much of your post where we differ is that I see no need or validity for Putin's invasion of Ukraine. Of course Donbass was not a land of milk and honey but that does not legitimise the bombing of Kiev and other cities. Further, if Russia's neighbours want to join NATO then that's up to them, much as it might rankle with Russia they would be best off asking themselves why that is?
I'm sure we do see a very pro Ukraine stance in what is reported but that doesn't mean Putin is an innocent party, slighted by an unjust group of countries. He is undoubtedly one of the biggest threats in the world and should have been stopped by hook or crook, many years ago.
How?
(08-15-2024, 12:24 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (08-15-2024, 12:03 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Hawks. While I agree with much of your post where we differ is that I see no need or validity for Putin's invasion of Ukraine. Of course Donbass was not a land of milk and honey but that does not legitimise the bombing of Kiev and other cities. Further, if Russia's neighbours want to join NATO then that's up to them, much as it might rankle with Russia they would be best off asking themselves why that is?
I'm sure we do see a very pro Ukraine stance in what is reported but that doesn't mean Putin is an innocent party, slighted by an unjust group of countries. He is undoubtedly one of the biggest threats in the world and should have been stopped by hook or crook, many years ago.
Putin is obsessed with the idea of "Greater Russia", he's an ardent Russian imperialist. NATO expansion is a reaction to that imperialism. Estonia, Lithuania, Latvia, Poland, Finland, Sweden etc. are sovereign nations and they joined NATO as they could see what was happening - western aligned nations like Sweden and Finland put off joining NATO for decades including during the bloody Cold War.
We should have realised what was going to happen in Ukraine after Georgia was invaded, that was the sign of things to come. Ukraine was invaded by Russia 10 years ago and we still tried to tiptoe around Russia while they were interfering in Western elections and trying to assassinate people, including British citizens, on British soil. We were complacent in thinking Russian irredentism was a thing of the 19th century and Georgia, Russia and Moldova are suffering as a result.
All easy to say now, but Russia was able to buy its own influence - perhaps all too easily - during the previous decade. One of BoJo's best mates was an ill-advised editor; the influence of Putin's regime on the early Trump administration is all too well documented. It's a complete falsehood to say that Putin was neither important nor a popular contributor to global politics, once upon a time.
As I have posted above (without for a second justifying the illegal invasion of Ukraine), he pushed it too far; and fell for a trap set for him. I truly believe that he miscalculated global reaction to what he saw as a corrupt, rebel state (which in many ways it was, there is plenty of evidence to justify this) falling into his hands. Crimea had been easy, and he thought this would be also. It hasn't been.
But the narrative is not 100% clear on this. Energy security and natural resource is as central to this conflict as any country's sovereignty, and certain things do not happen by accident. It's funny how many people don't trust their own politicians but those from overseas. As always, you have to look at who the winners and losers are to truly understand.
(08-15-2024, 12:03 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Hawks. While I agree with much of your post where we differ is that I see no need or validity for Putin's invasion of Ukraine. Of course Donbass was not a land of milk and honey but that does not legitimise the bombing of Kiev and other cities. Further, if Russia's neighbours want to join NATO then that's up to them, much as it might rankle with Russia they would be best off asking themselves why that is?
I'm sure we do see a very pro Ukraine stance in what is reported but that doesn't mean Putin is an innocent party, slighted by an unjust group of countries. He is undoubtedly one of the biggest threats in the world and should have been stopped by hook or crook, many years ago.
Also, where did I legitimise it?
I'm not saying for a moment that it should have happened, but nor am I ever going to be told that it wasn't encouraged.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
Hawks. OK, not legitimise but it appears you attempt to justify it. I'm not convinced at all it was encouraged either. Putin is as bad as they come but I'd say most Western nations would still have preferred not to back a war. Back it they have though and I don't know of any alternative. Those you mentioned previously that cosyied up the the great dictator, well, Johnson, Trump? Says enough about them.
Posts: 6,723
Threads: 355
Joined: Mar 2024
Reputation:
40
Interesting stuff chaps. Thanks. I was vaguely aware of Russia in Africa but China are all over the Caribbean. I couldnt believe it when i was last there.And the new silk road is quite something. Belt and Road initiative.
The future's Chinese.
Mind you, i thought that when we got a Chinese billionaire owner. Plus I have l no finance qualifications.
Posts: 8,125
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
08-18-2024, 08:10 AM
(This post was last modified: 08-18-2024, 08:12 AM by HawkingsHalfpint.)
(08-15-2024, 04:14 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Hawks. OK, not legitimise but it appears you attempt to justify it. I'm not convinced at all it was encouraged either. Putin is as bad as they come but I'd say most Western nations would still have preferred not to back a war. Back it they have though and I don't know of any alternative. Those you mentioned previously that cosyied up the the great dictator, well, Johnson, Trump? Says enough about them.
I am not justifying nor backing anything. But unlike today’s monoculture generation I refuse to simply accept that because black is black, white is white.
As someone pretty well travelled and having been to a lot of these places, it really isn’t like that at all. Project Leveson really has hoovered up the majority view on this, and cast any dissent into the wilderness of weirdness/Tateville.
Follow the money and you’ll figure it out. I feel deeply sorry for their people, but all of the Ukraine-flag Facebook decorative icons in the world can’t change that something isn’t right about any of this. Just ask the relatives of MH17.
|