Posts: 2,420
Threads: 158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
(01-03-2024, 04:27 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (01-03-2024, 04:05 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote: (01-03-2024, 03:45 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (01-03-2024, 03:35 PM)Duffers Wrote: (01-03-2024, 03:28 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote: Tulloch is just about to turn 23 and having had various loan spells in League Two without success (friends who are Rochdale fans thought he was awful) I think it's safe to see he's not going to make it. He's out of contract in the summer so I imagine he'll be leaving either this month or in June.
Give it a year and we'll be getting "shouldn't have let him go" posts whenever he scores for Mansfield.
These posts are often overplayed on here.
Sam Field, Iroegbunam, Azaz and potentially TGH (although he had his chance) are the ones it is regularly posted about and it's hard to argue. Looks like Azaz is going to Boro for £2m in the next couple of days.
I've always thought we should have kept Field and I think were it not for Pardew his career could have played out quite differently. Saying that, it's doubtful whether any of the 4 players you mention would get in our team this season with everyone fit (TGH in particular would have only been a bit part player had he stayed).
Sometimes players just need to move on to develop. Chris Wood is the classic example of someone who wouldn't have had the career he's had if he'd been kicking his heels in our reserves for years behind the likes of Odemwingie, Long and Lukaku.
Bit part players are what we are crying out for at the moment. Have you seen some of the XIs listed in the Aldershot thread?
Our obsession with doing everything short-term extends to our treatment of young players, given we've been largely rubbish for the last 2-3 years it is not outrageous to say that the likes of Azaz or Iroegbunam would have been a better option than the likes of Chalobah or Reach - and that's nothing against either of them. Would you rather have had the option of Morgan Rogers, or piss about with another loan signing we'll never hear from again?
Perhaps second half of the season will see our hand forced to use some of the young players and convince them that we're a club worth sticking with.
Add Livermore and Barry to that list, Azaz and Iroegbunam were always going to be better long term bets because of their ages.
I hope we will give some of the kids ago but doubt it, look at the short term signings we have made since relegation
Posts: 357
Threads: 13
Joined: Nov 2023
Reputation:
2
It has been an issue for us for some time now - a number of our youngsters have been sold or released without a full opportunity - there have been some exceptions of course. The issue of giving experienced players long term contracts and the number of short term signings over the last 4/5 years I would say has resulted in players like Azaz etc not being given opportunities to prove themselves properly at the club IMO
Posts: 1,987
Threads: 36
Joined: Jul 2023
Reputation:
4
Did we ever decide when his birthday was? Or was that one of the other World beating kids we had?
Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
I don't think we reward potential enough. Constant short term contracts whilst expecting players to prove themselves for a team that doesn't play them! It leads to situations like Fellows whereby he's finally got the opportunity and his contract is running out. Ferguson was another, three are probably several others too.
We don't have the right career progression path laid out, which probably comes down to money, infrastructure and maybe just not the right people organising it all. A decent contract with big incentive payments and a loan path stepping up the levels. That also means not having to recall them to make-up first team numbers\cover when they're never realistically likely to play, we've been guilty of stunting progression this way.
The most difficult bit is recognising the potential and the player achieving this.
Trump is a Cunt
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(01-04-2024, 11:23 AM)NewWanker Wrote: Did we ever decide when his birthday was? Or was that one of the other World beating kids we had?
It is not about world beaters though, is it? When we let Chris Woods go it was simply because we he would not get a chance as we were at a better level than he was. No one argued and I'm sure we all accept that it is simply our fate that he has since regularly been at a better level than us. No problems. Whereas the others mentioned on this thread are all playing at our level and commanding fees. There is a point when a prospect needs to play 1st team football and we have not timed that right for a number of years. People saying they are nothing special are simply not factoring in the experience, the fitness levels, match sharpness etc. Even established players like Molumby and Swift struggle with a game or two after a break. We are producing professional footballers at Championship level and need to make sure we look at them properly. An example is Palmer who was sent out on loan by Pork Pie Brain last season leaving us with a clown in goal. He would have been let go this season until HE decided he wasn't going.
Posts: 852
Threads: 60
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
10
01-04-2024, 01:07 PM
(This post was last modified: 01-04-2024, 01:08 PM by BurleyBaggie.)
What people forget is many of those aforementioned decided to leave. We can debate the whys and wherefores but ultimately it’s money. Those up the road pay more. We haven’t let these players go in the main they chose to leave.
Just look at that precocious idiot Barry in the Salford documentary. He’s achieved nothing, lit fires barely anywhere, scored 2 in 18 for Salford in that spell and driving around in a top of the range Merc AMG.
We can’t keep blaming the club and hierarchy for everything. On the one hand we blame the club for the wages they give, then here we blame we’ve not done enough to keep them. It’s all a balance these days but the balance sits with the players not the club.
Posts: 10,700
Threads: 674
Joined: Feb 2020
(01-04-2024, 01:07 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: What people forget is many of those aforementioned decided to leave. We can debate the whys and wherefores but ultimately it’s money. Those up the road pay more. We haven’t let these players go in the main they chose to leave.
Just look at that precocious idiot Barry in the Salford documentary. He’s achieved nothing, lit fires barely anywhere, scored 2 in 18 for Salford in that spell and driving around in a top of the range Merc AMG.
We can’t keep blaming the club and hierarchy for everything. On the one hand we blame the club for the wages they give, then here we blame we’ve not done enough to keep them. It’s all a balance these days but the balance sits with the players not the club.
You can lead a horse to water……
The majority of our young prospects leave as they’ tend to be too young to sign a professional contract and their heads are turned by the big clubs, Chelsea, Liverpool. Man City etc and more recently Villa, following ex Albion coaches and other Albion academy players.
There’s nowt we can do to stop this and baldie even questioned the benefit of us running an academy, when players who have been with us for many years, leave for a pittance.
Those players who want to stay, it’s a balancing act by the club to try and determine if a 16 year old has the potential to improve in to a championship level player. If we keep them on and they flop, then we’ve wasted money. If we let them leave and they go on to improve, then that’s hard luck on the club. We can’t afford to keep all our academy players until they’ve reached say 21 and then make a decision on whether they are good enough or not.
Posts: 10,866
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
01-04-2024, 01:59 PM
(This post was last modified: 01-04-2024, 02:00 PM by Peachy.)
(01-04-2024, 01:17 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: (01-04-2024, 01:07 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: What people forget is many of those aforementioned decided to leave. We can debate the whys and wherefores but ultimately it’s money. Those up the road pay more. We haven’t let these players go in the main they chose to leave.
Just look at that precocious idiot Barry in the Salford documentary. He’s achieved nothing, lit fires barely anywhere, scored 2 in 18 for Salford in that spell and driving around in a top of the range Merc AMG.
We can’t keep blaming the club and hierarchy for everything. On the one hand we blame the club for the wages they give, then here we blame we’ve not done enough to keep them. It’s all a balance these days but the balance sits with the players not the club.
You can lead a horse to water……
The majority of our young prospects leave as they’ tend to be too young to sign a professional contract and their heads are turned by the big clubs, Chelsea, Liverpool. Man City etc and more recently Villa, following ex Albion coaches and other Albion academy players.
There’s nowt we can do to stop this and baldie even questioned the benefit of us running an academy, when players who have been with us for many years, leave for a pittance.
Those players who want to stay, it’s a balancing act by the club to try and determine if a 16 year old has the potential to improve in to a championship level player. If we keep them on and they flop, then we’ve wasted money. If we let them leave and they go on to improve, then that’s hard luck on the club. We can’t afford to keep all our academy players until they’ve reached say 21 and then make a decision on whether they are good enough or not.
Agree. In the cases of Tulloch and Azaz we just backed the wrong horse. We fought hard to keep Tulloch and gave him a much better offer than Azaz and he's done bugger all. We gave Azaz a new contract before loaning him to Cheltenham where he did really well. Why we didn't offer him a better contract after that to keep him I'm not sure but Villa came in and offered him more money. No doubt he would have stayed had we offered him a bit more.
It says we released Azaz but that's only after he turned us down.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
I will just never get the angst over young players. There's someone on Twitter now bemoaning us selling Rogers to pay for Slav. Lunacy! Bilic, for all his faults, brought in Pereria and got use promoted. I shudder to think where we would be without that season in the PL.
As has been said upthread, it's always a gamble. We backed Harper and he did v little. Field was always injured at the worst times.
Also, people lie like rugs about wanting to see the youth play, when as soon as they misplace a pass on the pitch, people are soon very quick to grumble.
Posts: 2,927
Threads: 44
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation:
7
(01-04-2024, 04:15 PM)Squid Wrote: I will just never get the angst over young players. There's someone on Twitter now bemoaning us selling Rogers to pay for Slav. Lunacy! Bilic, for all his faults, brought in Pereria and got use promoted. I shudder to think where we would be without that season in the PL.
As has been said upthread, it's always a gamble. We backed Harper and he did v little. Field was always injured at the worst times.
Also, people lie like rugs about wanting to see the youth play, when as soon as they misplace a pass on the pitch, people are soon very quick to grumble.
Generally agree with this. We've got some good fees in very recent years for the likes of Roberts, Rogers, Field, Leko and Harper. Even the 900k for Ferguson is at least something for a player who probably won't play again (I know it should have been a lot more). All of these are players who either haven't yet done anything in their career whereby they've improved on being at the Albion or their careers are on a downward spiral.
Albion have got a lot of things wrong in the last 10 years in terms of transfer policy but I don't feel we've done too badly in terms of knowing which younger players to hold on to and which to let go. You can't get every decision correct. I just hope we can make the most of this coming summer which will allow us to release a number of out of contract players and change to a more progressive policy of bringing in younger players who can be sold on for profit should they develop and give youth players opportunity rather than our fringe players being the likes of Reach and Kelly on high wages.
|