England cricket squad. India 24.
#11
(12-11-2023, 04:00 PM)Cuzer Wrote: He has, but it doesn't

He's not been picked in our test squad for years and Bob Key has come out and said it's not fair on him to tour India as 16th man etc, they clearly don't see him above the others

We just have to accept, ever since Swann rally, we've not really had a world class spinner, and you never need one more than ever out in India

Cuzer

I'm surprised at that. He has experience out there too.
Reply
#12
(12-11-2023, 04:00 PM)Cuzer Wrote: He has, but it doesn't

He's not been picked in our test squad for years and Bob Key has come out and said it's not fair on him to tour India as 16th man etc, they clearly don't see him above the others

We just have to accept, ever since Swann rally, we've not really had a world class spinner, and you never need one more than ever out in India

Cuzer

Part of that is due to the lack of opportunity for spinners in the test side. We spent a good chunk of the post-Swann years ignoring some of our more promising spin bowlers in favour of guys who take their wickets at 40 in the CCC but can bat a bit.
Reply
#13
With Stokes unlikely to bowl bowling very very lightweight!!..This tour will end Anderson’s career fingers crossed for the young spinners.
Vital for Root to bat very well for England to get any kind of positive result from the tour!!.
Reply
#14
(12-11-2023, 04:00 PM)Cuzer Wrote: He has, but it doesn't

He's not been picked in our test squad for years and Bob Key has come out and said it's not fair on him to tour India as 16th man etc, they clearly don't see him above the others

We just have to accept, ever since Swann rally, we've not really had a world class spinner, and you never need one more than ever out in India

Cuzer

Leach is the best we have, no doubt (obviously not in Swann’s class).

But surely you pick your next best in addition to Leach, and base that on first class averages? This has got Mason Crane vibes…
Reply
#15
(12-11-2023, 04:13 PM)pindgill Wrote: With Stokes unlikely to bowl bowling very very lightweight!!..This tour will end Anderson’s career fingers crossed for the young spinners.
Vital for Root to bat very well for England to get any kind of positive result from the tour!!.

Oddly this is as confident as I've been in our batting for a good while (bookmark this for when we're 30-5 on the first morning).

I don't think we have the bowlers to take 20 wickets often enough on Indian pitches. Joe Root will have to bat and bowl well if we're to have any success.
Reply
#16
(12-11-2023, 04:13 PM)pindgill Wrote: With Stokes unlikely to bowl bowling very very lightweight!!..This tour will end Anderson’s career fingers crossed for the young spinners.
Vital for Root to bat very well for England to get any kind of positive result from the tour!!.

I don't think a tour to India on featherbed pictures will define the end of Andersons career personally

He can reverse swing the ball and is always "wicket to wicket" even when not bowling well

He will play this summer in England I'm sure

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#17
Jimmy Anderson is 42 next July he is one of the GOAT.
An India 5 test tour is draining for someone half his age the man has to be respected to want to go on such an arduous tour!!.
Reply
#18
This squad selection looks to me a bit like Sven Goran Eriksson's last hurrah for the 2006 World Cup. Fatally flawed, and wholly indicative of the selector's uselessness.

Left out the most successful English spin bowler of 2023 (Dawson). Picked a man who can't stay fit for love nor money (Robinson) and two geriatrics (Anderson and Wood). Which meant the promising Josh Tongue and Matty Potts don't get on the plane. Because Gus Atkinson is the "New Kid in Town" apparently. The reason for omitting them (and Woakes)? Because Anderson and Robinson can "use reverse swing". Yeah, limping in and bowling at 76mph in the second innings (as they are both prone to do) won't reverse anything other than England's first innings lead, should there be one.

With Foakes in the squad, one wonders if Bairstow will keep wicket as first choice. Best way to blunt the effectiveness of a spin attack. The pressure is really on Root, Pope, Leach and Foakes to play some grown-up cricket, because most of the rest are flaky as fuck with the bat. The Indians will love to see some Stokesy bravado back-firing big time.

The early Bazball fireworks have bought Rob Key some credit and some time, but so many of his cunning plans turn out to be rubbish. Somehow I'm just not feeling the optimism and enthusiasm of this great new era of English cricket. Maybe if we got back to winning matches I would feel better about it all.

And just to rile the flag-wavers even more, let me say that Jimmy Anderson is only there because everyone at the ECB wants to see him get to 700 wickets. Is that a good reason to not pick your best side?
Reply
#19
Whatever happens in this series, it’s worth remembering India have lost two home series in 20 years. It’s bloody hard away in India.

Having said that, taking spinners who have actually taken some wickets in the last year or so (however average they might be), would help.

I genuinely don’t think it matters which seamers we take. They’d all be spanked.

Calling Wood and Anderson a geriatric is a bit silly though. Wood was bloody good in the summer. He’s only 5 months older.
Reply
#20
(12-11-2023, 10:51 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: This squad selection looks to me a bit like Sven Goran Eriksson's last hurrah for the 2006 World Cup. Fatally flawed, and wholly indicative of the selector's uselessness.

Left out the most successful English spin bowler of 2023 (Dawson). Picked a man who can't stay fit for love nor money (Robinson) and two geriatrics (Anderson and Wood). Which meant the promising Josh Tongue and Matty Potts don't get on the plane. Because Gus Atkinson is the "New Kid in Town" apparently. The reason for omitting them (and Woakes)? Because Anderson and Robinson can "use reverse swing". Yeah, limping in and bowling at 76mph in the second innings (as they are both prone to do) won't reverse anything other than England's first innings lead, should there be one.

With Foakes in the squad, one wonders if Bairstow will keep wicket as first choice. Best way to blunt the effectiveness of a spin attack. The pressure is really on Root, Pope, Leach and Foakes to play some grown-up cricket, because most of the rest are flaky as fuck with the bat. The Indians will love to see some Stokesy bravado back-firing big time.

The early Bazball fireworks have bought Rob Key some credit and some time, but so many of his cunning plans turn out to be rubbish. Somehow I'm just not feeling the optimism and enthusiasm of this great new era of English cricket. Maybe if we got back to winning matches I would feel better about it all.

And just to rile the flag-wavers even more, let me say that Jimmy Anderson is only there because everyone at the ECB wants to see him get to 700 wickets. Is that a good reason to not pick your best side?

Seriously harsh this Chesh, what Key/McCullum have done to the test team, from where they inherited it, is off the charts, including the last Ashes series where it's easy to make a case we were much the better side in a drawn series

We know our spin bowling cupboard is bare, Broad has retired, Anderson is showing signs of age but still performs at an admirable level, we've had ridicously bad luck with injuries and therefore key players missing, for me they are both well in credit and a notoriously difficult trip to India shouldn't affect the progress made, regardless of the series score

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: