Musical artists for people not interested in music
#11
(05-25-2023, 02:24 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(05-25-2023, 02:14 PM)Duffers Wrote: As I've grown older I've endeavoured to be more open minded and far less snobbish when it comes to music and accept that just because I don't like something that other people like it's not in any way less valid or worthy.

"Music for people who don't like music" is one such term that's dripping with muso snobbery.

That said Westlife sold shitloads of records despite being terrible.

I think music snobbery is good fun so long as it's relatively light-hearted.

I recently lambasted a mate as wanting to question his gender identity as he accompanied his Mrs to see Take That a few years back.

I went to see Hugh Cornwell of The Stranglers a couple of weeks ago with a pair of music snobs who I knew were bristling to take me on as I'd seen Duran Duran at the O2 a few days beforehand. They really wouldn't have it when I steadfastly said Save a Prayer and Ordinary World are classics.

By the way, thanks for getting on your soapbox re music snobbery and then mentioning Westlife at the end. You redeemed yourself magnificently with that mention.

Don't get me wrong, I absolutely love shitting on bands I can't stand and retain a healthy amount of snobbery.

But what I've come to realise in time is that if you are too snobbish on whether it's music, film, books or whatever, then you end up deliberately excluding yourselves from some fantastic experiences. Things can be good mainly bought by teenage girls and/or Tesco mums, I'll give Harry Styles' last album as an example...

Anyway, Ed Sheeran is definitely another. Glorified fucking busker who is somehow one of the biggest acts on the planet. Fuck happened there?
Reply
#12
(05-25-2023, 02:51 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(05-25-2023, 02:24 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(05-25-2023, 02:14 PM)Duffers Wrote: As I've grown older I've endeavoured to be more open minded and far less snobbish when it comes to music and accept that just because I don't like something that other people like it's not in any way less valid or worthy.

"Music for people who don't like music" is one such term that's dripping with muso snobbery.

That said Westlife sold shitloads of records despite being terrible.

I think music snobbery is good fun so long as it's relatively light-hearted.

I recently lambasted a mate as wanting to question his gender identity as he accompanied his Mrs to see Take That a few years back.

I went to see Hugh Cornwell of The Stranglers a couple of weeks ago with a pair of music snobs who I knew were bristling to take me on as I'd seen Duran Duran at the O2 a few days beforehand. They really wouldn't have it when I steadfastly said Save a Prayer and Ordinary World are classics.

By the way, thanks for getting on your soapbox re music snobbery and then mentioning Westlife at the end. You redeemed yourself magnificently with that mention.

Don't get me wrong, I absolutely love shitting on bands I can't stand and retain a healthy amount of snobbery.

But what I've come to realise in time is that if you are too snobbish on whether it's music, film, books or whatever, then you end up deliberately excluding yourselves from some fantastic experiences. Things can be good mainly bought by teenage girls and/or Tesco mums, I'll give Harry Styles' last album as an example...

Anyway, Ed Sheeran is definitely another. Glorified fucking busker who is somehow one of the biggest acts on the planet. Fuck happened there?

I accidentally came across the song Golden by Harry Style when it was on in a shop and I Shazamed it as I thought this is very good.
I do like some guilty pleasures and have been known to even defend Cliff Richard on this very bored!
Reply
#13
My idea of the sort of music snobbery that is allowed -or even to be encouraged- is deriding formulaic music by algorithm type commercialism. Example, Stock, Aitkin, Waterman. It worked once so we'll remake it a 100 times. There are so many that fall into this, some decent musicians and singers included, but most are simply lazy one trick ponies. Unimaginative drivel. The charts is normally full of them.
Reply
#14
(05-25-2023, 02:46 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(05-25-2023, 02:14 PM)Duffers Wrote: As I've grown older I've endeavoured to be more open minded and far less snobbish when it comes to music and accept that just because I don't like something that other people like it's not in any way less valid or worthy.

"Music for people who don't like music" is one such term that's dripping with muso snobbery.

That said Westlife sold shitloads of records despite being terrible.

I use that phrase as a joke mind, even more so if it winds someone up enough.

Coldplay are sort of the epitome of that sort of band, but I also know some very knowledgeable musicians who are really into music love them. Though they usually have a good sense of humour about the jokes like above 

It's when people think stupid shit like "I'm too knowledgeable to be into this artist." Is when that person is just a cunt.

I'm heavily into my music, but I like some very accessible, easy listening artists too because, well, it's easy to listen to and is fun. There are times I'd rather listen to something accessible and a sing along rather than some 15 minute prog masterpiece.

Yeah it's this sort of snobbery that I rail against.
Reply
#15
It's snobbery that's rife in the heavy rock and metal cultures. Honestly, it just gets boring that every band is judged by some weird scale, and you can't like metal if you like some particular band and stupid shit like that. It's just stupid.
Reply
#16
(05-25-2023, 03:25 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: It's snobbery that's rife in the heavy rock and metal cultures. Honestly, it just gets boring that every band is judged by some weird scale, and you can't like metal if you like some particular band and stupid shit like that. It's just stupid.

That is the genre this applies to most. As a kid if you met a Led Zeppelin, Yes, Black Sabbath fan you could expect this in spadefuls. 

I do know some terrible indie snobs though. 

There is a particular music snob who instantly recoils at anything that has mass mainstream success. I love it though when I hear stuff like Johnny Rotten adored Abba and Noel Gallagher is a fan of A-Ha.
Reply
#17
(05-25-2023, 03:25 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: It's snobbery that's rife in the heavy rock and metal cultures. Honestly, it just gets boring that every band is judged by some weird scale, and you can't like metal if you like some particular band and stupid shit like that. It's just stupid.

Are you trying to say you don't like the band Butthole Surfers?
Reply
#18
The "I hate anything that's mainstream and popular" snobs are the fucking worst.

The crusty "guitar music achieved perfection with Pink Floyd/Genesis/other 70's bands" snobs are a close second.
Reply
#19
It's not the snobbery necessarily in metal circles it's the "OMG you moron, it's not melodic death metal, it's neo-classical doom metal how could you even think they're similar!"

People fucking love tribalism don't they...

A lot of the Coldplay/Sheeran hate is just popular=bad bollocks. They write and play all their own songs which is more than can be said for 90% of pop stars. I always say that if you'd never heard of them and came across Ed Sheeran or Chris Martin at some grotty pub open-mic night you'd be blown away.
Reply
#20
(05-25-2023, 03:33 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: It's not the snobbery necessarily in metal circles it's the "OMG you moron, it's not melodic death metal, it's neo-classical doom metal how could you even think they're similar!"

People fucking love tribalism don't they...

Only a fool would confuse those tbf...
In the form of his life.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)