Former Reading DoF slams Gourlay
#11
(05-16-2023, 01:46 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: That whole Reading debacle was a disaster from the first minute - the club had massively overachieved during the 16/17 season with Stam having done a really good job and the club decided to throw some big money at another promotion push and got it very wrong.

The signings they made were very obvious Championship players that anyone who'd watched a few episodes on Quest would have spotted - so  very similar to here - and there was little or no resale value in any of them.

I'm sure Gourlay has learned some tough lessons from that spell, but I would be lying if I said I wasn't worried that our transfer business will continue to be lazy, agent driven acquisitions based entirely on whether or not he's heard of them.

This

Lets judge RG on his merits and time here.  As Birdy stated - he gets credit for CC and the current alternative is another of the faceless shysters behind our fugging  owners.   But unless there is a real improvement in our Recruitment Dept - RG will (quite rightly) get criticism.
Reply
#12
Reading fans don’t like Gourlay, but they really don’t like Tevreden
Reply
#13
(05-16-2023, 04:00 PM)MancBaggie Wrote:
(05-16-2023, 01:46 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: That whole Reading debacle was a disaster from the first minute - the club had massively overachieved during the 16/17 season with Stam having done a really good job and the club decided to throw some big money at another promotion push and got it very wrong.

The signings they made were very obvious Championship players that anyone who'd watched a few episodes on Quest would have spotted - so  very similar to here - and there was little or no resale value in any of them.

I'm sure Gourlay has learned some tough lessons from that spell, but I would be lying if I said I wasn't worried that our transfer business will continue to be lazy, agent driven acquisitions based entirely on whether or not he's heard of them.

This

Lets judge RG on his merits and time here.  As Birdy stated - he gets credit for CC and the current alternative is another of the faceless shysters behind our fugging  owners.   But unless there is a real improvement in our Recruitment Dept - RG will (quite rightly) get criticism.

Manc I expect us to do well in the market.

Main thing is we need to nail the 2 PL loans
Reply
#14
The big question is have Reading done better since RG left ?
That's a no then.
Reply
#15
(05-16-2023, 04:35 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: The big question is have Reading done better since RG left ?
That's a no then.

They have been rather hamstrung since then!
Reply
#16
Spandaubaggie Wrote:This is a typical post where those who still haven't forgiven Gourlay for appointing Bruce wade in.

I know Gourlay got a lot of blame for Reading's woe, but when things go wrong at clubs they need the spacegoat.

I've not been one for the sarcastic deriding posts of Gourlay as everyone deserves his chance and whoever allowed 4 years of Ishmael is far more a clown than he is.

Most of our issues stem from before Gourlay's time. He cocked up with Bruce but he's evened it out in my eyes with CC.

This guy at Reading, who gives a shit really? It's grade D footie gossip and nowt more.
Except no one has, Spandau!
For most of us it's currently one all, the appointment of CC being the equaliser. I fear we'll struggle whoever is CEO until there is a proper DoF dept with an appropriate budget. It's not exactly brain surgery. Identify good players, check out their character, place an appropriate value on them. I can't help thinking there are a lot employed in football that are riding the gravy train.
Reply
#17
(05-16-2023, 04:29 PM)Super-Okay Wrote:
(05-16-2023, 04:00 PM)MancBaggie Wrote:
(05-16-2023, 01:46 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: That whole Reading debacle was a disaster from the first minute - the club had massively overachieved during the 16/17 season with Stam having done a really good job and the club decided to throw some big money at another promotion push and got it very wrong.

The signings they made were very obvious Championship players that anyone who'd watched a few episodes on Quest would have spotted - so  very similar to here - and there was little or no resale value in any of them.

I'm sure Gourlay has learned some tough lessons from that spell, but I would be lying if I said I wasn't worried that our transfer business will continue to be lazy, agent driven acquisitions based entirely on whether or not he's heard of them.

This

Lets judge RG on his merits and time here.  As Birdy stated - he gets credit for CC and the current alternative is another of the faceless shysters behind our fugging  owners.   But unless there is a real improvement in our Recruitment Dept - RG will (quite rightly) get criticism.

Manc I expect us to do well in the market.

Main thing is we need to nail the 2 PL loans

That 2nd line is the big if.  

We need something akin to a Diallo and Tella - instead of some old crock on a meal ticket
Reply
#18
(05-16-2023, 05:28 PM)MancBaggie Wrote:
(05-16-2023, 04:29 PM)Super-Okay Wrote:
(05-16-2023, 04:00 PM)MancBaggie Wrote:
(05-16-2023, 01:46 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: That whole Reading debacle was a disaster from the first minute - the club had massively overachieved during the 16/17 season with Stam having done a really good job and the club decided to throw some big money at another promotion push and got it very wrong.

The signings they made were very obvious Championship players that anyone who'd watched a few episodes on Quest would have spotted - so  very similar to here - and there was little or no resale value in any of them.

I'm sure Gourlay has learned some tough lessons from that spell, but I would be lying if I said I wasn't worried that our transfer business will continue to be lazy, agent driven acquisitions based entirely on whether or not he's heard of them.

This

Lets judge RG on his merits and time here.  As Birdy stated - he gets credit for CC and the current alternative is another of the faceless shysters behind our fugging  owners.   But unless there is a real improvement in our Recruitment Dept - RG will (quite rightly) get criticism.

Manc I expect us to do well in the market.

Main thing is we need to nail the 2 PL loans

That 2nd line is the big if.  

We need something akin to a Diallo and Tella - instead of some old crock on a meal ticket

Yup
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)