Ian Pearce
#11
I'm sorry, perhaps its me, but I don't get this.

Last Summer we sign two of the best free's available in the division in Wallace & Swift. Pieters has been a good signing. BTA has proven to be good value. Two good loans were identified in August, and you won't convince me otherwise that finances didn't play a part in the failure to complete those signings. We had a budget, and we used it. Quality kids from City & Chelsea cost money, and we know we don't have much of that. I think Bruce got the targets he wanted, and most of them worked out. Signing Kelly on a 2 year deal was a mistake - but the club successfully shipped him out in January.

The January acquisitions didn't work out, but Chalobah was starting to find some form before injury. We will skip past Albrighton.

Yes there have been some mistakes, but it is suggested that Bilac led the charge for Grant. Grady was a signing that offered plenty, but hasn't quite worked out. Zohore has been a disaster. Equally, he was in charge of recruitment when Pereira walked through the door.

Overall I think he has done ok. Not great, not terribly.
Reply
#12
(04-27-2023, 09:16 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: I'm sorry, perhaps its me, but I don't get this.

Last Summer we sign two of the best free's available in the division in Wallace & Swift. Pieters has been a good signing. BTA has proven to be good value. Two good loans were identified in August, and you won't convince me otherwise that finances didn't play a part in the failure to complete those signings. We had a budget, and we used it. Quality kids from City & Chelsea cost money, and we know we don't have much of that. I think Bruce got the targets he wanted, and most of them worked out. Signing Kelly on a 2 year deal was a mistake - but the club successfully shipped him out in January.

The January acquisitions didn't work out, but Chalobah was starting to find some form before injury. We will skip past Albrighton.

Yes there have been some mistakes, but it is suggested that Bilac led the charge for Grant. Grady was a signing that offered plenty, but hasn't quite worked out. Zohore has been a disaster. Equally, he was in charge of recruitment when Pereira walked through the door.

Overall I think he has done ok. Not great, not terribly.

Come on, he's done OK ? Your just on the wind up aren't you.
Reply
#13
(04-27-2023, 09:22 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(04-27-2023, 09:16 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: I'm sorry, perhaps its me, but I don't get this.

Last Summer we sign two of the best free's available in the division in Wallace & Swift. Pieters has been a good signing. BTA has proven to be good value. Two good loans were identified in August, and you won't convince me otherwise that finances didn't play a part in the failure to complete those signings. We had a budget, and we used it. Quality kids from City & Chelsea cost money, and we know we don't have much of that. I think Bruce got the targets he wanted, and most of them worked out. Signing Kelly on a 2 year deal was a mistake - but the club successfully shipped him out in January.

The January acquisitions didn't work out, but Chalobah was starting to find some form before injury. We will skip past Albrighton.

Yes there have been some mistakes, but it is suggested that Bilac led the charge for Grant. Grady was a signing that offered plenty, but hasn't quite worked out. Zohore has been a disaster. Equally, he was in charge of recruitment when Pereira walked through the door.

Overall I think he has done ok. Not great, not terribly.

Come on, he's done OK ? Your just on the wind up aren't you.

I think he has signed as many good players as bad ones. Don't under-estimate the roll of the Manager in some of these signings (good and bad) as well.
Reply
#14
I really don't know the answer but simply we had the Dan Ashworth/Jeremy Peace manual of how to run a club of our size brilliantly. It seems bewildering we've lost that expertise and we need to get back some of that knowledge.
For those who want to lambast Peace, in the near 20 years he ran the club we never finished outside the playoffs.
We should be bending over backwards to get the experts in to see what we need to do to get back to the club we had been.
Reply
#15
(04-27-2023, 09:26 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: I really don't know the answer but simply we had the Dan Ashworth/Jeremy Peace manual of how to run a club of our size brilliantly. It seems bewildering we've lost that expertise and we need to get back some of that knowledge.
For those who want to lambast Peace, in the near 20 years he ran the club we never finished outside the playoffs.
We should be bending over backwards to get the experts in to see what we need to do to get back to the club we had been.

Not everyone DAshworth signed came off. Admittedly his record was far better than Pearce, thats why he ended up with a top job at the FA and Man Utd wanted him. Those type of people land once in a lifetime.
Reply
#16
(04-27-2023, 09:25 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(04-27-2023, 09:22 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(04-27-2023, 09:16 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: I'm sorry, perhaps its me, but I don't get this.

Last Summer we sign two of the best free's available in the division in Wallace & Swift. Pieters has been a good signing. BTA has proven to be good value. Two good loans were identified in August, and you won't convince me otherwise that finances didn't play a part in the failure to complete those signings. We had a budget, and we used it. Quality kids from City & Chelsea cost money, and we know we don't have much of that. I think Bruce got the targets he wanted, and most of them worked out. Signing Kelly on a 2 year deal was a mistake - but the club successfully shipped him out in January.

The January acquisitions didn't work out, but Chalobah was starting to find some form before injury. We will skip past Albrighton.

Yes there have been some mistakes, but it is suggested that Bilac led the charge for Grant. Grady was a signing that offered plenty, but hasn't quite worked out. Zohore has been a disaster. Equally, he was in charge of recruitment when Pereira walked through the door.

Overall I think he has done ok. Not great, not terribly.

Come on, he's done OK ? Your just on the wind up aren't you.

I think he has signed as many good players as bad ones. Don't under-estimate the roll of the Manager in some of these signings (good and bad) as well.

Ok players weak as piss in mindset
Reply
#17
(04-27-2023, 09:22 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(04-27-2023, 09:16 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: I'm sorry, perhaps its me, but I don't get this.

Last Summer we sign two of the best free's available in the division in Wallace & Swift. Pieters has been a good signing. BTA has proven to be good value. Two good loans were identified in August, and you won't convince me otherwise that finances didn't play a part in the failure to complete those signings. We had a budget, and we used it. Quality kids from City & Chelsea cost money, and we know we don't have much of that. I think Bruce got the targets he wanted, and most of them worked out. Signing Kelly on a 2 year deal was a mistake - but the club successfully shipped him out in January.

The January acquisitions didn't work out, but Chalobah was starting to find some form before injury. We will skip past Albrighton.

Yes there have been some mistakes, but it is suggested that Bilac led the charge for Grant. Grady was a signing that offered plenty, but hasn't quite worked out. Zohore has been a disaster. Equally, he was in charge of recruitment when Pereira walked through the door.

Overall I think he has done ok. Not great, not terribly.

Come on, he's done OK ? Your just on the wind up aren't you.

The signings we’ve made have been OK. We’ve made some good ones and some bad ones, but no great ones.

My frustration is around the laziness of our signings. We sign players that half our fan base could locate and suggest. For a club with our resources, we have to be ultra competitive on recruitment, it’s the one way to generate additional income and we just don’t seem remotely interested in looking beyond “decent pros” and players doing well in our current division, or those out of favour in the league above.

Going back over the last 10 years, the signings we’ve made that have worked out have been the ones who want to be here and who see us as a stepping stone to improve. We just aren’t making those signings anymore and instead seem to be signing players who feel they’re doing us a favour by being here. We got lazy under Pulis and that rot has stayed ever since.
Reply
#18
(04-27-2023, 09:31 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-27-2023, 09:22 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(04-27-2023, 09:16 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: I'm sorry, perhaps its me, but I don't get this.

Last Summer we sign two of the best free's available in the division in Wallace & Swift. Pieters has been a good signing. BTA has proven to be good value. Two good loans were identified in August, and you won't convince me otherwise that finances didn't play a part in the failure to complete those signings. We had a budget, and we used it. Quality kids from City & Chelsea cost money, and we know we don't have much of that. I think Bruce got the targets he wanted, and most of them worked out. Signing Kelly on a 2 year deal was a mistake - but the club successfully shipped him out in January.

The January acquisitions didn't work out, but Chalobah was starting to find some form before injury. We will skip past Albrighton.

Yes there have been some mistakes, but it is suggested that Bilac led the charge for Grant. Grady was a signing that offered plenty, but hasn't quite worked out. Zohore has been a disaster. Equally, he was in charge of recruitment when Pereira walked through the door.

Overall I think he has done ok. Not great, not terribly.

Come on, he's done OK ? Your just on the wind up aren't you.

The signings we’ve made have been OK. We’ve made some good ones and some bad ones, but no great ones.

My frustration is around the laziness of our signings. We sign players that half our fan base could locate and suggest. For a club with our resources, we have to be ultra competitive on recruitment, it’s the one way to generate additional income and we just don’t seem remotely interested in looking beyond “decent pros” and players doing well in our current division, or those out of favour in the league above.

Going back over the last 10 years, the signings we’ve made that have worked out have been the ones who want to be here and who see us as a stepping stone to improve. We just aren’t making those signings anymore and instead seem to be signing players who feel they’re doing us a favour by being here. We got lazy under Pulis and that rot has stayed ever since.

I don't disagree with that, SW4. Do we know what Pearce's remit is though? Perhaps that comes down to Ron to tell him the type (age, experience etc)of players to sign. I don't know the answers. Perhaps Pearce is driving the recruitment style.
Reply
#19
(04-27-2023, 09:16 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: I'm sorry, perhaps its me, but I don't get this.

Last Summer we sign two of the best free's available in the division in Wallace & Swift. Pieters has been a good signing. BTA has proven to be good value. Two good loans were identified in August, and you won't convince me otherwise that finances didn't play a part in the failure to complete those signings. We had a budget, and we used it. Quality kids from City & Chelsea cost money, and we know we don't have much of that. I think Bruce got the targets he wanted, and most of them worked out. Signing Kelly on a 2 year deal was a mistake - but the club successfully shipped him out in January.

The January acquisitions didn't work out, but Chalobah was starting to find some form before injury. We will skip past Albrighton.

Yes there have been some mistakes, but it is suggested that Bilac led the charge for Grant. Grady was a signing that offered plenty, but hasn't quite worked out. Zohore has been a disaster. Equally, he was in charge of recruitment when Pereira walked through the door.

Overall I think he has done ok. Not great, not terribly.
Yes.
Most of the disagreement on here is hindsight.
Noone ever, from SAF down, gets 100 % recruitment right. That includes Megson, Ashworth.
Our problems are deeper rooted. In China.
Reply
#20
(04-27-2023, 09:37 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(04-27-2023, 09:31 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-27-2023, 09:22 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(04-27-2023, 09:16 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: I'm sorry, perhaps its me, but I don't get this.

Last Summer we sign two of the best free's available in the division in Wallace & Swift. Pieters has been a good signing. BTA has proven to be good value. Two good loans were identified in August, and you won't convince me otherwise that finances didn't play a part in the failure to complete those signings. We had a budget, and we used it. Quality kids from City & Chelsea cost money, and we know we don't have much of that. I think Bruce got the targets he wanted, and most of them worked out. Signing Kelly on a 2 year deal was a mistake - but the club successfully shipped him out in January.

The January acquisitions didn't work out, but Chalobah was starting to find some form before injury. We will skip past Albrighton.

Yes there have been some mistakes, but it is suggested that Bilac led the charge for Grant. Grady was a signing that offered plenty, but hasn't quite worked out. Zohore has been a disaster. Equally, he was in charge of recruitment when Pereira walked through the door.

Overall I think he has done ok. Not great, not terribly.

Come on, he's done OK ? Your just on the wind up aren't you.

The signings we’ve made have been OK. We’ve made some good ones and some bad ones, but no great ones.

My frustration is around the laziness of our signings. We sign players that half our fan base could locate and suggest. For a club with our resources, we have to be ultra competitive on recruitment, it’s the one way to generate additional income and we just don’t seem remotely interested in looking beyond “decent pros” and players doing well in our current division, or those out of favour in the league above.

Going back over the last 10 years, the signings we’ve made that have worked out have been the ones who want to be here and who see us as a stepping stone to improve. We just aren’t making those signings anymore and instead seem to be signing players who feel they’re doing us a favour by being here. We got lazy under Pulis and that rot has stayed ever since.

I don't disagree with that, SW4. Do we know what Pearce's remit is though? Perhaps that comes down to Ron to tell him the type (age, experience etc)of players to sign. I don't know the answers. Perhaps Pearce is driving the recruitment style.

Exactly. Who sets the parameters? For me, Pearce should be doing that, but I doubt he is.

What is our scouting process, how do we gather data, which markets are we tracking, how do we assess and categorise players, and how do we feed this into the coaching staff? These are questions we just don’t know the answers to. For all we know, Pearce’s team could be finding tonnes of players but their recommendations are being overruled… there was an article that alleged this was happening regularly under Slav for example. 

My gut feel is that we lazily work with a group of preferred agents and just take their recommendations and use our software and system to validate from their clients who is the best fit instead of actively mining players and building our own database to pluck from which is what we were so successful at under Ashworth.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: