Jos Buttler 'Mankad' dismissal: England batsman controversially run out in IPL
#11
(03-25-2019, 08:48 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-25-2019, 07:54 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote:
(03-25-2019, 07:39 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: I used to be firmly in the “Mankad is unsporting” school, which was always within the laws of the game but not within the spirit of the game.

A couple of years ago the laws were changed to make it very clear that a batsman is trying to gain an advantage by stealing ground, and that it should no longer be considered “unsporting” to run out the batsman who is trying to do just that.  

For those of us grew up under “the spirit of cricket” we have to accept that the game has moved on.

However, on this occasion the umpire was wrong to give it out because Ashwin’s front food had already landed and he was therefore past the point at which he should be completing the delivery of the ball. Buttler was not trying to gain an advantage here and was not stealing ground. It should have been given not out under the new laws.   Nothing to do with the spirit of the game.

Good post. Difficult to argue. 

Broad not walking was fucking hilarious, though!

That’s still one for “spirit of cricket”!

Funny as fook
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IBJL1H84Y2A
Reply
#12
Is this any worse than when Sidebottom barged Grant Elliott during a quick single and despite the latter being floored, England fielders proceeded to run him out?

Not even close to being as bad as that incident.
Reply
#13
It's been explained on Talkshite by David Lloyd. It should have been not out due to the bowler stopping the play at the point of release of the ball. It's the rules
Reply
#14
(03-26-2019, 01:02 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote: It's been explained on Talkshite by David Lloyd. It should have been not out due to the bowler stopping the play at the point of release of the ball. It's the rules
Then surely the elite 3rd umpire should have known that? 

i would trust a current umpire to be more familiar with the law as it stands than Bumble.

Former Australia Test batsman Dean Jones lent his support to Ashwin, and emphasised the legality of the move. “Please everyone ... read the new laws ... a bowler does not have to offer a warning to the batsman,” Jones tweeted.
The term Mankading was first coined after India’s tour of Australia in 1947-48, when Mankad twice dismissed Bill Brown, in a game against an Australian XI and in the second Test match.
Buttler has been the victim of a Mankad dismissal before, by Sachithra Senanayake during an ODI against Sri Lanka at Edgbaston in 2014. At the time Buttler admitted it was his own fault and that “it is all part of the game”.
Reply
#15
David Lloyd is a former Test batsman, former England coach, former England selector, excellent pundit AND a former umpire. I think its safe to trust his view point!
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
#16
Rules are rules

Footballers don’t ask referees to rule out incorrectly awarded goals - how is this different?
Reply
#17
(03-26-2019, 01:32 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(03-26-2019, 01:02 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote: It's been explained on Talkshite by David Lloyd. It should have been not out due to the bowler stopping the play at the point of release of the ball. It's the rules
Then surely the elite 3rd umpire should have known that? 

i would trust a current umpire to be more familiar with the law as it stands than Bumble.

Former Australia Test batsman Dean Jones lent his support to Ashwin, and emphasised the legality of the move. “Please everyone ... read the new laws ... a bowler does not have to offer a warning to the batsman,” Jones tweeted.
The term Mankading was first coined after India’s tour of Australia in 1947-48, when Mankad twice dismissed Bill Brown, in a game against an Australian XI and in the second Test match.
Buttler has been the victim of a Mankad dismissal before, by Sachithra Senanayake during an ODI against Sri Lanka at Edgbaston in 2014. At the time Buttler admitted it was his own fault and that “it is all part of the game”.

Truthfully Mon I couldn't give a shite. I was just relaying what I heard. Let Bumble know about his mistake at #iknowmorethanyou
Reply
#18
(03-26-2019, 04:32 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(03-26-2019, 03:45 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote:
(03-26-2019, 01:32 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(03-26-2019, 01:02 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote: It's been explained on Talkshite by David Lloyd. It should have been not out due to the bowler stopping the play at the point of release of the ball. It's the rules
Then surely the elite 3rd umpire should have known that? 

i would trust a current umpire to be more familiar with the law as it stands than Bumble.

Former Australia Test batsman Dean Jones lent his support to Ashwin, and emphasised the legality of the move. “Please everyone ... read the new laws ... a bowler does not have to offer a warning to the batsman,” Jones tweeted.
The term Mankading was first coined after India’s tour of Australia in 1947-48, when Mankad twice dismissed Bill Brown, in a game against an Australian XI and in the second Test match.
Buttler has been the victim of a Mankad dismissal before, by Sachithra Senanayake during an ODI against Sri Lanka at Edgbaston in 2014. At the time Buttler admitted it was his own fault and that “it is all part of the game”.

Truthfully Mon I couldn't give a shite. I was just relaying what I heard. Let Bumble know about his mistake at #iknowmorethanyou
That's one way of saying 'I hear ya but I don't wanna believe ya''. It's about knowing the CURRENT laws ..not those that were applied a former this n that n the other.
Nope. It's exactly what I said.

Another stoopid ex cricketer

[Image: bjPwqtI4_normal.jpg]
[/url]Shane Warne

✔@ShaneWarne


[url=https://twitter.com/ShaneWarne/status/1110256662760300547]



So disappointed in @ashwinravi99 as a Captain & as a person. All captains sign the #IPL wall & agree to play in the spirit of the game. RA had no intention of delivering the ball - so it should have been called a dead ball. Over to u BCCI - this a not a good look for the #IPL
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: