Telegraph front page
#11
(11-27-2022, 10:51 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote:
(11-27-2022, 10:50 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(11-27-2022, 10:48 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Kane had an off game but he’s such a good footballer, not just a goalscorer. He failed to score on Monday but had a hand in most of the goals somehow. He can be allowed one dud performance after that, not to mention his record and unquestionable work-ethic.

The bigger question here of course is why he isn’t performing, and why he didn’t early in the last tournament. And it’s the Southgate elephant in the room again. Whilst Southgate is a disciplinarian, I don’t think he really puts fire in anyone’s belly, and with all of the players mentioned above we should be finding out away to unlock the pressure/ask questions of teams like US of A.

What does that even mean?

Too many words for a Sunday?

One poor game and suddenly Southgate can’t motivate the players? 

Are we ignoring our two best tournament performances for the last 25 years? Getting to a semi final with the likes of Lingard and Dele Alli in the side; fucking Ashley Young at left wing back too…
Reply
#12
People are getting over-excited about this. Kane didn't look fit. When he plays well, the team plays around him. When he doesn't, we don't create chances. This is the problem with having a centre-forward for captain - his form is central to the performance, but he gets to play anyway because he's skipper.

So yes, time to rest him. The Foden issue is separate. The midfield were devoid of ideas on Friday, so change it. I don't think Southgate is very good at innovation or change. I suspect the most senior players are very close to him and he can't easily make the tough decisions.
Reply
#13
I don't think I should comment on England games as I really don't give a toss.

But Kane it trying to do too much.  He could have been told to push up and play on their centre backs' shoulders all game and stay there.  That would have taken two of them out as they would have been scared of the through ball.  That would have left more room for the mid field to work in.

But because he is such a team player, when he's not getting the ball he feels obliged to drop into the congested midfield to try and help and get something moving.  This means there is no one to pass to anyway should he get the ball,  and their centre backs are free to do their job easily as the ball is always in front of them. 

But I know fuck all about football so what do I know.  

And Bono still can't sing.
Reply
#14
(11-27-2022, 11:03 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(11-27-2022, 10:51 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote:
(11-27-2022, 10:50 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(11-27-2022, 10:48 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Kane had an off game but he’s such a good footballer, not just a goalscorer. He failed to score on Monday but had a hand in most of the goals somehow. He can be allowed one dud performance after that, not to mention his record and unquestionable work-ethic.

The bigger question here of course is why he isn’t performing, and why he didn’t early in the last tournament. And it’s the Southgate elephant in the room again. Whilst Southgate is a disciplinarian, I don’t think he really puts fire in anyone’s belly, and with all of the players mentioned above we should be finding out away to unlock the pressure/ask questions of teams like US of A.

What does that even mean?

Too many words for a Sunday?

One poor game and suddenly Southgate can’t motivate the players? 

Are we ignoring our two best tournament performances for the last 25 years? Getting to a semi final with the likes of Lingard and Dele Alli in the side; fucking Ashley Young at left wing back too…

Erm... what?

One sentence and you know my entire viewpoint on the subject? OK, you're good. 

I think Southgate has worked wonders for England personally. The FIFA rankings show it, the appetite and attitude of the players demonstrate it, and after iteration upon iteration of off-the-peg decorated, but otherwise-shite Euroflop managers, he's gone from literally most of us having stopped caring, to caring again. So yes, while he's only guilty of exceeding expectations if anything, he does have a bloody good sqaud to play with still. Which - yes - he does know best, as evidenced by taking Maguire after the 12 months or so he's had. Proves what everyone else knows. 

But that doesn't make him immune from criticism. Bar Monday, we have been poor of late, and we were poor on Friday. But no one can deny the progress and achievements as you say, as this is still as much his tournament to win as it is job to lose. 

So assuming you understand what this post means, by all means have it out with someone who wants him to fail? Because I certainly don't. I'm just not as polarised on the issue as you seemingly have to be these days.

Hopefully we show a bit of flair and guile in smashing Wales, and hit the knockout phase with our tails up. There is a fantastic side if he can select and instruct it right. Again as the rankings - maybe not in all the big games that matter, but on average - show he is best at.
Reply
#15
(11-27-2022, 08:57 AM)SophLad Wrote: “Start Foden and drop Kane, says Cole”

Joe Cole has spoken, Gareth.

Read that as "Start Foden and drop Keane" say Cole.

As football pundits go give me Keane any day of the week, although he could do with a shave, dont they sell razors in quatar?

It's been a long day.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: