fao rsbaggy2
#11
It has been suggested that players should be warned by bowler or opposing non-striking batsmen/women that they're in danger of being run out if they do leave the crease too often too early. Perhaps that might be a worthwhile rule to be added to the laws of the game?
Reply
#12
(09-25-2022, 09:16 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: It has been suggested that players should be warned by bowler or opposing non-striking batsmen/women that they're in danger of being run out if they do leave the crease too often too early.  Perhaps that might be a worthwhile rule to be added to the laws of the game?

It is amazing, given it's controversial nature, that when the rules were made clearer and allowed this kind of dismissal, it was not included then.
Reply
#13
(09-25-2022, 06:44 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(09-25-2022, 12:04 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Aren't India supportive of Russia in the illegal invasion of Ukraine?

Just asking.

WTF has that got to do with the ill feeling left by yesterday's game? 
Post on the political board if you wish to.

And why haven’t you fixed the caste system yet?
Reply
#14
(09-25-2022, 09:31 AM)SophLad Wrote:
(09-25-2022, 06:44 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(09-25-2022, 12:04 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Aren't India supportive of Russia in the illegal invasion of Ukraine?

Just asking.

WTF has that got to do with the ill feeling left by yesterday's game? 
Post on the political board if you wish to.

And why haven’t you fixed the caste system yet?

We are waiting the return of certain valuables. Then we can fix that too!  Big Grin
Reply
#15
(09-25-2022, 09:16 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: It has been suggested that players should be warned by bowler or opposing non-striking batsmen/women that they're in danger of being run out if they do leave the crease too often too early.  Perhaps that might be a worthwhile rule to be added to the laws of the game?

Exactly this. A bit like a foot fault in tennis. They don’t give them the entire game/set for what’s a minimal attempted advantage gain, which is often a more a competitive reaction than a knowingly dishonest attempt to gain such advantage.
Reply
#16
(09-25-2022, 08:52 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: There are a few aspects of this which stand out for me.

  • The captain definitely gave Sharma the nod to do it. Worried that they might not get the wicket any other way, desperate to win, despite being 2-0 up in the series.
  • The England batter wasn't trying to steal an advantage, her bat was grounded behind the crease as the bowler went into her "delivery stride".
  • The bowler clearly intended to deceive the batter into thinking she'd released the ball, wasn't even looking down the wicket as she shaped up to "bowl".
  • The self-congratulatory hysterics of the Indian team were insulting.
  • The joyous crowd scenes were unsurprising and rather charmless.
  • The England women behaved with rather more dignity than I could have mustered in similar circumstances. Imagine someone doing that to Stuart Broad?
  • The Indian press was full of jubilation, describing it as a "brilliant run-out".
For me, this takes the unpopular "Mankad" to a new level - not punishing a non-striking batter for cheating by backing up too far, but deliberately deceiving them. Does Sharma practice this move? To put it in football terms, it's like praising a player for "drawing a foul", or the old Bergkamp favourite "I felt a touch so I went down".


And it says all we need to know about the post-Colonial chip on the Indian shoulder. Sad that our great game is now owned lock, stock and barrel by them.

I’ve played and always watched the ball be bowled, she strolled down the wicket oblivious to what was happening. I’ve no problem with it. Stay in your bloody crease.
Reply
#17
(09-25-2022, 10:41 AM)KRO Wrote:
(09-25-2022, 08:52 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: There are a few aspects of this which stand out for me.

  • The captain definitely gave Sharma the nod to do it. Worried that they might not get the wicket any other way, desperate to win, despite being 2-0 up in the series.
  • The England batter wasn't trying to steal an advantage, her bat was grounded behind the crease as the bowler went into her "delivery stride".
  • The bowler clearly intended to deceive the batter into thinking she'd released the ball, wasn't even looking down the wicket as she shaped up to "bowl".
  • The self-congratulatory hysterics of the Indian team were insulting.
  • The joyous crowd scenes were unsurprising and rather charmless.
  • The England women behaved with rather more dignity than I could have mustered in similar circumstances. Imagine someone doing that to Stuart Broad?
  • The Indian press was full of jubilation, describing it as a "brilliant run-out".
For me, this takes the unpopular "Mankad" to a new level - not punishing a non-striking batter for cheating by backing up too far, but deliberately deceiving them. Does Sharma practice this move? To put it in football terms, it's like praising a player for "drawing a foul", or the old Bergkamp favourite "I felt a touch so I went down".


And it says all we need to know about the post-Colonial chip on the Indian shoulder. Sad that our great game is now owned lock, stock and barrel by them.

I’ve played and always watched the ball be bowled, she strolled down the wicket oblivious to what was happening. I’ve no problem with it. Stay in your bloody crease.

I’m with you on this. You can sledge with all manner of derogatory comments and that’s seen as fine but then folk are up in arms about a genuine way to get a batsman out. It’s bollox, really.
Reply
#18
But why is it that it seems only the Indians seem to do it, win at all costs and fuck the spirit of the game. If she or the captain had given the bats person a warning it would have been fair enough. Still what do you expect from some.
Reply
#19
(09-25-2022, 08:52 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: There are a few aspects of this which stand out for me.

  • The captain definitely gave Sharma the nod to do it. Worried that they might not get the wicket any other way, desperate to win, despite being 2-0 up in the series.
  • The England batter wasn't trying to steal an advantage, her bat was grounded behind the crease as the bowler went into her "delivery stride".
  • The bowler clearly intended to deceive the batter into thinking she'd released the ball, wasn't even looking down the wicket as she shaped up to "bowl".
  • The self-congratulatory hysterics of the Indian team were insulting.
  • The joyous crowd scenes were unsurprising and rather charmless.
  • The England women behaved with rather more dignity than I could have mustered in similar circumstances. Imagine someone doing that to Stuart Broad?
  • The Indian press was full of jubilation, describing it as a "brilliant run-out".
For me, this takes the unpopular "Mankad" to a new level - not punishing a non-striking batter for cheating by backing up too far, but deliberately deceiving them. Does Sharma practice this move? To put it in football terms, it's like praising a player for "drawing a foul", or the old Bergkamp favourite "I felt a touch so I went down".


And it says all we need to know about the post-Colonial chip on the Indian shoulder. Sad that our great game is now owned lock, stock and barrel by them.

Spot on Chesh in every point

It's disgusting and rightly all outside the ever important Indian Cricket bubble have rightly slammed it for what it was

I played my sport right on the wire, physically, mentally pushing every boundary to win but this I'd never stoop too, your second point from the side on camera is bob on and just makes it even worse, she was backing up, not running down the wicket and to people who say it's in the game etc just watch any match at any level side on and frankly you could skittle teams at any opportunity with this dismissal, all batsmen back up, it was intentional, wrong and embarrassing for the Indian Womens Team, lowest of the low I'm afriad

Any anybody trying to defend it needs a massive head wobble. If an England team did this, male or female they would be getting pelters also

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#20
(09-25-2022, 10:41 AM)KRO Wrote:
(09-25-2022, 08:52 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: There are a few aspects of this which stand out for me.

  • The captain definitely gave Sharma the nod to do it. Worried that they might not get the wicket any other way, desperate to win, despite being 2-0 up in the series.
  • The England batter wasn't trying to steal an advantage, her bat was grounded behind the crease as the bowler went into her "delivery stride".
  • The bowler clearly intended to deceive the batter into thinking she'd released the ball, wasn't even looking down the wicket as she shaped up to "bowl".
  • The self-congratulatory hysterics of the Indian team were insulting.
  • The joyous crowd scenes were unsurprising and rather charmless.
  • The England women behaved with rather more dignity than I could have mustered in similar circumstances. Imagine someone doing that to Stuart Broad?
  • The Indian press was full of jubilation, describing it as a "brilliant run-out".
For me, this takes the unpopular "Mankad" to a new level - not punishing a non-striking batter for cheating by backing up too far, but deliberately deceiving them. Does Sharma practice this move? To put it in football terms, it's like praising a player for "drawing a foul", or the old Bergkamp favourite "I felt a touch so I went down".


And it says all we need to know about the post-Colonial chip on the Indian shoulder. Sad that our great game is now owned lock, stock and barrel by them.

I’ve played and always watched the ball be bowled, she strolled down the wicket oblivious to what was happening. I’ve no problem with it. Stay in your bloody crease.

Not true, KRO, Dean watched the feet go into the stride before she left her ground. Non-striking batters don't watch the ball out of the bowler's hand, they're looking for where it might be hit and whether there's a run. This kind of dismissal is to punish batters who steal a lot of ground as the bowler bowls. Not intended as an opportunity for a bowler to pretend to bowl, just to catch an unwary batter out. Dean wasn't trying to cheat, in my opinion Sharma was. Do we want all footballers to be like Greasy Grealish, famed for winning free kicks? Do we want bowlers to be good at pretending to release the ball? The game's gone, Tom!

You've played cricket. Have you ever even seen a Mankad situation? If so, how often? I never did. This can't be defended by any reasonable argument that acknowledges sportsmanship as a concept.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)