The "it will take ages to undo the damage done by val" argument...
#11
If Val was the issue, Bruce may not have been the best option.
He's hardly renowned for his football style. It's too similar imo
Reply
#12
(02-14-2022, 10:03 PM)ericlegrisly Wrote:
(02-14-2022, 10:01 PM)Sliced Wrote: I noticed this narrative changing too Big Grin

I'm old enough to remember two weeks ago when "All we need is a manager who can get the best out of these players." and "Let's see how we do when a new manager comes in" were the flavour of the week.

New manager comes in, it turns out the players aren't actually very good as some of us have been saying all season.

"See! That's proof that Val has ruined these players"

How anyone can look at that 11 today and think we're entitled to promotion this season is beyond me.

Righto - just so I'm clear and this is a genuine question. Is it the case that Val overperformed with the squad at his disposal by having us in the top 6 for 7/8ths of his time in charge?

Erm... yes and no. Yes because we started well in his own image. Before the players yet again decided they didn't want to, or couldn't perform how they were being requested. So hissed and sulked him out. Before getting their ideal bloke in. Brucey. Nice bloke  will create a welcoming togetherness and not demand too much. 

No because he didn't just stick to his pricples and sack more senior pros off and really be honest with the fans jn interviews.

Once again, boring monotony has shone through at The Albion. Yay...
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#13
It's a confidence issue. We need a win quickly.
Reply
#14
I think Bruce will improve is and sneak into the play offs. Then it’s a lottery. We’ve been on the slide for the last 5 years, diluting the team with mediocre players. If you going to buy cheap you need to make sure you have someone like Ashworth to get you something for nothing.
Reply
#15
He took a shit squad and made it worse. No-one wins.

Bruce will improve us but it won't be quick enough so he needs to still be here in August.

Val's credibility will be proven by what happens next. More chance of going to Chester than Chelsea, imo, but time will tell.
Reply
#16
(02-14-2022, 10:03 PM)ericlegrisly Wrote:
(02-14-2022, 10:01 PM)Sliced Wrote: I noticed this narrative changing too Big Grin

I'm old enough to remember two weeks ago when "All we need is a manager who can get the best out of these players." and "Let's see how we do when a new manager comes in" were the flavour of the week.

New manager comes in, it turns out the players aren't actually very good as some of us have been saying all season.

"See! That's proof that Val has ruined these players"

How anyone can look at that 11 today and think we're entitled to promotion this season is beyond me.

Righto - just so I'm clear and this is a genuine question. Is it the case that Val overperformed with the squad at his disposal by having us in the top 6 for 7/8ths of his time in charge?

Genuine answer. At the start of the season, absolutely. We were top 2 for quite a while.

By the end our form was that of a team in 18/19th if I remember correctly. While overall we were probably around where we should have been, something had clearly gone wrong, which is why we rightly got rid of him.

However, the idea that this was somehow all down to the manager and we just needed someone else to come in to make these players the level that they should be at was clearly bollocks as we're having exactly the same issues as before. Which is why now we have this "Val has clearly destroyed the players" nonsense.

The manager has changed, unfortunately the players and issues haven't.
Reply
#17
(02-14-2022, 10:06 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-14-2022, 10:03 PM)ericlegrisly Wrote:
(02-14-2022, 10:01 PM)Sliced Wrote: I noticed this narrative changing too Big Grin

I'm old enough to remember two weeks ago when "All we need is a manager who can get the best out of these players." and "Let's see how we do when a new manager comes in" were the flavour of the week.

New manager comes in, it turns out the players aren't actually very good as some of us have been saying all season.

"See! That's proof that Val has ruined these players"

How anyone can look at that 11 today and think we're entitled to promotion this season is beyond me.

Righto - just so I'm clear and this is a genuine question. Is it the case that Val overperformed with the squad at his disposal by having us in the top 6 for 7/8ths of his time in charge?

Erm... yes and no. Yes because we started well in his own image. Before the players yet again decided they didn't want to, or couldn't perform how they were being requested. So hissed and sulked him out. Before getting their ideal bloke in. Brucey. Nice bloke  will create a welcoming togetherness and not demand too much. 

No because he didn't just stick to his pricples and sack more senior pros off and really be honest with the fans jn interviews.

Once again, boring monotony has shone through at The Albion. Yay...
3 of his signings started tonight, you cannot deny he influenced this shite,
Reply
#18
What's interesting is that when we were winning games at the start of the season people complained that "Val is playing a way which takes away the skill of our players in favour of results". What fucking skill!?

Thank fuck we are unleashing them now eh
Reply
#19
(02-14-2022, 10:01 PM)Sliced Wrote: I noticed this narrative changing too Big Grin

I'm old enough to remember two weeks ago when "All we need is a manager who can get the best out of these players." and "Let's see how we do when a new manager comes in" were the flavour of the week.

New manager comes in, it turns out the players aren't actually very good as some of us have been saying all season.

"See! That's proof that Val has ruined these players"

How anyone can look at that 11 today and think we're entitled to promotion this season is beyond me.

This. It's only a few weeks since our win against The Mighty Posh that they were promoted to the second best squad in the division.
The judgement of some people on here is shocking.
I think we are about where we should be on the level of this squad so if we make the P.O.'s it will be a real achievement at the part of the season where being up there matters.
I don't think we will because Ismael wasted the run of easier games we had around December.
Under Val I personally believe we would have finished in the region of 10-12th and that would have been underperforming - even for this bunch.
Reply
#20
Don't think Ismael was the right manager for us.

But let's not delude ourselves there were big issues at the club before he got here.

32 points from the second half of the Bilic promotion season, is the form of a side not good enough to make the play offs. And that was with Pereria. 

What is happening this season doesn't surprise me.

Still think Bruce will steady the ship and see improved results and performances before the season is over,  but I don't expect it to be pretty.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: