My simple perspective
#11
(02-26-2019, 09:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-26-2019, 09:10 PM)Black penny Wrote: If we dont get promotion it's a failure?  The reality of the so called star players is they got us relegated. I wouldn't be crying if they left. Actually Darren needs another season to mould his team.
This league is never a walk in the park, that's why the majority expected a mid table position this season and Stoke, Forest and Boro were favourites for promotion. Norwich and Sheffield were not expected to even make the play offs. Clearly shows all the experts don't have a clue either. Funny old game. PS I'm the same old black penny watching from.the gallery.

We were also favourites for promotion...

No we weren't, that is extreme revisionism. Within the Albion fanbase most of our fans were saying in and around the play offs bar a few extreme pessimists and optimists, the distribution curve if you'd polled our fans would have 4th to 8th as the most likely position.

The BBC pundits said 4th with the fans vote saying between 5th and 6th and Sky Sports predicted us to finish 11th.
#12
(02-26-2019, 09:36 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(02-26-2019, 09:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-26-2019, 09:10 PM)Black penny Wrote: If we dont get promotion it's a failure?  The reality of the so called star players is they got us relegated. I wouldn't be crying if they left. Actually Darren needs another season to mould his team.
This league is never a walk in the park, that's why the majority expected a mid table position this season and Stoke, Forest and Boro were favourites for promotion. Norwich and Sheffield were not expected to even make the play offs. Clearly shows all the experts don't have a clue either. Funny old game. PS I'm the same old black penny watching from.the gallery.

We were also favourites for promotion...

No we weren't, that is extreme revisionism. Within the Albion fanbase most of our fans were saying in and around the play offs bar a few extreme pessimists and optimists, the distribution curve if you'd polled our fans would have 4th to 8th as the most likely position.

The BBC pundits said 4th with the fans vote saying between 5th and 6th and Sky Sports predicted us to finish 11th.

One of the favourites and most bookies had us around the promotion / play off places. Certainly not midtable which other posters have said we were likely to finish on here.

Bookies predictions
#13
It's just Dek being Dek. We had a vote on here and the majority voted 6 to 12 mid table. My memory is fine.
#14
(02-26-2019, 09:45 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-26-2019, 09:36 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(02-26-2019, 09:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-26-2019, 09:10 PM)Black penny Wrote: If we dont get promotion it's a failure?  The reality of the so called star players is they got us relegated. I wouldn't be crying if they left. Actually Darren needs another season to mould his team.
This league is never a walk in the park, that's why the majority expected a mid table position this season and Stoke, Forest and Boro were favourites for promotion. Norwich and Sheffield were not expected to even make the play offs. Clearly shows all the experts don't have a clue either. Funny old game. PS I'm the same old black penny watching from.the gallery.

We were also favourites for promotion...

No we weren't, that is extreme revisionism. Within the Albion fanbase most of our fans were saying in and around the play offs bar a few extreme pessimists and optimists, the distribution curve if you'd polled our fans would have 4th to 8th as the most likely position.

The BBC pundits said 4th with the fans vote saying between 5th and 6th and Sky Sports predicted us to finish 11th.

One of the favourites and most had us around the promotion / play off places. Certainly not midtable which other posters have said we were likely to finish.

If your promotion favourites extend to the lottery of the Play-Off places then sure, for most it's the top two or three which for the vast majority Albion fan or not we weren't part of. Expectations are being revised based on where we were in November/December.
#15
(02-26-2019, 09:46 PM)Black penny Wrote: It's just Dek being Dek. We had a vote on here and the majority voted 6 to 12 mid table. My memory is fine.

Just because this place had a vote doesn’t make the majority correct.
#16
(02-26-2019, 09:48 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(02-26-2019, 09:45 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-26-2019, 09:36 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(02-26-2019, 09:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-26-2019, 09:10 PM)Black penny Wrote: If we dont get promotion it's a failure?  The reality of the so called star players is they got us relegated. I wouldn't be crying if they left. Actually Darren needs another season to mould his team.
This league is never a walk in the park, that's why the majority expected a mid table position this season and Stoke, Forest and Boro were favourites for promotion. Norwich and Sheffield were not expected to even make the play offs. Clearly shows all the experts don't have a clue either. Funny old game. PS I'm the same old black penny watching from.the gallery.

We were also favourites for promotion...

No we weren't, that is extreme revisionism. Within the Albion fanbase most of our fans were saying in and around the play offs bar a few extreme pessimists and optimists, the distribution curve if you'd polled our fans would have 4th to 8th as the most likely position.

The BBC pundits said 4th with the fans vote saying between 5th and 6th and Sky Sports predicted us to finish 11th.

One of the favourites and most had us around the promotion / play off places. Certainly not midtable which other posters have said we were likely to finish.

If your promotion favourites extend to the lottery of the Play-Off places then sure, for most it's the top two or three which for the vast majority Albion fan or not we weren't part of. Expectations are being revised based on where we were in November/December.

Exactly right
#17
(02-26-2019, 07:26 PM)Penny Black Baggie Wrote: If we don’t get promoted then this season must be seen as a failure, we have without doubt the best squad in the league.

Automatic promotion is beginning to look an increasingly remote possibility- but of course the best way to get out of this league for the fan is a Wembley victory, so it could still turn out to be one the best seasons even if we miss out on the top two (although the new Wembley has not been a kind Mistress to us  so far).

The reality of not going up is the loss of the loan players for sure (may happen if we get promoted anyway) - but also Gibbs, Hegazi, Dawson, Philips, Livermore, JRod to name but a few.

Which leaves 2019/20 a last chance saloon to go up with a mixture of the best crop of youngsters the club has produced alongside old heads like Bartley, Barry, Brunt and Morrison.

We could be in for a long spell out of the greed league - with only the annual derby v the Villa to look forward too....

Our own squad is good but somewhat overated, unbalanced and one paced in the middle of the park with a lack of creativity. 

We lose one of Phillips/Barnes now Murphy and we stuggle to get up the pitch quickly. Added to this Phillips does pick up regular injuries. If Barry isnt on it, or if he is marked out of the game, we have no other players who can link and Jake cannot do that job at all. Shame that Jimmy couldn't give us a season as he might have made a real difference. We have been left hoping an 18 year old can now be the diffetence but he still had lots to learn. 
Upfront we lack phydicality and genuinely miss HRK for his presence when not playing, which says it all.. 

As for our PL quality players, well as much as I like Dawson, Gibbs and Jrod there is a reason why no one would meet our valuations of them. Hegazi is close but still inexperienced even at this level. None can be considered real PL quality. 

Gayle looked the bomb in a 5-3-2 with Barnes but is struggling in the 4-3-3 at home. He neefs a creator of chances to play with so again, injuries haven't helped since Barnes left.

So good yes, the best.....can't be so sure.
#18
(02-26-2019, 09:10 PM)Black penny Wrote: If we dont get promotion it's a failure?  The reality of the so called star players is they got us relegated. I wouldn't be crying if they left. Actually Darren needs another season to mould his team.
This league is never a walk in the park, that's why the majority expected a mid table position this season and Stoke, Forest and Boro were favourites for promotion. Norwich and Sheffield were not expected to even make the play offs. Clearly shows all the experts don't have a clue either. Funny old game. PS I'm the same old black penny watching from.the gallery.

Sorry about the name duplication - Penny Black refers to my local watering hole.
#19
(02-26-2019, 09:50 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-26-2019, 09:46 PM)Black penny Wrote: It's just Dek being Dek. We had a vote on here and the majority voted 6 to 12 mid table. My memory is fine.

Just because this place had a vote doesn’t make the majority correct.

Dek ask Enzo to come back and have a debate with him.
#20
(02-26-2019, 09:48 PM)Bookies prediction 2Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(02-26-2019, 09:45 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-26-2019, 09:36 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(02-26-2019, 09:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-26-2019, 09:10 PM)Black penny Wrote: If we dont get promotion it's a failure?  The reality of the so called star players is they got us relegated. I wouldn't be crying if they left. Actually Darren needs another season to mould his team.
This league is never a walk in the park, that's why the majority expected a mid table position this season and Stoke, Forest and Boro were favourites for promotion. Norwich and Sheffield were not expected to even make the play offs. Clearly shows all the experts don't have a clue either. Funny old game. PS I'm the same old black penny watching from.the gallery.

We were also favourites for promotion...

No we weren't, that is extreme revisionism. Within the Albion fanbase most of our fans were saying in and around the play offs bar a few extreme pessimists and optimists, the distribution curve if you'd polled our fans would have 4th to 8th as the most likely position.

The BBC pundits said 4th with the fans vote saying between 5th and 6th and Sky Sports predicted us to finish 11th.

One of the favourites and most had us around the promotion / play off places. Certainly not midtable which other posters have said we were likely to finish.

If your promotion favourites extend to the lottery of the Play-Off places then sure, for most it's the top two or three which for the vast majority Albion fan or not we weren't part of. Expectations are being revised based on where we were in November/December.

Or based on the bookies assessment rather than here...

Bookies prediction 1
Bookies prediction 2
Goal favourites

Oh...


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: