Ball playing defenders.
#11
I've said before.

There's a misconception that direct means long ball it doesn't. There's a difference between an accurate, well timed long ball into space for us to run on to, or to a target man to hold up, to what we've been doing last few games, which is aimlessly belting it up field. Part of that is the loss of O'Shea and Clarke, they knew how to do the former, and when to pass into midfield and then they get it forward quickly along the ground.

Ajayi lacks the football intelligence to do that, Bartley isn't that type of player, and tbf, he doesn't want to be, he's a defender and wants to just clear the ball away. Kipre is just a disaster, and Townsend playing there weakens us on the left, and he's not truly comfortable there either.

Bryan needs to get up to speed if Val thinks he's the type of defender we need there.

I know people have this basic idea that attackers equals attack, defenders equals defence and midfield links them. However the way Val has us playing, the defence is where the attack starts, so they need to be clever, decisive players that know when to start those attacks. With the loss of the two that do, we've suffered. Our attack has issues by itself of course but we aren't even allowing them to do well anyway. Once the press is removed, we're reliant on how we approach our attack, amd right now, it's dire, no argument from me there.
Reply
#12
(09-20-2021, 09:58 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(09-20-2021, 09:36 AM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(09-20-2021, 09:02 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I guess my thought process behind Jake at the back is that we rarely concede any chances with the way we play  and how teams are forced to play against us. But Jake ability to pass the ball is much better than any available defenders.

Regardless of whether Jake is the answer, the question will still be same for me. How do we improve our first pass. How do we get our ball players into positions to hurt teams without the need for so much physical exertion first.

Shorter passes into midfield instead of hoofing it from the back?  That's tippy-tappy round this way these days and will lead you into the Heart Bilic  Heart camp!

But yeah we lack composure from the back and tend to play it long so it is an issue.  Maybe Clarke will be better, he seemed to like carry it out from the back, that can create space too.  Shots and chances are being rushed because teams ares sitting deep and there's little to no room. To create the space you need to be smarter and play the triangles, not lump it onto the centre half's head.

I think the issue is not length of pass per se, but accuracy. 

Many times v Derby second half we played long passes behind their defence, or switched play directly, but we did so after having good stable posession in deeper areas. 

Earlier in the season we had 5/6 players in and around the oppositions area and overloads in most positions on the pitch, offensively. Now  because we are having our press nullified by long, high, safe out balls, we are having to build from much deeper and not turning the ball over in the middle and offensive 3rds where quick balls work well.

It's much, much easier to be accurate with shorter passes, we can't expect defenders at this level to ping 40-60 yard passes to people's feet or for them to run on to.  It ends up being a 50/50 ball a lot of the time and therefore you've just wasted the energy in winning the ball back.

Shorter passes need a quicker tempo otherwise you end up with the Swansea passing, 30 passes and the keeper still has the ball at his feet.

Anything that speeds up play or is a longer pass is going to reduce the accuracy, especially from defenders, at the moment we haven't got it quite right and it's a bit too much of a hoof and hot potato.  Hopefully they're working on it and we'll find the balance.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#13
(09-20-2021, 11:07 AM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(09-20-2021, 09:58 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(09-20-2021, 09:36 AM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(09-20-2021, 09:02 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I guess my thought process behind Jake at the back is that we rarely concede any chances with the way we play  and how teams are forced to play against us. But Jake ability to pass the ball is much better than any available defenders.

Regardless of whether Jake is the answer, the question will still be same for me. How do we improve our first pass. How do we get our ball players into positions to hurt teams without the need for so much physical exertion first.

Shorter passes into midfield instead of hoofing it from the back?  That's tippy-tappy round this way these days and will lead you into the Heart Bilic  Heart camp!

But yeah we lack composure from the back and tend to play it long so it is an issue.  Maybe Clarke will be better, he seemed to like carry it out from the back, that can create space too.  Shots and chances are being rushed because teams ares sitting deep and there's little to no room. To create the space you need to be smarter and play the triangles, not lump it onto the centre half's head.

I think the issue is not length of pass per se, but accuracy. 

Many times v Derby second half we played long passes behind their defence, or switched play directly, but we did so after having good stable posession in deeper areas. 

Earlier in the season we had 5/6 players in and around the oppositions area and overloads in most positions on the pitch, offensively. Now  because we are having our press nullified by long, high, safe out balls, we are having to build from much deeper and not turning the ball over in the middle and offensive 3rds where quick balls work well.

It's much, much easier to be accurate with shorter passes, we can't expect defenders at this level to ping 40-60 yard passes to people's feet or for them to run on to.  It ends up being a 50/50 ball a lot of the time and therefore you've just wasted the energy in winning the ball back.

Shorter passes need a quicker tempo otherwise you end up with the Swansea passing, 30 passes and the keeper still has the ball at his feet.

Anything that speeds up play or is a longer pass is going to reduce the accuracy, especially from defenders, at the moment we haven't got it quite right and it's a bit too much of a hoof and hot potato.  Hopefully they're working on it and we'll find the balance.

You can though if you have those types of defenders. We did with O'Shea and Clarke. Bartley has a decent range of passing given time on the ball, but not as things stand. Which is why we need to find a solutions get us up the pitch and through the lines more accurately. It may be the case that we need to have an extra man in midfield or the defensive line which would give us more short options, but not sure Val would want to have one less offensive player on the pitch.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#14
If it's accurate passing from the CH's then Livermore is no better than what we have, so we would just end up with a CH, who can't head it either.
I would drop Jake altogether and give Molumby a try. He certainly has more energy so, if he can pick a half decent pass, I don't see what we could lose?
Reply
#15
(09-20-2021, 01:54 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: If it's accurate passing from the CH's then Livermore is no better than what we have, so we would just end up with a CH, who can't head it either.
I would drop Jake altogether and give Molumby a try. He certainly has more energy so, if he can pick a half decent pass, I don't see what we could lose?

+1
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: