Onions and ratings
#11
(09-14-2021, 09:57 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Right let's be sensible. 

We were poor in possession first half and missed a couple of great chances.  Second half we absolutely battered them, and dominated them in all areas. But still couldn't finish. 

On another day it would have been a massacre. Still unbeaten, plenty of improvement to come, but plenty to be positive about. 

SJ - 6.5 - couldn't really score as he hardly did anything as was our domination. Acted well as a sweeper and some good passing. 

Ajayi - 6 - gives me the shits, but is a beast in equal quantities. Does the hard stuff well, but the easy stuff poorly. 
Bartley - 8 - Dominated in the air and some great passing. 
Townsend - 7 - Grew into it, and got better ad the game went on as he started overlapping. Good option to cover LCB. 

Furlong - 7 - Could have had a hattrick. Always a threat. Could have been MOTM if he would have taken his chances. 
Mowatt - 7 - Reliable. 
Livermore - 7 - Reliable. 
Reach - 7 - Played well, plenty of energy and decent delivery. 

Grant - 5 - Poor. 
Robinson - 6 - Not involved enough. 
Grady - 8.5 - MOTM, sparks of the old grady. From the off he made things happen. Could have scored and made assists tonight. 

Subs:
Hugill - 8 - Proper championship target man. Will create goals for those around him and chip in with a few no doubt. Should start next game. 
Phillips - 7 - Gave us directness and pace and power up top which helped push them back. Decent showing.
Snoddy - 6.5 - Did fine. Will be a good squad option. Poor delivery late in the game. 

Should be Grady, Hugill and Robbo on Saturday as I suggested today. Its our most balanced front 3.

I agree with these marks.

First time I've had chance to watch Reach. Looked very decent and did little wrong.
Reply
#12
(09-14-2021, 10:58 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-14-2021, 10:55 PM)MrFizz Wrote:
(09-14-2021, 10:51 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Johnstone - 6

Townsend - 7
Bartley - 7.5
Ajayi - 6.5

Furlong - 7
Reach - 6.5

Livermore - 6
Mowatt - 6.5

Grant - 0
Robinson - 6.5
Grady - 8 MOTM

Hugill - 6
Phillips - 6
Snodgrass - 5

Bit harsh.  Big Grin

Big Grin I am genuinely unsure if Grant even touched the ball in the first half

Bit harsh the Hugill scoring less than Robbo.

(09-14-2021, 09:57 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Right let's be sensible. 

We were poor in possession first half and missed a couple of great chances.  Second half we absolutely battered them, and dominated them in all areas. But still couldn't finish. 

On another day it would have been a massacre. Still unbeaten, plenty of improvement to come, but plenty to be positive about. 

SJ - 6.5 - couldn't really score as he hardly did anything as was our domination. Acted well as a sweeper and some good passing. 

Ajayi - 6 - gives me the shits, but is a beast in equal quantities. Does the hard stuff well, but the easy stuff poorly. 
Bartley - 8 - Dominated in the air and some great passing. 
Townsend - 7 - Grew into it, and got better ad the game went on as he started overlapping. Good option to cover LCB. 

Furlong - 7 - Could have had a hattrick. Always a threat. Could have been MOTM if he would have taken his chances. 
Mowatt - 7 - Reliable. 
Livermore - 7 - Reliable. 
Reach - 7 - Played well, plenty of energy and decent delivery. 

Grant - 5 - Poor. 
Robinson - 6 - Not involved enough. 
Grady - 8.5 - MOTM, sparks of the old grady. From the off he made things happen. Could have scored and made assists tonight. 

Subs:
Hugill - 8 - Proper championship target man. Will create goals for those around him and chip in with a few no doubt. Should start next game. 
Phillips - 7 - Gave us directness and pace and power up top which helped push them back. Decent showing.
Snoddy - 6.5 - Did fine. Will be a good squad option. Poor delivery late in the game. 

Should be Grady, Hugill and Robbo on Saturday as I suggested today. Its our most balanced front 3.

Pretty much agree. Would maybe take one off Livermore for that reckless booking
Reply
#13
6 for everyone except Furlong and Grady who get 7.
Reply
#14
For context, I've just clicked onto the Derby forum and their keeper is the unanimous choice for MOTM, closely followed by their three centre halves. So perhaps not the abject shitshow many on here thought.s
Reply
#15
Think the marks on here are largely fair. The second half performance would, more often than not, garner all three points, so no need for panic.

Struggling to justify 7 for Furlong though. (Who I am a fan of) I thought he was woeful last night. Very poor in possession, gave the ball away regularly and should have scored a winner at the end. Definitely no higher than 5. Only Grant deserves less

Grady was excellent
Reply
#16
(09-15-2021, 07:24 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: For context, I've just clicked onto the Derby forum and their keeper is the unanimous choice for MOTM, closely followed by their three centre halves. So perhaps not the abject shitshow many on here thought.s

I've been converted to the camp 'Results are all that matter' so it still is a shit show.

Were I a Derby fan then I'd be lauding their battling lads too. And yes I'd say their keeper looked good, and deserved MOTM. Doesn't mean we played any better because of it though. None of the saves he made were breath taking Worldies sort of thing, all were pretty routine but done well.
Reply
#17
(09-15-2021, 07:35 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(09-15-2021, 07:24 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: For context, I've just clicked onto the Derby forum and their keeper is the unanimous choice for MOTM, closely followed by their three centre halves. So perhaps not the abject shitshow many on here thought.s

I've been converted to the camp 'Results are all that matter' so it still is a shit show.

Were I a Derby fan then I'd be lauding their battling lads too. And yes I'd say their keeper looked good, and deserved MOTM. Doesn't mean we played any better because of it though. None of the saves he made were breath taking Worldies sort of thing, all were pretty routine but done well.

Correct, and on another day he doesn't make them, defenders don't get in the way of the ball. All the stats from last night (second half) show that we will win more than we lose in this league. A big improvement from the last couple of seasons is that we never really looked like conceding. Two clean sheets in our last three games is a huge improvement on what we saw last time we were down here. Goals will come when we have the quality that we do.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: