Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(05-19-2021, 02:08 PM)wbamitch Wrote: Shame for him to miss out on what would have been a great experience for him. I was scanning through a Lincoln forum last night and I was a bit surprised to see a mixed bag of opinions on him. Apparently commands his area well, but struggles with long range efforts. The opposite of Johnstone really. A lot of them said they don't think he's ready for championship level, especially for a side aiming for promotion.
If you could pick you'd take the keeper who commands his area over the shot stopper every time. The vast majority of the goals Johnstone gets blamed for are as a result of hesitancy when the ball is bouncing round our penalty area.
Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(05-19-2021, 06:11 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (05-19-2021, 02:08 PM)wbamitch Wrote: Shame for him to miss out on what would have been a great experience for him. I was scanning through a Lincoln forum last night and I was a bit surprised to see a mixed bag of opinions on him. Apparently commands his area well, but struggles with long range efforts. The opposite of Johnstone really. A lot of them said they don't think he's ready for championship level, especially for a side aiming for promotion.
If you could pick you'd take the keeper who commands his area over the shot stopper every time. The vast majority of the goals Johnstone gets blamed for are as a result of hesitancy when the ball is bouncing round our penalty area.
Disagree, especially in the top flight. How many goals would we have conceded this season without Johnstones shot stopping?
As I've said before, the obsession of 'keepers commanding their area is very much old school nowadays and isn't supported by stats in most top flights, it does have some reasoning in the Championship, and as you drop lower it becomes more important.
Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(05-19-2021, 06:13 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (05-19-2021, 06:11 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (05-19-2021, 02:08 PM)wbamitch Wrote: Shame for him to miss out on what would have been a great experience for him. I was scanning through a Lincoln forum last night and I was a bit surprised to see a mixed bag of opinions on him. Apparently commands his area well, but struggles with long range efforts. The opposite of Johnstone really. A lot of them said they don't think he's ready for championship level, especially for a side aiming for promotion.
If you could pick you'd take the keeper who commands his area over the shot stopper every time. The vast majority of the goals Johnstone gets blamed for are as a result of hesitancy when the ball is bouncing round our penalty area.
Disagree, especially in the top flight. How many goals would we have conceded this season without Johnstones shot stopping?
As I've said before, the obsession of 'keepers commanding their area is very much old school nowadays and isn't supported by stats in most top flights, it does have some reasoning in the Championship, and as you drop lower it becomes more important.
If you're keeper is having lots to do then your defence has failed... which to be fair ours mostly has this season.
Think back to the two seasons Johnstone was our keeper in the Championship, so many avoidable goals that cost us points where a more commanding keeper would have dealt with the situation.
Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(05-19-2021, 06:24 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (05-19-2021, 06:13 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (05-19-2021, 06:11 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (05-19-2021, 02:08 PM)wbamitch Wrote: Shame for him to miss out on what would have been a great experience for him. I was scanning through a Lincoln forum last night and I was a bit surprised to see a mixed bag of opinions on him. Apparently commands his area well, but struggles with long range efforts. The opposite of Johnstone really. A lot of them said they don't think he's ready for championship level, especially for a side aiming for promotion.
If you could pick you'd take the keeper who commands his area over the shot stopper every time. The vast majority of the goals Johnstone gets blamed for are as a result of hesitancy when the ball is bouncing round our penalty area.
Disagree, especially in the top flight. How many goals would we have conceded this season without Johnstones shot stopping?
As I've said before, the obsession of 'keepers commanding their area is very much old school nowadays and isn't supported by stats in most top flights, it does have some reasoning in the Championship, and as you drop lower it becomes more important.
If you're keeper is having lots to do then your defence has failed... which to be fair ours mostly has this season.
Think back to the two seasons Johnstone was our keeper in the Championship, so many avoidable goals that cost us points where a more commanding keeper would have dealt with the situation.
Yes, at lower levels where more goals and chances are made via long and high balls into the box, commanding 'keepers are far more valuable. However at the highest level ,shot stopping becomes far more important, since play tends to be much quicker, and reliant on reflexes.
|