Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(05-14-2021, 11:32 AM)Mayo Wrote: (05-14-2021, 10:51 AM)Fido Wrote: (05-14-2021, 10:31 AM)Mayo Wrote: The largest Muslim majority country in population terms is Indonesia where many westerners seem to like a holiday. They have elected government I think but no doubt have their problems with religious groups, a bit like the US. I agree with some comments re monotheistic religion in general and would prefer more reasonable and realistic religions where you have a group of flawed individuals, good and bad or both, such as Greek or Norse, which allow you to worship whatever you want. Maybe that's just me. And I have actually seen and met Santa so don't start denying that.
Another opportunity for a Hitch-ism:
"You can make good people do good things and you can make evil people to do evil things. But to make good people do bad things, you need religion".
The moment you make people believe they have God on their side then you can get them to do pretty much what you want. Indonesia is pretty stable now but the soldiers that went into East Timor would have been briefed that it was the will of Allah to go out murdering innocent souls.
I don't know how the Indonesian or Timor sides were briefed in that horrific conflict though I don't doubt God was mentioned which is common - again as with the US and Christian nations too. Politicsand power rather than religion is usually behind such conflicts though with religion as an excuse.
But you do not need religion as the excuse for evil or even for good people to turn to evil as per your quote; neat as it is, it simply is not true. The regimes under Mao, Stallin and Hitler - the three biggest mass murderers in history - had political ideology and just blatant racism as the driving forces of evils perpetrated.
China's actions today in Hong Kong and against minority groups are about retaining their authoritarian control which is not based on religion - rather suppressing it in some cases. I do not think Genghis Khan went on the rampage for religious reasons - and other brutal empires too grew throughout history with power and economics or prestige itself simply as the cause. - as with the Vikings.
Ghengis Kahn, killed a quarter of the known world population... he was definitely the top mass murderer statistically speaking. BBC4 have just done a great double episode documentary on violence and human aggression. Probably a lot more insightful than let’s blame religions for all the evils in the world. Humans are by their nature aggressive, violent and prone to destruction, we are also vain, intolerant and greedy these traits don’t need any help from religion to flourish.
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(05-14-2021, 11:32 AM)Mayo Wrote: (05-14-2021, 10:51 AM)Fido Wrote: (05-14-2021, 10:31 AM)Mayo Wrote: The largest Muslim majority country in population terms is Indonesia where many westerners seem to like a holiday. They have elected government I think but no doubt have their problems with religious groups, a bit like the US. I agree with some comments re monotheistic religion in general and would prefer more reasonable and realistic religions where you have a group of flawed individuals, good and bad or both, such as Greek or Norse, which allow you to worship whatever you want. Maybe that's just me. And I have actually seen and met Santa so don't start denying that.
Another opportunity for a Hitch-ism:
"You can make good people do good things and you can make evil people to do evil things. But to make good people do bad things, you need religion".
The moment you make people believe they have God on their side then you can get them to do pretty much what you want. Indonesia is pretty stable now but the soldiers that went into East Timor would have been briefed that it was the will of Allah to go out murdering innocent souls.
I don't know how the Indonesian or Timor sides were briefed in that horrific conflict though I don't doubt God was mentioned which is common - again as with the US and Christian nations too. Politicsand power rather than religion is usually behind such conflicts though with religion as an excuse.
But you do not need religion as the excuse for evil or even for good people to turn to evil as per your quote; neat as it is, it simply is not true. The regimes under Mao, Stallin and Hitler - the three biggest mass murderers in history - had political ideology and just blatant racism as the driving forces of evils perpetrated.
China's actions today in Hong Kong and against minority groups are about retaining their authoritarian control which is not based on religion - rather suppressing it in some cases. I do not think Genghis Khan went on the rampage for religious reasons - and other brutal empires too grew throughout history with power and economics or prestige itself simply as the cause. - as with the Vikings.
Stalin and Hitler both had enormous backing from the Catholic and Orthodox churches. Hitler's birthday was celebrated from pulpit by the former until his death with "Gott mit uns" being the prominent slogan of the army. Mao I know little about but North Korea is pretty much the most religious country on Earth and is completely totalitarian (the dead father is actually the leader of the country, the son is just looking after stuff) and to a certain China has used similar ideological methods.
The suicide bombing and genital mutilation communities are pretty much exclusively religious.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(05-14-2021, 11:58 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Humans are by their nature aggressive, violent and prone to destruction, we are also vain, intolerant and greedy these traits don’t need any help from religion to flourish.
I think I finally understand why you are the way you are now.
I tend to think about humanity's positive traits myself. I bet I'm much happier for it too.
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(05-14-2021, 11:58 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (05-14-2021, 11:32 AM)Mayo Wrote: (05-14-2021, 10:51 AM)Fido Wrote: (05-14-2021, 10:31 AM)Mayo Wrote: The largest Muslim majority country in population terms is Indonesia where many westerners seem to like a holiday. They have elected government I think but no doubt have their problems with religious groups, a bit like the US. I agree with some comments re monotheistic religion in general and would prefer more reasonable and realistic religions where you have a group of flawed individuals, good and bad or both, such as Greek or Norse, which allow you to worship whatever you want. Maybe that's just me. And I have actually seen and met Santa so don't start denying that.
Another opportunity for a Hitch-ism:
"You can make good people do good things and you can make evil people to do evil things. But to make good people do bad things, you need religion".
The moment you make people believe they have God on their side then you can get them to do pretty much what you want. Indonesia is pretty stable now but the soldiers that went into East Timor would have been briefed that it was the will of Allah to go out murdering innocent souls.
I don't know how the Indonesian or Timor sides were briefed in that horrific conflict though I don't doubt God was mentioned which is common - again as with the US and Christian nations too. Politicsand power rather than religion is usually behind such conflicts though with religion as an excuse.
But you do not need religion as the excuse for evil or even for good people to turn to evil as per your quote; neat as it is, it simply is not true. The regimes under Mao, Stallin and Hitler - the three biggest mass murderers in history - had political ideology and just blatant racism as the driving forces of evils perpetrated.
China's actions today in Hong Kong and against minority groups are about retaining their authoritarian control which is not based on religion - rather suppressing it in some cases. I do not think Genghis Khan went on the rampage for religious reasons - and other brutal empires too grew throughout history with power and economics or prestige itself simply as the cause. - as with the Vikings.
Ghengis Kahn, killed a quarter of the known world population... he was definitely the top mass murderer statistically speaking. BBC4 have just done a great double episode documentary on violence and human aggression. Probably a lot more insightful than let’s blame religions for all the evils in the world. Humans are by their nature aggressive, violent and prone to destruction, we are also vain, intolerant and greedy these traits don’t need any help from religion to flourish.
I don't agree at all. The large majority of people are tolerant, helpful and kind and they know that this is the only way to survive as a society. When you ask people what their one wish may be why do so many reply "World Peace" or "An End To Disease" or the like? Who says "I Want To Own Everything And Kill Everyone Who Gets In My Way"?
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(05-14-2021, 12:45 PM)Fido Wrote: Who says "I Want To Own Everything And Kill Everyone Who Gets In My Way"?
tORy BaSTaRdS
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
A lotta people won't get no virgins tonight.....
Posts: 27,984
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
Are mods allowed to post anti-Islamic stuff now?
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(05-14-2021, 12:45 PM)Fido Wrote: (05-14-2021, 11:58 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (05-14-2021, 11:32 AM)Mayo Wrote: (05-14-2021, 10:51 AM)Fido Wrote: (05-14-2021, 10:31 AM)Mayo Wrote: The largest Muslim majority country in population terms is Indonesia where many westerners seem to like a holiday. They have elected government I think but no doubt have their problems with religious groups, a bit like the US. I agree with some comments re monotheistic religion in general and would prefer more reasonable and realistic religions where you have a group of flawed individuals, good and bad or both, such as Greek or Norse, which allow you to worship whatever you want. Maybe that's just me. And I have actually seen and met Santa so don't start denying that.
Another opportunity for a Hitch-ism:
"You can make good people do good things and you can make evil people to do evil things. But to make good people do bad things, you need religion".
The moment you make people believe they have God on their side then you can get them to do pretty much what you want. Indonesia is pretty stable now but the soldiers that went into East Timor would have been briefed that it was the will of Allah to go out murdering innocent souls.
I don't know how the Indonesian or Timor sides were briefed in that horrific conflict though I don't doubt God was mentioned which is common - again as with the US and Christian nations too. Politicsand power rather than religion is usually behind such conflicts though with religion as an excuse.
But you do not need religion as the excuse for evil or even for good people to turn to evil as per your quote; neat as it is, it simply is not true. The regimes under Mao, Stallin and Hitler - the three biggest mass murderers in history - had political ideology and just blatant racism as the driving forces of evils perpetrated.
China's actions today in Hong Kong and against minority groups are about retaining their authoritarian control which is not based on religion - rather suppressing it in some cases. I do not think Genghis Khan went on the rampage for religious reasons - and other brutal empires too grew throughout history with power and economics or prestige itself simply as the cause. - as with the Vikings.
Ghengis Kahn, killed a quarter of the known world population... he was definitely the top mass murderer statistically speaking. BBC4 have just done a great double episode documentary on violence and human aggression. Probably a lot more insightful than let’s blame religions for all the evils in the world. Humans are by their nature aggressive, violent and prone to destruction, we are also vain, intolerant and greedy these traits don’t need any help from religion to flourish.
I don't agree at all. The large majority of people are tolerant, helpful and kind and they know that this is the only way to survive as a society. When you ask people what their one wish may be why do so many reply "World Peace" or "An End To Disease" or the like? Who says "I Want To Own Everything And Kill Everyone Who Gets In My Way"?
As a species (we’re just apes after all) we are all of those negative things and quite a few positive things too but the discussion started with a very dubious post about the negatives of one religion when in fact human basic instinct is to be destructive with or without religion. Religion is just an expression of human nature. A mix of compassion, love, peace, hypocrisy, greed anger etc etc.
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(05-14-2021, 05:48 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (05-14-2021, 12:45 PM)Fido Wrote: (05-14-2021, 11:58 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (05-14-2021, 11:32 AM)Mayo Wrote: (05-14-2021, 10:51 AM)Fido Wrote: Another opportunity for a Hitch-ism:
"You can make good people do good things and you can make evil people to do evil things. But to make good people do bad things, you need religion".
The moment you make people believe they have God on their side then you can get them to do pretty much what you want. Indonesia is pretty stable now but the soldiers that went into East Timor would have been briefed that it was the will of Allah to go out murdering innocent souls.
I don't know how the Indonesian or Timor sides were briefed in that horrific conflict though I don't doubt God was mentioned which is common - again as with the US and Christian nations too. Politicsand power rather than religion is usually behind such conflicts though with religion as an excuse.
But you do not need religion as the excuse for evil or even for good people to turn to evil as per your quote; neat as it is, it simply is not true. The regimes under Mao, Stallin and Hitler - the three biggest mass murderers in history - had political ideology and just blatant racism as the driving forces of evils perpetrated.
China's actions today in Hong Kong and against minority groups are about retaining their authoritarian control which is not based on religion - rather suppressing it in some cases. I do not think Genghis Khan went on the rampage for religious reasons - and other brutal empires too grew throughout history with power and economics or prestige itself simply as the cause. - as with the Vikings.
Ghengis Kahn, killed a quarter of the known world population... he was definitely the top mass murderer statistically speaking. BBC4 have just done a great double episode documentary on violence and human aggression. Probably a lot more insightful than let’s blame religions for all the evils in the world. Humans are by their nature aggressive, violent and prone to destruction, we are also vain, intolerant and greedy these traits don’t need any help from religion to flourish.
I don't agree at all. The large majority of people are tolerant, helpful and kind and they know that this is the only way to survive as a society. When you ask people what their one wish may be why do so many reply "World Peace" or "An End To Disease" or the like? Who says "I Want To Own Everything And Kill Everyone Who Gets In My Way"?
As a species (we’re just apes after all) we are all of those negative things and quite a few positive things too but the discussion started with a very dubious post about the negatives of one religion when in fact human basic instinct is to be destructive with or without religion. Religion is just an expression of human nature. A mix of compassion, love, peace, hypocrisy, greed anger etc etc.
Absolutely not.
We are builders and creators by nature. Survival instincts will lead us to battle at times but it's not the over-riding emotional driver. Religion was our first foray into philosophy and science. We've never really found an answer to the universe that is comprehendible by all so the first on the scene still has credence. It's ridiculous, in many ways, that people with so much knowledge and intelligence hold onto these beliefs. I've no idea if apes know that they are going to die at some point but humans do and this clouds their judgement as there is always hope that there is something else beyond this life. The sooner we grasp the fact that this is all there is would make the whole world a better place.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
On the topic of religion and politics, I see the DUP have appointed a fundamentalist Presbyterian who thinks that the Earth is 6,000 tests old as leader.
|