Posts: 9,633
Threads: 518
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
He should stay.
He did a good job rebuilding an ageing squad after we failed st the first attempt to get back up.
He then managed to secure Grady and MP which although hasn't worked perfectly will be great signings jn the long run, with both players being good enough for this level with better around them.
Even Big Sam has praised his ability to get deals done, and by all accounts he was key in the AMN deal with The Arse.
We need a coach like Dyche that can maximise the output from limited resources. This does not mean they have to favour attritional football, but they need that coaching and man management acumen which allows clubs like us to flourish.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 4,733
Threads: 105
Joined: May 2019
Reputation:
3
Go please. Failure shouldn't be rewarded.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(02-08-2021, 08:03 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: We had the smallest budget to use on the Prem. it’s not his fault that we are shopping at Quick Save whilst others are going to Harrods for their weekly shop.
Stop looking for blame we are where we are because we don’t have the resources to compete. The owners never said they would spend millions that we didn’t generate as a club so just accept unless we do sell to new owners that will then as the Prem evolves further yoyoing is looking increasingly likely to be the best we can do.
I did say a few years ago when idiots were talking about ‘next levels’ whilst we were sitting 8th -11th in the Prem that was likely to be the best we can achieve without an investor who will spend beyond the clubs resources. Nothing has changed for us but the Prem has become even more about money and the only thing that might change that a little is erm Brexit, but even then it’ll help widen the gap not bridge it between the rich clubs and the rest.
We've also made some shocking decisions on the way. The key one being not replacing Pulis at the end of 16/17 when it was clear his heart was no longer in the role (to put it kindly). Instead the inevitable happened and we then appointed the worst of all worlds: Pardew. So a team which needn't have been relegated, was. Not only that, we didn't sack Pardew, but allowed him to leave by mutual consent.
Hindsight, but if the club could have grilled Darren Moore a bit about his choice of assistant and averted that on the grounds of common sense, that would have been great too.
As for this season, we may have indeed always been relegated, but the fact is there seems to have been endless squabbles in the summer as opposed to constructing a coherent team. From the players we have, two different managers have struggled to name their best team and that is damning.
Furthermore, relegation is one thing, but to narrowly avoid breaking Derby's record is quite another. I think we definitely should be expecting more than that and that it's quite right to question the role of various senior figures in the club, including Dowling.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(02-08-2021, 10:39 AM)Squid Wrote: (02-08-2021, 08:03 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: We had the smallest budget to use on the Prem. it’s not his fault that we are shopping at Quick Save whilst others are going to Harrods for their weekly shop.
Stop looking for blame we are where we are because we don’t have the resources to compete. The owners never said they would spend millions that we didn’t generate as a club so just accept unless we do sell to new owners that will then as the Prem evolves further yoyoing is looking increasingly likely to be the best we can do.
I did say a few years ago when idiots were talking about ‘next levels’ whilst we were sitting 8th -11th in the Prem that was likely to be the best we can achieve without an investor who will spend beyond the clubs resources. Nothing has changed for us but the Prem has become even more about money and the only thing that might change that a little is erm Brexit, but even then it’ll help widen the gap not bridge it between the rich clubs and the rest.
We've also made some shocking decisions on the way. The key one being not replacing Pulis at the end of 16/17 when it was clear his heart was no longer in the role (to put it kindly). Instead the inevitable happened and we then appointed the worst of all worlds: Pardew. So a team which needn't have been relegated, was. Not only that, we didn't sack Pardew, but allowed him to leave by mutual consent.
Hindsight, but if the club could have grilled Darren Moore a bit about his choice of assistant and averted that on the grounds of common sense, that would have been great too.
As for this season, we may have indeed always been relegated, but the fact is there seems to have been endless squabbles in the summer as opposed to constructing a coherent team. From the players we have, two different managers have struggled to name their best team and that is damning.
Furthermore, relegation is one thing, but to narrowly avoid breaking Derby's record is quite another. I think we definitely should be expecting more than that and that it's quite right to question the role of various senior figures in the club, including Dowling.
Well said.
Dowling shoulders part of the blame for constructing such an unbalanced squad, especially given how even the most deluded fan could see the inadequacies when the window closed.
Poor planning, poor expectation setting, squad disharmony, lack of fitness, lack of organisation... all of these have nothing to do with budgets
Posts: 489
Threads: 24
Joined: Nov 2019
Reputation:
0
Look at the Dowling deals , Austin , Zohore , Furlong , Grosicki , Peltier .
The poor returns and decent wages are starting to stack against Dowling .
Add this to his reluctance to shop overseas means for me he's had his go , id get rid .
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
Dowling (like anyone in any job), has pluses and minuses. We don't know exactly who wanted who? Zohore, for example was rumoured to be Slav's choice. Plus didn't Slav want Austin at West Ham? We really only deal with rumour and speculation. Diangana was Dowling's choice and Slav signed a similar sided player in Grant? We take that as true on here although we don't know for sure. One thing I've said numerous times before is that whoever went into this season without a recognised no.9 should be held to account. The one and a half games Diagne has played have given us a totally different dimension. Whether Big Sam is or isn't the right man, he certainly got his players in and Dowling is the one that got them over the line.
I think Dowling's future is absolutely up in the air. Takeovers, new manager, relegation etc. assuming we appoint a younger manager then his knowhow will be useful.
Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
Dowling wanted a defensive midfielder and the full backs changed, also wanted to buy other strikers rather than Grant who he felt was unsuited and too expensive.
Bilic had way too much say in the summer, and look where it got us. Dowling maybe messed up buying Grady, but that may yet come good.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(02-08-2021, 03:02 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Dowling wanted a defensive midfielder and the full backs changed, also wanted to buy other strikers rather than Grant who he felt was unsuited and too expensive.
Bilic had way too much say in the summer, and look where it got us. Dowling maybe messed up buying Grady, but that may yet come good.
The biggest transfer blot on Dowling's copy book is Zohore. He was very much a punt that Slav didn't seem keen on, so to commit £4m+ to him was very short-sighted. The only positive is the deal was structured in such a manner that it didn't hurt us too much.
Austin was a poor signing, but both he and Slav take the blame here. Slav was given other options, but he'd had a hard-on for Austin since his time at WHU and was very positive on bringing him in.
The other signings in the main represented excellent value for money, and we've managed to bring in numerous signings that required beating off other clubs' interest. Peltier and Grosicki were cheap, short term signings to get promotion secured. Slav decided to keep Peltier on, and we would have made our money back and more on Grosicki if he'd been willing to move to Greece, or the FA had granted Forest another 30mins!
Dowling has generally got more right than wrong... we've completely rebuilt the youth system again, tied down positive kids... we delivered promotion and got Slav in when had Jenkins had his way we'd have Alex Neil at the helm now, and was only a crooked ref away from seeing Shan take us up a year previous when Moore+Jones were dragging us out of playoff contention.
This season, he acted quickly to dispense with Slav - let's face it, his head had already been turned by China... he's managed in Saudi and Russia already, he's no stranger to easy money - in Big Sam he's brought in potentially the strongest candidate for the situation we were in - unfortunately not even Sam can turn this shit-show round, and the money just wasn't there to get players in early enough. Had we got AMN, Yokuslu and Diagne in 4 weeks ago, we may well be in a very different place now!
Dowling gets this summer - as we can't keep chopping and changing infrastruture non-stop.
Posts: 830
Threads: 1
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
Diangana and Pereira basically carried us to promotion and they were both Bilic contacts.
Posts: 489
Threads: 24
Joined: Nov 2019
Reputation:
0
Bilic wouldn't know a striker if one smacked him on his arse
|