New depths.
#11
Good post birdman but for me your very hard on Allardyce, not had hardly anytime on training ground took over a very unmotivated group of players.I will wait until he’s had chance to bring in and coach his own players. I think Snodgrass is a great start, he’s a great professional there will be a few ins and outs before January is out.
Reply
#12
(01-10-2021, 02:53 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Well this season seems to be a mission in what new depths of disappointment and misery can we plumb.

Honestly, whatever happens, we're going down. I can't see this squad being competitive enough without a good 5 or 6 players on top of Snodgrass, and they have to be integrated, and firing from day one, it isn't going to happen.

I'm extremely disappointed in Sam Alladyce. I expected a Hodgson style transition, as he changed our style of play to be more defense focussed and shape orientated. These are pro footballers, they shouldn't need lots of coaching to know how to hold shape and defend. These are basics taught in academy level football. Against Arsenal could have played 5-4-1 all deep, with the sole aim of keeping a clean sheet, I'd have been tempted to do the same last night, just to get it into these players to do it. Clean Sheets boost confidence more than scoring goals, that's always been the case, when you are sure you can keep a clean sheet, you know just getting one or two goals wins you the game. At the moment, we can't create and we know we'll concede up to 5. 

I was all for calling out Livermore for his idiocy against Villa, as Captain he was a massive let down, however all Sam has done is bitch and moan, that's not what a supposedly excellent coach, as his reputation suggests should be doing, work with what you've got. Instead he has just dismissed them and basically wants to build a completely new team, well you can't. Deal with it.

Yes our squad is weak, however weaker teams have done better and even survived, it has been poorly coached and managed since Lockdown, and Sam hasn't improved this in the slightest it seems, if anything he's doing worse.

As for the appointment of Sam, well I don't think that's Dowling to be honest, I think it was a decision made above him. He is very much into buy young, develop and sell for profit. He was expecting relegation this season anyway due to the impact Covid had on our budget, so I am far from convinced recent events are down to him. Yes he has made mistakes, Grady being a big one, that MAY pay off in time, but right now, was certainly a big problem. However I'm not completely against him, I get what he tried to do, he felt there was better value than Grant elsewhere, and wanted a defensive midfielder over Krov, Bilic was adamant on both of them. 

For now, well Sam isn't going to get the money he wants and the players he wants imo, so don't expect too much more, nothing that will cause much impact past next season. Summer we rebuild again. I've stated my preference is for Appleton, and I've given my reasons plenty, and it seems a very good fit in the circumstances.

I've written off this season, just worried it's effect on the club going down so, so painfully.

Good post. I agree with what you said about BFS, I know his playing style won't suit a lot of people but the fact is he's been relatively successful with it in previous jobs and you'd hope to see some of that here in terms of organisation at least. I too don't like the complete dismissal of the current squad, you can think that we need 11 new players in private if you want but just writing off the current bunch doesn't do much to boost morale and even with a great window (unlikely) you're going to need to rely on several of them for the rest of the season. 

Still needs till the end of Jan though before I fully write the season off.
Reply
#13
(01-10-2021, 03:39 PM)TartanRug Wrote:
(01-10-2021, 02:53 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Well this season seems to be a mission in what new depths of disappointment and misery can we plumb.

Honestly, whatever happens, we're going down. I can't see this squad being competitive enough without a good 5 or 6 players on top of Snodgrass, and they have to be integrated, and firing from day one, it isn't going to happen.

I'm extremely disappointed in Sam Alladyce. I expected a Hodgson style transition, as he changed our style of play to be more defense focussed and shape orientated. These are pro footballers, they shouldn't need lots of coaching to know how to hold shape and defend. These are basics taught in academy level football. Against Arsenal could have played 5-4-1 all deep, with the sole aim of keeping a clean sheet, I'd have been tempted to do the same last night, just to get it into these players to do it. Clean Sheets boost confidence more than scoring goals, that's always been the case, when you are sure you can keep a clean sheet, you know just getting one or two goals wins you the game. At the moment, we can't create and we know we'll concede up to 5. 

I was all for calling out Livermore for his idiocy against Villa, as Captain he was a massive let down, however all Sam has done is bitch and moan, that's not what a supposedly excellent coach, as his reputation suggests should be doing, work with what you've got. Instead he has just dismissed them and basically wants to build a completely new team, well you can't. Deal with it.

Yes our squad is weak, however weaker teams have done better and even survived, it has been poorly coached and managed since Lockdown, and Sam hasn't improved this in the slightest it seems, if anything he's doing worse.

As for the appointment of Sam, well I don't think that's Dowling to be honest, I think it was a decision made above him. He is very much into buy young, develop and sell for profit. He was expecting relegation this season anyway due to the impact Covid had on our budget, so I am far from convinced recent events are down to him. Yes he has made mistakes, Grady being a big one, that MAY pay off in time, but right now, was certainly a big problem. However I'm not completely against him, I get what he tried to do, he felt there was better value than Grant elsewhere, and wanted a defensive midfielder over Krov, Bilic was adamant on both of them. 

For now, well Sam isn't going to get the money he wants and the players he wants imo, so don't expect too much more, nothing that will cause much impact past next season. Summer we rebuild again. I've stated my preference is for Appleton, and I've given my reasons plenty, and it seems a very good fit in the circumstances.

I've written off this season, just worried it's effect on the club going down so, so painfully.

Good post. I agree with what you said about BFS, I know his playing style won't suit a lot of people but the fact is he's been relatively successful with it in previous jobs and you'd hope to see some of that here in terms of organisation at least. I too don't like the complete dismissal of the current squad, you can think that we need 11 new players in private if you want but just writing off the current bunch doesn't do much to boost morale and even with a great window (unlikely) you're going to need to rely on several of them for the rest of the season. 

Still needs till the end of Jan though before I fully write the season off.

Apart from Poo, I've seen nothing at the moment that gives me any confidence whatsoever that he can turn it round. 

Has anyone ever seen sam and Charlie Caroli in the same room?
Reply
#14
(01-10-2021, 02:53 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Well this season seems to be a mission in what new depths of disappointment and misery can we plumb.

Honestly, whatever happens, we're going down. I can't see this squad being competitive enough without a good 5 or 6 players on top of Snodgrass, and they have to be integrated, and firing from day one, it isn't going to happen.

I'm extremely disappointed in Sam Alladyce. I expected a Hodgson style transition, as he changed our style of play to be more defense focussed and shape orientated. These are pro footballers, they shouldn't need lots of coaching to know how to hold shape and defend. These are basics taught in academy level football. Against Arsenal could have played 5-4-1 all deep, with the sole aim of keeping a clean sheet, I'd have been tempted to do the same last night, just to get it into these players to do it. Clean Sheets boost confidence more than scoring goals, that's always been the case, when you are sure you can keep a clean sheet, you know just getting one or two goals wins you the game. At the moment, we can't create and we know we'll concede up to 5. 

I was all for calling out Livermore for his idiocy against Villa, as Captain he was a massive let down, however all Sam has done is bitch and moan, that's not what a supposedly excellent coach, as his reputation suggests should be doing, work with what you've got. Instead he has just dismissed them and basically wants to build a completely new team, well you can't. Deal with it.

Yes our squad is weak, however weaker teams have done better and even survived, it has been poorly coached and managed since Lockdown, and Sam hasn't improved this in the slightest it seems, if anything he's doing worse.

As for the appointment of Sam, well I don't think that's Dowling to be honest, I think it was a decision made above him. He is very much into buy young, develop and sell for profit. He was expecting relegation this season anyway due to the impact Covid had on our budget, so I am far from convinced recent events are down to him. Yes he has made mistakes, Grady being a big one, that MAY pay off in time, but right now, was certainly a big problem. However I'm not completely against him, I get what he tried to do, he felt there was better value than Grant elsewhere, and wanted a defensive midfielder over Krov, Bilic was adamant on both of them. 

For now, well Sam isn't going to get the money he wants and the players he wants imo, so don't expect too much more, nothing that will cause much impact past next season. Summer we rebuild again. I've stated my preference is for Appleton, and I've given my reasons plenty, and it seems a very good fit in the circumstances.

I've written off this season, just worried it's effect on the club going down so, so painfully.

Great post Birdmon. Pretty much summed up my thoughts entirely.
Reply
#15
(01-10-2021, 02:53 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Well this season seems to be a mission in what new depths of disappointment and misery can we plumb.

Honestly, whatever happens, we're going down. I can't see this squad being competitive enough without a good 5 or 6 players on top of Snodgrass, and they have to be integrated, and firing from day one, it isn't going to happen.

I'm extremely disappointed in Sam Alladyce. I expected a Hodgson style transition, as he changed our style of play to be more defense focussed and shape orientated. These are pro footballers, they shouldn't need lots of coaching to know how to hold shape and defend. These are basics taught in academy level football. Against Arsenal could have played 5-4-1 all deep, with the sole aim of keeping a clean sheet, I'd have been tempted to do the same last night, just to get it into these players to do it. Clean Sheets boost confidence more than scoring goals, that's always been the case, when you are sure you can keep a clean sheet, you know just getting one or two goals wins you the game. At the moment, we can't create and we know we'll concede up to 5. 

I was all for calling out Livermore for his idiocy against Villa, as Captain he was a massive let down, however all Sam has done is bitch and moan, that's not what a supposedly excellent coach, as his reputation suggests should be doing, work with what you've got. Instead he has just dismissed them and basically wants to build a completely new team, well you can't. Deal with it.

Yes our squad is weak, however weaker teams have done better and even survived, it has been poorly coached and managed since Lockdown, and Sam hasn't improved this in the slightest it seems, if anything he's doing worse.

As for the appointment of Sam, well I don't think that's Dowling to be honest, I think it was a decision made above him. He is very much into buy young, develop and sell for profit. He was expecting relegation this season anyway due to the impact Covid had on our budget, so I am far from convinced recent events are down to him. Yes he has made mistakes, Grady being a big one, that MAY pay off in time, but right now, was certainly a big problem. However I'm not completely against him, I get what he tried to do, he felt there was better value than Grant elsewhere, and wanted a defensive midfielder over Krov, Bilic was adamant on both of them. 

For now, well Sam isn't going to get the money he wants and the players he wants imo, so don't expect too much more, nothing that will cause much impact past next season. Summer we rebuild again. I've stated my preference is for Appleton, and I've given my reasons plenty, and it seems a very good fit in the circumstances.

I've written off this season, just worried it's effect on the club going down so, so painfully.

Great post, pretty much sums up exactly where we are. And more importantly how most of us are feeling.
Reply
#16
(01-10-2021, 03:29 PM)Dumbo Wrote: I’m positive knowing if we go down, Big Sam will be gone.

But our fantastic owners remain...
Reply
#17
(01-10-2021, 02:53 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Well this season seems to be a mission in what new depths of disappointment and misery can we plumb.

Honestly, whatever happens, we're going down. I can't see this squad being competitive enough without a good 5 or 6 players on top of Snodgrass, and they have to be integrated, and firing from day one, it isn't going to happen.

I'm extremely disappointed in Sam Alladyce. I expected a Hodgson style transition, as he changed our style of play to be more defense focussed and shape orientated. These are pro footballers, they shouldn't need lots of coaching to know how to hold shape and defend. These are basics taught in academy level football. Against Arsenal could have played 5-4-1 all deep, with the sole aim of keeping a clean sheet, I'd have been tempted to do the same last night, just to get it into these players to do it. Clean Sheets boost confidence more than scoring goals, that's always been the case, when you are sure you can keep a clean sheet, you know just getting one or two goals wins you the game. At the moment, we can't create and we know we'll concede up to 5. 

I was all for calling out Livermore for his idiocy against Villa, as Captain he was a massive let down, however all Sam has done is bitch and moan, that's not what a supposedly excellent coach, as his reputation suggests should be doing, work with what you've got. Instead he has just dismissed them and basically wants to build a completely new team, well you can't. Deal with it.

Yes our squad is weak, however weaker teams have done better and even survived, it has been poorly coached and managed since Lockdown, and Sam hasn't improved this in the slightest it seems, if anything he's doing worse.

As for the appointment of Sam, well I don't think that's Dowling to be honest, I think it was a decision made above him. He is very much into buy young, develop and sell for profit. He was expecting relegation this season anyway due to the impact Covid had on our budget, so I am far from convinced recent events are down to him. Yes he has made mistakes, Grady being a big one, that MAY pay off in time, but right now, was certainly a big problem. However I'm not completely against him, I get what he tried to do, he felt there was better value than Grant elsewhere, and wanted a defensive midfielder over Krov, Bilic was adamant on both of them. 

For now, well Sam isn't going to get the money he wants and the players he wants imo, so don't expect too much more, nothing that will cause much impact past next season. Summer we rebuild again. I've stated my preference is for Appleton, and I've given my reasons plenty, and it seems a very good fit in the circumstances.

I've written off this season, just worried it's effect on the club going down so, so painfully.

As ever a well written post.

We can all blame Sam as much as we like but is Sam to blame?

Given his track record I think it was a solid appointment. A good appointment at the wrong club. The squad he has to work with is awful. The players, as people have said, don't want to know. Why? Perhaps they've been treated overly well? I see a number of 'star' players in there who ain't good enough and who'll probably not take well to being told so. Take Pereira. Average in that league and finding out the hard way. Diangana, same. So trying to get these players to chuck in a bit more effort, particularly off the ball, is paramount and it's not happening. Sam wants his own players and a blind man could see why. And has already stated he needs better forwards - Austin has finally gone, HRK not good enough ditto grant which leaves us with Robinson... Other end of the pitch as much as I like Johnstone he should go if we need the cash. Ivanovic - well, blame Slav for that one. Much needed experience but legs, knees and everything else voe.

A daft clichéd appointment which has worked before. It's worked at clubs who were willing to back him and their squads were better than ours to begin with. I'm no Sam fan to say the least but if you're going to get him in then back him or it won't work. Snodgrass is a good signing. But, again, as await the signings of our new forwards. Imperitive. We need goals.

Do remember the fact that we've got Sam in and not accepted our fate tells its own story. Absolutely desperate to stay up yet won't pay for it. You get what what's coming...
Reply
#18
I guess what we don’t know is who is calling the shots in appointing Big Sam, our owners or the potential new owners.

It really is going to be interesting to see how many we bring in and in the names speculated we seem to be on the write track. I’m disappointed as well with the way we have regressed under him and have little idea of any game plan.

If we have to tear it up and start again, I’d go with Paul Cook. He plays attractive football and seems to be able to organise a team.

Hopefully, we can only get better now, although I fear the worst against the Dingles.
Reply
#19
(01-10-2021, 08:33 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote:
(01-10-2021, 02:53 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Well this season seems to be a mission in what new depths of disappointment and misery can we plumb.

Honestly, whatever happens, we're going down. I can't see this squad being competitive enough without a good 5 or 6 players on top of Snodgrass, and they have to be integrated, and firing from day one, it isn't going to happen.

I'm extremely disappointed in Sam Alladyce. I expected a Hodgson style transition, as he changed our style of play to be more defense focussed and shape orientated. These are pro footballers, they shouldn't need lots of coaching to know how to hold shape and defend. These are basics taught in academy level football. Against Arsenal could have played 5-4-1 all deep, with the sole aim of keeping a clean sheet, I'd have been tempted to do the same last night, just to get it into these players to do it. Clean Sheets boost confidence more than scoring goals, that's always been the case, when you are sure you can keep a clean sheet, you know just getting one or two goals wins you the game. At the moment, we can't create and we know we'll concede up to 5. 

I was all for calling out Livermore for his idiocy against Villa, as Captain he was a massive let down, however all Sam has done is bitch and moan, that's not what a supposedly excellent coach, as his reputation suggests should be doing, work with what you've got. Instead he has just dismissed them and basically wants to build a completely new team, well you can't. Deal with it.

Yes our squad is weak, however weaker teams have done better and even survived, it has been poorly coached and managed since Lockdown, and Sam hasn't improved this in the slightest it seems, if anything he's doing worse.

As for the appointment of Sam, well I don't think that's Dowling to be honest, I think it was a decision made above him. He is very much into buy young, develop and sell for profit. He was expecting relegation this season anyway due to the impact Covid had on our budget, so I am far from convinced recent events are down to him. Yes he has made mistakes, Grady being a big one, that MAY pay off in time, but right now, was certainly a big problem. However I'm not completely against him, I get what he tried to do, he felt there was better value than Grant elsewhere, and wanted a defensive midfielder over Krov, Bilic was adamant on both of them. 

For now, well Sam isn't going to get the money he wants and the players he wants imo, so don't expect too much more, nothing that will cause much impact past next season. Summer we rebuild again. I've stated my preference is for Appleton, and I've given my reasons plenty, and it seems a very good fit in the circumstances.

I've written off this season, just worried it's effect on the club going down so, so painfully.

As ever a well written post.

We can all blame Sam as much as we like but is Sam to blame?

Given his track record I think it was a solid appointment. A good appointment at the wrong club. The squad he has to work with is awful. The players, as people have said, don't want to know. Why? Perhaps they've been treated overly well? I see a number of 'star' players in there who ain't good enough and who'll probably not take well to being told so. Take Pereira. Average in that league and finding out the hard way. Diangana, same. So trying to get these players to chuck in a bit more effort, particularly off the ball, is paramount and it's not happening. Sam wants his own players and a blind man could see why. And has already stated he needs better forwards - Austin has finally gone, HRK not good enough ditto grant which leaves us with Robinson... Other end of the pitch as much as I like Johnstone he should go if we need the cash. Ivanovic - well, blame Slav for that one. Much needed experience but legs, knees and everything else voe.

A daft clichéd appointment which has worked before. It's worked at clubs who were willing to back him and their squads were better than ours to begin with. I'm no Sam fan to say the least but if you're going to get him in then back him or it won't work. Snodgrass is a good signing. But, again, as await the signings of our new forwards. Imperitive. We need goals.

Do remember the fact that we've got Sam in and not accepted our fate tells its own story. Absolutely desperate to stay up yet won't pay for it. You get what what's coming...

Not sure I like how much time I’m spending agreeing with you lately Nick, but think this is very true.

Slav and Dowling got it wrong this summer if the plan was survival at all costs, or they were hung out to dry if the plan changed after the window shut. 

We could have spent our limited resources better in the short term, and Slav allowed the squad to end up very unbalanced, and whilst Sam has seemingly taken us backwards, he was not the right appointment for the squad we had available.

If we throw some money at expensive loans, 6-18 month deals it’s a gamble worth taking is Lai is serious about surviving, and Sam is the best chance of pulling that off... it just won’t be pretty.
Reply
#20
Money isn't the problem. You can get very good players on the cheap if you know where they are and do your homework on them. Leicester didn't get where they are by spending ridiculous sums of money and when we finished in the top half we didn't either. Our low budget isn't the reason we are in this mess, it's a lack of intelligence.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: