Posts: 13,261
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
(10-30-2020, 08:55 PM)Duffers Wrote: Drop Grady to the bench and give Robinson a run alongside Grant and Periera.
Livermore, Gallagher and Kroc as a midfield trio.
Agree
Posts: 8,118
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
10-31-2020, 12:08 AM
(This post was last modified: 10-31-2020, 12:20 AM by HawkingsHalfpint.)
He has a really tough choice to make with Livermore. I don't think anyone wants him dropped, but he's clearly one of the weaker links right now. Problem is, do we look too lightweight without him away from home (if that even matters anymore).
We suddenly began to play with much more fluidity when he came off. Other changes helped, but Livermore's immobility creates massive lethargy on the break, and his turnover in possession is so slow that we frequently lose half a yard when he's involved. For me, he just doesn't EVER switch play fast enough to be a top flight holding CM (Claudio Yacob, for instance, was far more useful in games vulnerability was an issue, and in spite of his clearly limited distribution compared to Mulumbu/Scharner/Brunt/Fletcher/Jonno... it wasn't a major handicap. Yet is Jake as useful as any of these players? No he isn't, and we struggled with all of these better players at times. Go figure!).
He looked like he'd had a rocket up his arse at HT on Monday. I think he'd been told he'd be hooked unless he stepped it up. I also thought it interesting Slav sent him for interview after being withdrawn, when again he looked a little tender and hurt. I want him to succeed but it isn't happening, and he needs time to reflect on that.
If he starts on Monday, we have to go in a goal up at HT. Or we have wasted another half being too respectful to another dogshit side.
Sick to shit of saying this, but games are so often won or lost in midfield. Slav doesn't seem to get this, and it's now a big worry. We have failed to reinforce there, we have not looked like controlling a game now since Winter, and it's totally unfair to expect a Scharner of Gallagher at this point in time.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(10-31-2020, 12:08 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: He has a really tough choice to make with Livermore. I don't think anyone wants him dropped, but he's clearly one of the weaker links right now. Problem is, do we look too lightweight without him away from home (if that even matters anymore).
We suddenly began to play with much more fluidity when he came off. Other changes helped, but Livermore's immobility creates massive lethargy on the break, and his turnover in possession is so slow that we frequently lose half a yard when he's involved. For me, he just doesn't EVER switch play fast enough to be a top flight holding CM (Claudio Yacob, for instance, was far more useful in games vulnerability was an issue, and in spite of his clearly limited distribution compared to Mulumbu/Scharner/Brunt/Fletcher/Jonno... it wasn't a major handicap. Yet is Jake as useful as any of these players? No he isn't, and we struggled with all of these better players at times. Go figure!).
He looked like he'd had a rocket up his arse at HT on Monday. I think he'd been told he'd be hooked unless he stepped it up. I also thought it interesting Slav sent him for interview after being withdrawn, when again he looked a little tender and hurt. I want him to succeed but it isn't happening, and he needs time to reflect on that.
If he starts on Monday, we have to go in a goal up at HT. Or we have wasted another half being too respectful to another dogshit side.
Sick to shit of saying this, but games are so often won or lost in midfield. Slav doesn't seem to get this, and it's now a big worry. We have failed to reinforce there, we have not looked like controlling a game now since Winter, and it's totally unfair to expect a Scharner of Gallagher at this point in time.
Really? Millwall away, Bristol away, Preston and Luton at home, Reading away, Derby at home...in none of them we controlled the game?
I know it's a popular narrative on here and elsewhere that we've been poor since Christmas, but it isn't true.
The rest of your post I agree with. I actually think with Jake he gets in his head a bit. He's clearly been mentally carrying the team since lockdown and he probably needs a break.
Posts: 8,118
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
10-31-2020, 12:33 AM
(This post was last modified: 10-31-2020, 12:36 AM by HawkingsHalfpint.)
(10-31-2020, 12:29 AM)Squid Wrote: (10-31-2020, 12:08 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: He has a really tough choice to make with Livermore. I don't think anyone wants him dropped, but he's clearly one of the weaker links right now. Problem is, do we look too lightweight without him away from home (if that even matters anymore).
We suddenly began to play with much more fluidity when he came off. Other changes helped, but Livermore's immobility creates massive lethargy on the break, and his turnover in possession is so slow that we frequently lose half a yard when he's involved. For me, he just doesn't EVER switch play fast enough to be a top flight holding CM (Claudio Yacob, for instance, was far more useful in games vulnerability was an issue, and in spite of his clearly limited distribution compared to Mulumbu/Scharner/Brunt/Fletcher/Jonno... it wasn't a major handicap. Yet is Jake as useful as any of these players? No he isn't, and we struggled with all of these better players at times. Go figure!).
He looked like he'd had a rocket up his arse at HT on Monday. I think he'd been told he'd be hooked unless he stepped it up. I also thought it interesting Slav sent him for interview after being withdrawn, when again he looked a little tender and hurt. I want him to succeed but it isn't happening, and he needs time to reflect on that.
If he starts on Monday, we have to go in a goal up at HT. Or we have wasted another half being too respectful to another dogshit side.
Sick to shit of saying this, but games are so often won or lost in midfield. Slav doesn't seem to get this, and it's now a big worry. We have failed to reinforce there, we have not looked like controlling a game now since Winter, and it's totally unfair to expect a Scharner of Gallagher at this point in time.
Really? Millwall away, Bristol away, Preston and Luton at home, Reading away, Derby at home...in none of them we controlled the game?
I know it's a popular narrative on here and elsewhere that we've been poor since Christmas, but it isn't true.
The rest of your post I agree with. I actually think with Jake he gets in his head a bit. He's clearly been mentally carrying the team since lockdown and he probably needs a break.
I can be as selective as I like with history if I want
But look at the opposition you cite. I don't see Preston, Milwall, Bristol, Luton, Derby or Reading on the fixture list.
Did we have a convincing end to the season? No. Has this one started any better? No.
Perhaps it would have been more accurate to say that we have not controlled a game against quality opposition since Winter. And it is very early in the season for the table to not be lying.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(10-31-2020, 12:33 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: (10-31-2020, 12:29 AM)Squid Wrote: (10-31-2020, 12:08 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: He has a really tough choice to make with Livermore. I don't think anyone wants him dropped, but he's clearly one of the weaker links right now. Problem is, do we look too lightweight without him away from home (if that even matters anymore).
We suddenly began to play with much more fluidity when he came off. Other changes helped, but Livermore's immobility creates massive lethargy on the break, and his turnover in possession is so slow that we frequently lose half a yard when he's involved. For me, he just doesn't EVER switch play fast enough to be a top flight holding CM (Claudio Yacob, for instance, was far more useful in games vulnerability was an issue, and in spite of his clearly limited distribution compared to Mulumbu/Scharner/Brunt/Fletcher/Jonno... it wasn't a major handicap. Yet is Jake as useful as any of these players? No he isn't, and we struggled with all of these better players at times. Go figure!).
He looked like he'd had a rocket up his arse at HT on Monday. I think he'd been told he'd be hooked unless he stepped it up. I also thought it interesting Slav sent him for interview after being withdrawn, when again he looked a little tender and hurt. I want him to succeed but it isn't happening, and he needs time to reflect on that.
If he starts on Monday, we have to go in a goal up at HT. Or we have wasted another half being too respectful to another dogshit side.
Sick to shit of saying this, but games are so often won or lost in midfield. Slav doesn't seem to get this, and it's now a big worry. We have failed to reinforce there, we have not looked like controlling a game now since Winter, and it's totally unfair to expect a Scharner of Gallagher at this point in time.
Really? Millwall away, Bristol away, Preston and Luton at home, Reading away, Derby at home...in none of them we controlled the game?
I know it's a popular narrative on here and elsewhere that we've been poor since Christmas, but it isn't true.
The rest of your post I agree with. I actually think with Jake he gets in his head a bit. He's clearly been mentally carrying the team since lockdown and he probably needs a break.
I can be as selective as I like with history if I want
But look at the opposition you cite. I don't see Preston, Milwall, Bristol, Luton, Derby or Reading on the fixture list.
Did we have a convincing end to the season? No. Has this one started any better? No.
Perhaps it would have been more accurate to say that we have not controlled a game against quality opposition since Winter. And it is very early in the season for the table to not be lying.
I just don't see the point in comparing last season to this season. Different league, different opposition, different jobs.
It's also clear to anyone with eyes that the fear of the financial armageddon not being promoted would bring got to the team a lot. It happens.
As for the start to this season, it's more about how we finish. Southampton were getting beaten 9-0 by Leicester this time last. The Vile were awful all season, but managed to scrap a few wins toward the end.
Posts: 1,459
Threads: 169
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
10-31-2020, 08:35 AM
(This post was last modified: 10-31-2020, 08:47 AM by B36baggie.)
(10-30-2020, 09:03 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote: (10-30-2020, 08:48 PM)Super_Slav Wrote: Johnstone;
Furlong, Ivanović, Ajayi, Gibbs;
Gallagher,
Krovinović, Pereria;
Robinson, Grant, Diangana,
Attack, Attack, Attack.
Yeah...
I have a really nasty feeling about this game.
Nasty feeling as in you feel we are going to win
Johnstone
Furlong
Ivanovic
Ajayi
Gibbs
Krov
Gallagher
Pereira
Phillips
Robinson
Grant
Button. Townsend. Bartley. Livermore. Sawyers. Edwards. Grady,
Would have had O’Shea in if fit as I don’t rate Furlong enough & for me is our weak link at the back. If O’Shea in the rest would have most likely been different.
Phillips in for his tracking back qualities. Antonee Robinson & Lookman strong down their left. Pereira & Furlong together would be a disaster waiting to happen.
Get on the front foot & ask them some questions but still respect the oppositions strengths.
Posts: 582
Threads: 16
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
Johnstone
Furlong—Ivanovic—Ajayi—Townsend
Gallagher—Livermore—Krovinovic
Pereira
Robinson—Grant
Subs: Button, Bartley, Gibbs, Sawyers, Edwards, Grosicki, Diangana
Grady to bench for kick up the arse, but feel tough on Robinson to be dropped in first instance so deserves a place. Need to get Pereira central as much as we can, so play him behind two strikers who will drift wide when needed.
COYB!
Posts: 9,321
Threads: 720
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(10-30-2020, 09:03 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote: (10-30-2020, 08:48 PM)Super_Slav Wrote: Johnstone;
Furlong, Ivanović, Ajayi, Gibbs;
Gallagher,
Krovinović, Pereria;
Robinson, Grant, Diangana,
Attack, Attack, Attack.
Yeah...
I have a really nasty feeling about this game.
Cheap shot as usual.
Posts: 10,530
Threads: 487
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
28
Johnstone
Furlong Ivanovic Ajai Townsend
Gallagher Livermore Krovi
Periera
Robinson Grant
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
HawkingsHalfpint Wrote:He has a really tough choice to make with Livermore. I don't think anyone wants him dropped, but he's clearly one of the weaker links right now. Problem is, do we look too lightweight without him away from home (if that even matters anymore).
We suddenly began to play with much more fluidity when he came off. Other changes helped, but Livermore's immobility creates massive lethargy on the break, and his turnover in possession is so slow that we frequently lose half a yard when he's involved. For me, he just doesn't EVER switch play fast enough to be a top flight holding CM (Claudio Yacob, for instance, was far more useful in games vulnerability was an issue, and in spite of his clearly limited distribution compared to Mulumbu/Scharner/Brunt/Fletcher/Jonno... it wasn't a major handicap. Yet is Jake as useful as any of these players? No he isn't, and we struggled with all of these better players at times. Go figure!).
He looked like he'd had a rocket up his arse at HT on Monday. I think he'd been told he'd be hooked unless he stepped it up. I also thought it interesting Slav sent him for interview after being withdrawn, when again he looked a little tender and hurt. I want him to succeed but it isn't happening, and he needs time to reflect on that.
If he starts on Monday, we have to go in a goal up at HT. Or we have wasted another half being too respectful to another dogshit side.
Sick to shit of saying this, but games are so often won or lost in midfield. Slav doesn't seem to get this, and it's now a big worry. We have failed to reinforce there, we have not looked like controlling a game now since Winter, and it's totally unfair to expect a Scharner of Gallagher at this point in time.
I don't entirely disagree but we are in danger of throwing out the baby with the bathwater here. Comparing Jake unfavourably with past players is not accurate. Fletcher was regularly criticized as slow, Mulumbu and Claudio for giving the ball away. No one criticized Scharner mind, he'd come round your house and get you. Livermore is the natural captain and a vital member of the squad but I don't disagree we looked better without him t'other night. He'll play his part but as someone previously said, he may need a rest now and again.
|