Schmeichel⁸
#11
(09-28-2020, 09:47 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 04:34 PM)strawman Wrote: Are you seriously comparing a shot that was smashed from 12 yards into the opposite side of the goal into the top corner with one that was hit from 30 yards at a saveable height and within 4 feet of Johnstone.

Which goal you referring to?

I'm one of his fiercest critics and will remain so until I see improvements in his game, though I guess that's as much to do with management and coaching as SJ's shortcomings but he had absolutely no chance with Mount's goal. 

For one thing there was a crowd of bodies in front of him and he saw it very late - it was just one of those. 

The 2nd goal again absolutely no chance but we had enough defenders to prevent it, Furlong just stood and watched and probably said "after you Sir" to Odoi. 

You could argue SJ was at fault for the third as I see no real reason why he couldn't have hung on to it but of course the current culture and his instincts are to palm everything away.  Fine as long as you either put it out for a corner or into a safe area - not tee it up perfectly for the centre-forward, however it did come at him quickly through a crowded goalmouth so it's unfair to be too harsh.

+1 to all that. I'm on record as not rating SJ but I don't blame him for any of the goals. Like you say the last one looks like he maybe could have done better but it came quickly.
Reply
#12
(09-28-2020, 09:47 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 04:34 PM)strawman Wrote: Are you seriously comparing a shot that was smashed from 12 yards into the opposite side of the goal into the top corner with one that was hit from 30 yards at a saveable height and within 4 feet of Johnstone.

Which goal you referring to?


I'm one of his fiercest critics and will remain so until I see improvements in his game, though I guess that's as much to do with management and coaching as SJ's shortcomings but he had absolutely no chance with Mount's goal. 

For one thing there was a crowd of bodies in front of him and he saw it very late - it was just one of those. 

The 2nd goal again absolutely no chance but we had enough defenders to prevent it, Furlong just stood and watched and probably said "after you Sir" to Odoi. 

You could argue SJ was at fault for the third as I see no real reason why he couldn't have hung on to it but of course the current culture and his instincts are to palm everything away.  Fine as long as you either put it out for a corner or into a safe area - not tee it up perfectly for the centre-forward, however it did come at him quickly through a crowded goalmouth so it's unfair to be too harsh.

The first goal - there is not a crowd of players in front of him there are 3 players spaced out about 16 yards away from him. He committed his weight because he seemed to assume that the shot was going to be to the far post, instead he was beaten at his near post because he couldn't get back.
No problem with the second or third goal, he was at a stretch to palm out the third goal and did well to get down to it. Though he could have done far better when he finally came and punched just before the goal.
Reply
#13
I liked the way he turned and admired the first one.

I've lost count the number of times he has ended up facing the net when the ball hit it.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: