An Outsider's View
#11
(09-20-2020, 11:27 AM)Begley Wrote: VFIP

Some of you know of me on here and yes I am a Villa fan but I am also a football fan. I like a bit of rivalry between local teams but I would also like to see WBA, Wolves, Villa and Blues are competing at the top end of the PL and yes I would like to see Villa on top. But I am not into the hatred between team's fans.

Any my view of yesterday.

Positives:
- Baggies can score goals (this could save you this season)
- Summer summer signings look very good
- A real goal scorer would be very happy with the supply
- Looked good for large periods of 1st half

Negatives
- Gibbs reaction can not be tolerated in the PL
- Even down to 10 men there is no excuse for the defending at set pieces (continue defending like this and it will be relegation)
- There looks to be a lack of belief from the players that they are actually PL players (some confidence boosting wins / draws are needed)
- New defenders are needed (is there budget)

Reality
- A very good season would be finishing 17th, this means you will lose more than you win or draw. You can't give in on the back of 2 losses to good quality teams
- It is s red card for the manager if he enters the pitch. Yes, very harsh yesterday but the rules are the rules. Rules are not ignored for bigger team. Look at ridiculous pen that Palace won and the ridiculous retaking of the pen against Man Utd
- The concept of accidental / deliberate has been removed from many ref decisions. The goal should not have been disallowed
- Biggest problem for Baggies is that they needed to spend a huge amount of money making loan players permanent which means budget was spent on maintaining a Championship team as opposed to building a PL team. IMO, owner must spend some cash to improve if u want a chance of staying up otherwise it is just preparing for the Championship next season.

The objective of the PL for a newly promoted team is to finish above 3 other teams. So losing week in week out to top half tables really doesn't matter too much, the season will be judged on how you compete with Fulham, Hammers, Sheffield Utd, Burnley and Leeds etc. I went through last season on Villa forums reading and interacting with fans that constantly moaned about the manager and the players. It really becomes tiresome. You all went through a few very difficult years of dreaming about returning to the PL, it may be worth actually enjoying it now that you have it Smile 

Anyway, good luck for the season!

Fair dos,  the 6 points off Villa should be handy  Wink

ps. Bilic didn't encroach on the pitch the away team dressing room was on the other side of the ground due to Covid.
Reply
#12
Wink 
Fair dos Begley. A balanced well composed post. For a few milliseconds there you had me wanting Villa to stay up Big Grin

Most of your fellow Seals are arrogant and have this deluded sense of entitlement which we Baggies find incomprehensible given Villa's recent history.

Come over to the dark side!
Reply
#13
I think we know a bit about PL survival battles too. I kept my head down yesterday but there are positive signs with the goals we scored and players yet to come in (signed and yet to sign). That said, if we leak goals against our proper rivals once the window shuts then obviously we're fucked. Statin' the bleedin' obvious, I know.
Reply
#14
(09-20-2020, 12:16 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: Written as though Villa are the reigning PL
Champions Big Grin

Not sure how u get that from what I have written. We achieved my hope last season of finishing above 3 other teams and it went down to the wire. It is written by someone with experience of last season which I think is similar to the season Baggies will have this season. We were promoted with too many loan players (Mings, Tuanzebe, El Ghazi and Tammy). Before we could even think about improving we had to try and buy the team that got promoted via the playoffs. We also had an old team and a number of first teamers left (Hutton, Whelan) That is a bloody nightmare and when u add more players and buying PL experience is nearly impossible. Villa is a very long way from breaking into the top half of the table let alone having aspirations of Europa football. I expect Villa to stay up this season and I think we will finish somewhere between 10th & 15th, any position that avoids a relegation dogfight will be a success imo. My expectation is not because Villa is a 'big team' or 'deserves to be in the PL' or any of the bull shyte. We are obviously spending big and the players we are buying look to me like they are improving on what we had. Improvement to me each season is all I ask for.

(09-20-2020, 12:47 PM)Mr vertical Wrote: I think we know a bit about PL survival battles too. I kept my head down yesterday but there are positive signs with the goals we scored and players yet to come in (signed and yet to sign). That said, if we leak goals against our proper rivals once the window shuts then obviously we're fucked. Statin' the bleedin' obvious, I know.

I think a big problem is leaking goals to set pieces and that is something you didn't have last season. The PL is unforgiving to basic errors in defense, I was really surprised how weak u guys have looked at the back. I am not a huge fan of SJ but he is not the worst but I do think in the PL a really good GK is required. Look at Blades, only 3 teams scored fewer goals and 2 of those were relegated and the other is managed by Bruce. Blades finished 9th because of Henderson in goal and I think they will be fighting relegation this season
Reply
#15
(09-20-2020, 12:15 PM)Begley Wrote:
(09-20-2020, 11:52 AM)baggiebloke Wrote: Simon Inglis brought out some excellent books on football stadia.

He's a Seal aswell.

Although I didn't think he could be.

Are you sure, Begley?

Yes, sure I am, I am sure like you the team you support is not something you sit down and think about to make a rational decision, its in the DNA for real fans and we just couldn't support any other team.

OK, fair dos.
Reply
#16
Is it just me that finds the opening post just a tiny bit patronising?
Reply
#17
(09-20-2020, 01:08 PM)ericlegrisly Wrote: Is it just me that finds the opening post just a tiny bit patronising?

Nope.

Particularly the last paragraph.
Reply
#18
(09-20-2020, 01:08 PM)ericlegrisly Wrote: Is it just me that finds the opening post just a tiny bit patronising?
Yes
Reply
#19
(09-20-2020, 01:13 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(09-20-2020, 01:08 PM)ericlegrisly Wrote: Is it just me that finds the opening post just a tiny bit patronising?
Yes

Apparently not the case, see above.
Reply
#20
(09-20-2020, 01:14 PM)ericlegrisly Wrote:
(09-20-2020, 01:13 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(09-20-2020, 01:08 PM)ericlegrisly Wrote: Is it just me that finds the opening post just a tiny bit patronising?
Yes

Apparently not the case, see above.
That's 2 of you then.
I withdraw my assessment.
But I think it's an excellent post.  Wink
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)