Hypothetical question... if Labour had handled the situation the same
#11
Can you expand on "mischief" and "taking advantage" giving examples of policies you think would've been enacted that you would disagree with? I'm interested to know as I think a Labour govt would've resulted in better outcomes for a greater number of people, both in terms of the crisis and more generally.
Reply
#12
(05-07-2020, 11:28 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: The London Economic ran a piece about what would've happened if Labour had won that I broadly agree with, wildly partisan though it may be.

Link

Wildly partisan?!

It reads like something from a pop fanpage. I'm embarrassed that a grown adult wrote that.

If Corbyn really, really cared for ordinary people, he wouldn't have made his party so massively unelectable.
Reply
#13
(05-07-2020, 01:59 PM)Squid Wrote:
(05-07-2020, 11:28 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: The London Economic ran a piece about what would've happened if Labour had won that I broadly agree with, wildly partisan though it may be.

Link

Wildly partisan?!

It reads like something from a pop fanpage. I'm embarrassed that a grown adult wrote that.  

If Corbyn really, really cared for ordinary people, he wouldn't have made his party so massively unelectable.

This. If he'd ever bothered to leave North London and visit the provinces, he would have realised the contempt the traditional Labour voting areas had for him. If he did actually know, then his pursuit of power was a vain, selfish act that failed those he purports to represent. Corbyn claims to be on the side of the working man, but I'm not sure he'd ever want to mix with one.

Re the OP, it's  purely hypothetical and hindsight will colour the answer. It is now clear the government haven't been exemplary in their handling of the virus. What I would say is that they do appear to have done a decent job in supporting the workforce.  I'm actually shocked (and pleasantly surprised) at the financial support  (although I haven't received it yet!). Hard to say whether Labour would have done any better, much of the damage had already been done by austerity measures.
Reply
#14
What do you think he did that made Labour unelectable? What should he have done differently?

Always interested when people say this sort of thing as I though the policies in the 2019 manifesto were much better than the Conservative one.
Reply
#15
(05-07-2020, 06:14 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: What do you think he did that made Labour unelectable? What should he have done differently?

Always interested when people say this sort of thing as I though the policies in the 2019 manifesto were much better than the Conservative one.

It wasn't anything so very much to do with the policies. He came with too much baggage. Corbyn had a terrible image with working class voters that remembered him photographed with people they see as enemies. The PLO, the IRA. Many in our areas have connections with the armed forces and wouldn't overlook this. Then his unfathomable stance on Brexit. A lifelong Brexiteer, yet Corbyn never convinced anyone exactly where he stood.  Then after the Salisbury poisonings, when the leaders of many countries publicly condemned  Russia, he came out with some rubbish about needing time to get to the bottom of it before accusing them (Russia), despite everyone in Europe knowing and castigating them.  Once again appearing unpatriotic.   I've never voted for anyone other than Labour but from the start he was unpopular with the electorate in the traditional Labour voting areas. He may well be the nicest guy in the world, but if the electorate didn't like him, he should have moved out of the way for someone that was electable. Not doing so is, as I said earlier,  a selfish and vain act that let down anyone he claimed to support.
Reply
#16
(05-07-2020, 11:03 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Labour wouldn't have handled the situation in the same way under Corbyn & McDonnell. The question isn't even hypothetical, it's ridiculous.

It's an interesting conjecture what they would have done but largely irrelevant. What we are seeing though is a Conservative government that via austerity and massive policy failure is systematically responsible for thousands of deaths. Yet the Daily Mail, Telegraph etc. focus on a scientists mistress and Meghan and Harry's baby.

Tory austerity, the decision not to lockdown earlier, what's going on in care homes and issues with PPE are all the fault of this horrific government.
Reply
#17
(05-07-2020, 11:00 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Do you think the DH would have been on here constantly moaning about them?

Edited for you
Reply
#18
(05-07-2020, 07:52 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote:
(05-07-2020, 11:00 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Do you think the DH would have been on here constantly moaning about them?

Edited for you

If they made the same mistakes yes.
Reply
#19
Corbyn would have sent all the ventilators and ppe to Palestine.
Reply
#20
(05-07-2020, 11:07 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(05-07-2020, 11:03 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Labour wouldn't have handled the situation in the same way under Corbyn & McDonnell. The question isn't even hypothetical, it's ridiculous.

How do you think things would have been different. And do you think things would have been worse and in what ways ?

But certainly if the only difference had been that it was a Labour Govt, then I think we can say with some certainty that the Conservative press would have a field day.

Corbyn and McDonnell couldn't even run their party, let alone the country, let alone in a crisis.

(05-07-2020, 11:25 AM)billybassett Wrote: Current govt has been a shambles. Didn't take it seriously, airports are still open with no quarantine, a testing strategy weeks behind, care home scandal, the NHS is now a charity and we are all happy about it (even though the Tories cut it to the bone), ppe scandal, highest death rate in Europe.

All in all what a complete bunch of incompetent murdering scum bags

Dear God. Where to begin?

1. Death figures are meaningless unless you consider them per capita
2. That gives a death *rate*
3. The UK hasn't got the highest death rate in Europe; Italy, Spain and France are all higher
4. We might not even have the highest number of deaths. France is only counting hospital deaths, recording in Spain and Italy is inconsistent
5. Contagion and population density go hand in hand. The UK has a high average number of inhabitants per square mile
7. 'Cut to the bone' - NHS funding has increased every year since 2010
8. It was taken seriously, the Government has been on about it since February. You can attack its strategy but to say it hasn't been taken seriously is risibly wrong
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)