Bournemouth game
(01-13-2025, 08:30 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-13-2025, 08:25 AM)KRO Wrote:
(01-12-2025, 12:16 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Yesterday's game reminds me how little I want usro be promoted this season.

Which makes me question what's the point of my support.

Really sad it has come to this, but I see little prospect of us bridging the gap in quality of where we are now and where we would need to be, to be competitive in the premier league.

When I watch us play I still want us to win, and get super nervous if we have a 1 goal lead with 15 mins to play. But I see each game as an individual event, rather than part of a collective with an end goal.

I like to think over a number of seasons we get stronger and stronger, until we have a squad that could be competitive at the higher level, then promotion would be great. But I'm not sure that's how football works these days, if it ever did.

But the idea of us playing in the Premier League next season brings me out in a cold sweat. Something to be endured not enjoyed. That ain't right.
Sorry to pick you up on this mate, but in a few years you might read this back in horror. The Championship without parachute money or savvy owner investment is vile. You’re at the start of that for the first time in over 20 odd years really but still winning enough games to keep most happy.
Without ProMotion it just gets harder and harder as you’re in a league with more teams receiving that parachute money or with the ability to invest more than you. Get promoted should be the aim and asap. Trust me on that

I wouldn’t bother, I’ve been saying this for years. When we start finishing lower and lower in the league due to the ludicrous fair play rules… I guarantee most of our fans will dislike the Championship just as much as the Prem.

We might not have to get to that stage if our owners are savvy enough to avoid it but the idea that bobbling around the Championship is in anyway fun for the long term is quite a niche position to take.

Yep. Been there. Done that.
Reply
(01-13-2025, 08:30 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-13-2025, 08:25 AM)KRO Wrote:
(01-12-2025, 12:16 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Yesterday's game reminds me how little I want usro be promoted this season.

Which makes me question what's the point of my support.

Really sad it has come to this, but I see little prospect of us bridging the gap in quality of where we are now and where we would need to be, to be competitive in the premier league.

When I watch us play I still want us to win, and get super nervous if we have a 1 goal lead with 15 mins to play. But I see each game as an individual event, rather than part of a collective with an end goal.

I like to think over a number of seasons we get stronger and stronger, until we have a squad that could be competitive at the higher level, then promotion would be great. But I'm not sure that's how football works these days, if it ever did.

But the idea of us playing in the Premier League next season brings me out in a cold sweat. Something to be endured not enjoyed. That ain't right.
Sorry to pick you up on this mate, but in a few years you might read this back in horror. The Championship without parachute money or savvy owner investment is vile. You’re at the start of that for the first time in over 20 odd years really but still winning enough games to keep most happy.
Without ProMotion it just gets harder and harder as you’re in a league with more teams receiving that parachute money or with the ability to invest more than you. Get promoted should be the aim and asap. Trust me on that

I wouldn’t bother, I’ve been saying this for years. When we start finishing lower and lower in the league due to the ludicrous fair play rules… I guarantee most of our fans will dislike the Championship just as much as the Prem.

We might not have to get to that stage if our owners are savvy enough to avoid it but the idea that bobbling around the Championship is in anyway fun for the long term is quite a niche position to take.

You are both probably correct.

Although, whilst when we were in the wilderness years, I enjoyed supporting us, despite the football, being on the whole rubbish. At least there was the potential of something better. 

Now I think we have experienced something better, but it came with a definite glass ceiling.

Nothing lasts forever, and maybe there will be a significant change in football, that will allow clubs like Albion and the Blues to challenge for top honours.

But for now the prospect of seeing us in the Premier League next season is not one I look forward to.
Reply
I get what you’re saying in a way, but Prem football and the ability to strengthen is better than the possibility of mid table Championship football with the guarantee of your best players leaving over the next few years to balance the books and replaced with inferior players
Reply
It's not the league we're in for me, or how much money we have, or how much we spend on players.

It's how we are approaching the challenges we have. If we go up, great. As long as the cash is invested in players 24 and younger, on decent contracts with proper flex downs and good release clauses for both club and player. Then regardless of our level of "success" he club is likely to be self sufficient, progressive and enjoyable to support.

The journey should be as interesting as the destination where ever possible.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
I too despair at the chasm between the very top clubs and all the rest but before we get too worried about glass ceilings, remember Brighton, Bournemouth and Brentford are all regulars in the top half of the Prem. Of course they have had financial help but that alone is no guarantee. What they have done with their money is establish a sustainable model with the aim of not being a cash drain. Many of us are tainted by Jeremy Peace's lack of ambition whereby we were always told how poor we were. How we were lucky to be at the same table as the big boys and were rightfully simply a mid table championship club. If we first become well run financially, and at the same time have a definitive plan for progress, there should be no reason for us not to be competitive at that level.
Reply
(01-13-2025, 10:30 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: I too despair at the chasm between the very top clubs and all the rest but before we get too worried about glass ceilings, remember Brighton, Bournemouth and Brentford are all regulars in the top half of the Prem. Of course they have had financial help but that alone is no guarantee. What they have done with their money is establish a sustainable model  with the aim of not being a cash drain. Many of us are tainted by Jeremy Peace's lack of ambition whereby we were always told how poor we were. How we were lucky to be at the same table as the big boys and were rightfully simply a mid table championship club.  If we first become well run financially, and at the same time have a definitive plan for progress, there should be no reason for us not to be competitive at that level.

Seems like the best plan would be to relocate to the south and drop the 'West' so our name begins with a 'B'!
Reply
(01-13-2025, 10:30 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: I too despair at the chasm between the very top clubs and all the rest but before we get too worried about glass ceilings, remember Brighton, Bournemouth and Brentford are all regulars in the top half of the Prem. Of course they have had financial help but that alone is no guarantee. What they have done with their money is establish a sustainable model  with the aim of not being a cash drain. Many of us are tainted by Jeremy Peace's lack of ambition whereby we were always told how poor we were. How we were lucky to be at the same table as the big boys and were rightfully simply a mid table championship club.  If we first become well run financially, and at the same time have a definitive plan for progress, there should be no reason for us not to be competitive at that level.

I'd love to agree but the years of clubs having success through sensible, sustainable ownership are gone. There was an article in The Athletic recently showing the level of external investment every club in the PL had had, and I think there wasn't a single club (including the promoted clubs this summer) that had received less than £100m of owner funding. Sure teams like Brighton and Brentford are now trying to operate more sustainably, but both have benefitted from owners paying for new grounds and subsidizing their rise through the divisions with interest free loans and equity conversion. Palace are probably the best run club currently, but they have received 2 huge cash injections from bringing in new investors since promotion and I think I'm right in saying despite 12 years in the PL, they've not had a single top half finish!

It will cost Patel and co. £100M to make us an established PL club, on top of any prize money that comes with promotion, and even that is not guaranteed. Look at Southampton, their owners have spend well over £100M in their 2 PL windows and they are currently rock bottom of the PL again.
Reply
(01-13-2025, 10:52 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(01-13-2025, 10:30 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: I too despair at the chasm between the very top clubs and all the rest but before we get too worried about glass ceilings, remember Brighton, Bournemouth and Brentford are all regulars in the top half of the Prem. Of course they have had financial help but that alone is no guarantee. What they have done with their money is establish a sustainable model  with the aim of not being a cash drain. Many of us are tainted by Jeremy Peace's lack of ambition whereby we were always told how poor we were. How we were lucky to be at the same table as the big boys and were rightfully simply a mid table championship club.  If we first become well run financially, and at the same time have a definitive plan for progress, there should be no reason for us not to be competitive at that level.

I'd love to agree but the years of clubs having success through sensible, sustainable ownership are gone. There was an article in The Athletic recently showing the level of external investment every club in the PL had had, and I think there wasn't a single club (including the promoted clubs this summer) that had received less than £100m of owner funding. Sure teams like Brighton and Brentford are now trying to operate more sustainably, but both have benefitted from owners paying for new grounds and subsidizing their rise through the divisions with interest free loans and equity conversion. Palace are probably the best run club currently, but they have received 2 huge cash injections from bringing in new investors since promotion and I think I'm right in saying despite 12 years in the PL, they've not had a single top half finish!

It will cost Patel and co. £100M to make us an established PL club, on top of any prize money that comes with promotion, and even that is not guaranteed. Look at Southampton, their owners have spend well over £100M in their 2 PL windows and they are currently rock bottom of the PL again.

^ this in spades, I'm realistic about getting to the premiership but as I've always said you have to aspire to finish as high in the league your in as possible, whatever happens this season I can guarantee villa will finish above us and we will finish above Blues.

What both Blues and Albion both have is history and a pretty loyal fan base, I'd take that anytime over the plastic Brighton fans turning up to a shit hole in the middle of nowhere to watch premier league football.
Reply
(01-13-2025, 08:52 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: It's not the league we're in for me, or how much money we have, or how much we spend on players.

It's how we are approaching the challenges we have. If we go up, great. As long as the cash is invested in players 24 and younger, on decent contracts with proper flex downs and good release clauses for both club and player. Then regardless of our level of "success" he club is likely to be self sufficient, progressive and enjoyable to support.

The journey should be as interesting as the destination where ever possible.

Well said !

We have to feel confident in how our club is operating and what it’s doing just as much as any success, as we aren’t likely to have much!
Reply
(01-13-2025, 08:52 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: It's not the league we're in for me, or how much money we have, or how much we spend on players.

It's how we are approaching the challenges we have. If we go up, great. As long as the cash is invested in players 24 and younger, on decent contracts with proper flex downs and good release clauses for both club and player. Then regardless of our level of "success" he club is likely to be self sufficient, progressive and enjoyable to support.

The journey should be as interesting as the destination where ever possible.

Great post.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)