Mason and Bracewell it is then….
(06-03-2025, 11:55 AM)MrBater Wrote: Trouble with 'data driven' is that in the real world it can mean fugg all...

Lots of countries took a data driven approach to COVID... Whereas some took a gut driven feeling and closed down super quickly.

Obviously they can't have used data on Mason's managerial performances as there's not really any. Maybe they used data on the fitness / improvement of Spurs players instead?
There's not really any metric for hiring a head coach outside of his winnings record / weighted by club level / extenuating circumstances...

So I can't see how he is a data driven appointment.
Agree. For me it's the least data driven appointment ever. Spurs have had a torrid season across the board, apart from Le DAF Trophie. Their performances have been shocking from front to back and their injury record is shite.

This feels very much like a gut feeling appointment based on the one to one interview process, where he's clearly aligned with the club's vision. If he delivers, it's a master stroke.
Reply
Have you seen the data?
Reply
(06-03-2025, 12:00 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(06-03-2025, 11:55 AM)MrBater Wrote: Trouble with 'data driven' is that in the real world it can mean fugg all...

Lots of countries took a data driven approach to COVID... Whereas some took a gut driven feeling and closed down super quickly.

Obviously they can't have used data on Mason's managerial performances as there's not really any. Maybe they used data on the fitness / improvement of Spurs players instead?
There's not really any metric for hiring a head coach outside of his winnings record / weighted by club level / extenuating circumstances...

So I can't see how he is a data driven appointment.
Agree. For me it's the least data driven appointment ever. Spurs have had a torrid season across the board, apart from Le DAF Trophie. Their performances have been shocking from front to back and their injury record is shite.

This feels very much like a gut feeling appointment based on the one to one interview process, where he's clearly aligned with the club's vision. If he delivers, it's a master stroke.

Yep, it's probably the biggest managerial gamble we've had in 40 years... Even though some of the old hands *should* have done better... Time will tell, and it doesn't excite me, but then again I'm not sure Wicky or something bloke coaching in USA would have excited me either.

He's a clean slate in every sense of things, which is kind of what we need, I guess?
Reply
Number of players that's have moved through spurs development program which he headed up for years that reached first team level in the top few divisions? The amount of money raised from the sales/loans of those young players?

I would imagine this is what they are looking at in terms of the the model we want to implement.

As always, "data" doesn't mean just the headline stuff, games won, trophies won, promotions etc. Much of those metrics are the result of a process not the process itself.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
(06-03-2025, 10:47 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(06-03-2025, 10:16 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(06-03-2025, 10:13 AM)Squid Wrote:
(06-03-2025, 08:04 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Managers come and go, no owner is is going to listen to random posters on a messageboard with regards to whether a manager should stay or go. I’m always a bit baffled as to why fellow posters think we have so much influence, we don’t. Results within the expectations of the owner will see a manager stay or go 9 times out of 10. There are exceptions like Alan Irvine but again despite the negativity it was results, the fear of losing Prem status and the subsequent potential loss of the sale of the club that got him the sack.

Given I go to home matches, watch the game, clap the decent bits, get mildly miffed at the refs poor decisions on occasion and then tut and perhaps moan a bit at half time to fellow fans if we are playing poorly, I’m not sure either my 25% or 110% support makes a jot of difference to whether Mason, or any other managers tenure makes any difference.

It will be interesting to see how things go, he’s been given a three year contract so I expect the owners don’t want to be making any managerial changes for this year or next at least. Within this ‘data-driven’ approach it becomes increasingly difficult to say whether it’s the manager, coaches, or data analysts that are ultimately responsible for results, this creates its own problems of accountability so whether Mason is a success or not, depends so much more on Nestor and the wider football department than just him.

Maybe fans on a message board don't have much power, but fans in the stadium do.

The noticeable drop in attendances under Ismael hastened his exit.

When fans turned on Bruce, Luton at home, that was his last match.

Finally, the mass exodus following the third Derby goal was the death knell for Mowbray's second spell.

Absolutely. Patel was present at Cov and Derby. The crowd unrest would have been clearly noted. Of course it has an effect.

The examples of Mowbray, Bruce and Val are simply down to managers results and performances, they had a direct effect on the fans either being disgruntled, bored or baffled. If it were just down to fans reactions Pulis would never have been appointed. Positive results will always no matter what the performances are mean a manager will keep his job, failure to get results will see them lose their job, how quickly that happens maybe be hastened by fans reactions. Lose playing pretty football gives you perhaps a couple more months leeway with some fans but it’ll always be results set against the owners expectations that will determine the managers tenure. 

When Megson got us up, the club made it clear that the Prem was a free hit in our first season, this gave him leeway with fans that this wasn’t a short term plan. Maybe the club now should give similar parameters with regards to how we are judging success. 

Also can those criticising others for using the term ‘data driven’ accept the club are the ones that are putting this message out their to fans not the other way round.
Pretty sure we won fans of the year as well, which proves we are not a bunch of thick cavemen, high on coke, who've never played the game!  Big Grin

I doubt, however that Mason will get this level of leaway, but I agree our expectations have to be tempered given our financial restriction. Not many expected play offs at the start of last season, but the good start blew that out of the water and we ended up disappointed. With the 3 coming down, and 2 of those coming up, having a financial advantage, everyone else could be playing for 6th and I would be surprised if we are the best of the rest. Same as last year, I will be happy if we consolidate, continue to bring in younger players and look like we have a long term plan. At this moment in time my prediction would be somewhere between 6th and 13th.

(06-03-2025, 12:02 PM)MGalea Wrote: Have you seen the data?

No. That's why I said "for me". It's an opinion, not a statement of fact.
Reply
(06-03-2025, 12:04 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Number of players that's have moved through spurs development program which he headed up for years that reached first team level in the top few divisions? The amount of money raised from the sales/loans of those young players?

I would imagine this is what they are looking at in terms of the the model we want to implement.

As always, "data" doesn't mean just the headline stuff, games won, trophies won, promotions etc. Much of those metrics are the result of a process not the process itself.

Excellent point Lurker.

Progression on the pitch to a point where we can become a stable PL side again is obviously the number one aim for Nestor and Patel, however it’s unlikely that will happen based on one managerial appointment. We need to build a club infrastructure and model that allows us to improve year on year, and under our financial constraints better using our youth players, being smarter in recruitment and improving players for profit are fundamental steps in giving us a platform to progress. To be competitive in this league we need to find £15-20m a year from somewhere other than ticket sales and media, so in the short to medium term if makes sense we’ve made an appointment based on that need.

I hope Mason can also contribute winning games too, but I can understand why we’ve gone with this appointment.
Reply
(06-03-2025, 11:49 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(06-03-2025, 10:47 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(06-03-2025, 10:16 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(06-03-2025, 10:13 AM)Squid Wrote:
(06-03-2025, 08:04 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Managers come and go, no owner is is going to listen to random posters on a messageboard with regards to whether a manager should stay or go. I’m always a bit baffled as to why fellow posters think we have so much influence, we don’t. Results within the expectations of the owner will see a manager stay or go 9 times out of 10. There are exceptions like Alan Irvine but again despite the negativity it was results, the fear of losing Prem status and the subsequent potential loss of the sale of the club that got him the sack.

Given I go to home matches, watch the game, clap the decent bits, get mildly miffed at the refs poor decisions on occasion and then tut and perhaps moan a bit at half time to fellow fans if we are playing poorly, I’m not sure either my 25% or 110% support makes a jot of difference to whether Mason, or any other managers tenure makes any difference.

It will be interesting to see how things go, he’s been given a three year contract so I expect the owners don’t want to be making any managerial changes for this year or next at least. Within this ‘data-driven’ approach it becomes increasingly difficult to say whether it’s the manager, coaches, or data analysts that are ultimately responsible for results, this creates its own problems of accountability so whether Mason is a success or not, depends so much more on Nestor and the wider football department than just him.

Maybe fans on a message board don't have much power, but fans in the stadium do.

The noticeable drop in attendances under Ismael hastened his exit.

When fans turned on Bruce, Luton at home, that was his last match.

Finally, the mass exodus following the third Derby goal was the death knell for Mowbray's second spell.

Absolutely. Patel was present at Cov and Derby. The crowd unrest would have been clearly noted. Of course it has an effect.

The examples of Mowbray, Bruce and Val are simply down to managers results and performances, they had a direct effect on the fans either being disgruntled, bored or baffled. If it were just down to fans reactions Pulis would never have been appointed. Positive results will always no matter what the performances are mean a manager will keep his job, failure to get results will see them lose their job, how quickly that happens maybe be hastened by fans reactions. Lose playing pretty football gives you perhaps a couple more months leeway with some fans but it’ll always be results set against the owners expectations that will determine the managers tenure. 

When Megson got us up, the club made it clear that the Prem was a free hit in our first season, this gave him leeway with fans that this wasn’t a short term plan. Maybe the club now should give similar parameters with regards to how we are judging success. 

Also can those criticising others for using the term ‘data driven’ accept the club are the ones that are putting this message out their to fans not the other way round.

People don't have a clue what data driven means and what data is being used to drive things. That's my issue about people using data driven to bash the club with.

Some is just tongue in cheek, some is down to people not understanding what it means and in my opinion most is down to the club making it clear it’s one of it not their key approach to their decision making. The club were the ones who said it was a key factor in appointing Mowbray which was bizarre at the time. I’m fine with a data-driven approach but if it fails to yield results it’s no better than any other approach. I’m not sure why fans should be criticised for questioning what the data was when the answer was Mowbray!

Anyway onto the next one Smile
Reply
(06-03-2025, 12:04 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Number of players that's have moved through spurs development program which he headed up for years that reached first team level in the top few divisions? The amount of money raised from the sales/loans of those young players?

I would imagine this is what they are looking at in terms of the the model we want to implement.

As always, "data" doesn't mean just the headline stuff, games won, trophies won, promotions etc. Much of those metrics are the result of a process not the process itself.

Which would make sense when looking for a Nestor replacement.... As I say, it's a gamble, it's a clean slate, none of us really have a clue what he'll do.

The Mowbray 'data' was his previous, decent record...
Reply
without being cynical, is it possible that raising money through developing and selling players is more important to the owners at the moment? That seems the only data driven common thread between Mowbray and Mason. Add to that our new transfer policy of prioritising youth and it seems very clear. I don't begrudge that, it's probably necessary, but it is slightly disingenuous not to mention it. 

As well as Masons career of developing youth players, I guess if he only brings in one discarded youth player from Tottenham that can play at championship level, he's paid for his wages for the duration of his contract.
Reply
(06-03-2025, 01:36 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: without being cynical, is it possible that raising money through developing and selling players is more important to the owners at the moment? That seems the only data driven common thread between Mowbray and Mason. Add to that our new transfer policy of prioritising youth and it seems very clear. I don't begrudge that, it's probably necessary, but it is slightly disingenuous not to mention it. 

Developing and selling players is the only way a club of our size can ever hope to be both successful and sustainable (including in the top flight if we can get back there). On that basis, having it as a built-in part of our overall plan is being pragmatic.

I'm sure Shilen and his Dad didn't buy the club on the basis that they don't expect us to reach the Prem and so aren't bothered about getting promoted. I'm sure their goal is to get us into the Prem and keep us there. I think the plans they've been talking about are sensible steps to achieving that and fans shouldn't get so het up about use of the word "data".
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: