Ismael…
(05-04-2022, 07:24 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: And we didn't have players with the legs to apply the high press.

I think that's the issue, right there. Whether it was the legs or the mindset or a bit of both, I'm not sure. Although, the amount of stupid, late, red card tackles under Ish, makes me think it was legs...

It's impossible to say for definite what would have happened because the players simply didn't do it. Maybe we would have been found out, maybe we wouldn't. What's for certain - and a combination of Bruce and the U23 proved it for me - a lack of controlled aggression and work rate makes any tactic doomed to fail.

I don't believe Steve Bruce is a bad coach (okay maybe not good) but he has been made to look awful here. So assuming he's not a bad coach, surely it's the players and that can't all be down to the previous manager (or Belic and Allardyce)

Let's drop blaming the managers and start having a serious look at the scouting system. We've wasted a huge amount of money on expensive players that either didn't fit, are too inconsistent or were totally unnecessary. Some of them defied belief, we all knew they wouldn't work. Some like Grant, we should have expected the issues. What Albion fans are saying about him - positive and negative - is EXACTLY what Huddersfield fans were saying. We should only have bought him if we had a plan for him - a way to minimise his weaknesses, whilst playing to his strengths. We didn't bother. Instead, we had to rediscover everything Huddersfield knew the hard way. God knows what that did to his confidence.

Then we went the other way and bought next to nothing. Let's face it, even if Dyke had of been fit, he was hardly a top marque signing. Having to put all our eggs in that basket was always a sign of where we were going.

Is it possible that he was given a small budget and knew that Dyke would take the majority of it and so compromised everywhere else? Maybe he assumed the rest of the squad could/would run? It was a 'safe' gamble - after all he got his man - but then it went spectacularly wrong.

FWIW, The players brought in by Ismael weren't great but they were cheap and could run around. Unfortunately, if they are the only ones doing it, they look like headless chickens because nobody is backing them up when - for instance - pressing. Then you lose heart, slow up and finally get shown up for your lack of skill.

Getting rid of the manager is just like throwing meat to the lions while the real culprits get away.
Reply
(05-04-2022, 08:24 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I cannot believe this is still going on.

Same.

Pointless argument now.
Reply
(05-04-2022, 09:10 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(05-04-2022, 08:24 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I cannot believe this is still going on.

Same.

Pointless argument now.

Aren't most football forums just a means of catharsis, rather than having any actual point?!
Reply
(05-04-2022, 09:14 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(05-04-2022, 09:10 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(05-04-2022, 08:24 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I cannot believe this is still going on.

Same.

Pointless argument now.

Aren't most football forums just a means of catharsis, rather than having any actual point?!

Oh indeed.

I'm just not joining in this argument anymore. It's a hopeless one for both sides.
Reply
fuzzbox Wrote:
Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:And we didn't have players with the legs to apply the high press.

I think that's the issue, right there. Whether it was the legs or the mindset or a bit of both, I'm not sure. Although, the amount of stupid, late, red card tackles under Ish, makes me think it was legs...

It's impossible to say for definite what would have happened because the players simply didn't do it. Maybe we would have been found out, maybe we wouldn't. What's for certain - and a combination of Bruce and the U23 proved it for me - a lack of controlled aggression and work rate makes any tactic doomed to fail.

I don't believe Steve Bruce is a bad coach (okay maybe not good) but he has been made to look awful here. So assuming he's not a bad coach, surely it's the players and that can't all be down to the previous manager (or Belic and Allardyce)

Let's drop blaming the managers and start having a serious look at the scouting system. We've wasted a huge amount of money on expensive players that either didn't fit, are too inconsistent or were totally unnecessary. Some of them defied belief, we all knew they wouldn't work. Some like Grant, we should have expected the issues. What Albion fans are saying about him - positive and negative - is EXACTLY what Huddersfield fans were saying. We should only have bought him if we had a plan for him - a way to minimise his weaknesses, whilst playing to his strengths. We didn't bother. Instead, we had to rediscover everything Huddersfield knew the hard way. God knows what that did to his confidence.

Then we went the other way and bought next to nothing. Let's face it, even if Dyke had of been fit, he was hardly a top marque signing. Having to put all our eggs in that basket was always a sign of where we were going.

Is it possible that he was given a small budget and knew that Dyke would take the majority of it and so compromised everywhere else? Maybe he assumed the rest of the squad could/would run? It was a 'safe' gamble - after all he got his man - but then it went spectacularly wrong.

FWIW, The players brought in by Ismael weren't great but they were cheap and could run around. Unfortunately, if they are the only ones doing it, they look like headless chickens because nobody is backing them up when - for instance - pressing. Then you lose heart, slow up and finally get shown up for your lack of skill.

Getting rid of the manager is just like throwing meat to the lions while the real culprits get away.

Good post Fuzzbox. further to the Dike signing/not signing thing. This guy was the one the manager insisted on (as was widely reported). His club started to play hardball.  Albion wouldn't pay what was wanted, the agent obviously told them he would most likely then  become available in January for less. We waited (with Hugill as a stopgap). Maybe Val was complicit in this but ultimately it was typical Albion penny pinching which almost certainly condemned us to a spell in this league. The real issue for me is not how Ismael does in future, it is that he was a wildcard appointment that we did not back. Ironically, he would probably be perfect for the job this time next season.
Reply
It's a shame Val couldn't stick around with the U23's.
I think he desperately needs a young, energetic, enthusiastic squad for his plan to work and, if he'd had that here, we'd be up by now. It's going to be really difficult for him to get that at any decent level though as all teams have their settled old pro's who's legs (or heads) are on the way out, who just won't buy into it and that's the issue, Valball really does require an all for one attitude and that's a tough ask.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: