Two State Delusion
(10-03-2025, 12:22 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Didn't really know which of the three or four Israel - Palestine threads to post this in. I've been trying to figure out what my opinion is over the last 24hrs particularly. I'm sure I'll be told why I'm wrong.

I start this post the same way I did in the Charlie Kirk thread when I said I don't believe anyone should be harmed or killed for what they say or what they believe, however neither are they free from people using those same viewpoints against them

Maybe not the greatest of sources but throughout this morning I heard on Good Morning Britain (not ideal but it's what the masses watch) discussion with prominent members of the British Jewish community who are rightfully appalled at what happened in Manchester. They spoke in terms that they are not responsible for the actions of the Jewish Government, no more or less than we are responsible for the actions of Starmer or Johnson before them. To a man those I heard on TV and radio cited the attacks in the context of the October 7th attacks and the subsequent response of the Jewish Government. I think this is where I start to struggle connecting the dots. It's been done to death on here, but 7th October 2023 was no surprise to either side of the conflict in the Middle East (the area formerly known as the 'Armpit').

There seems a real disconnect between the two sides of the debate in this country, especially from people who are not members of the Jewish or Muslim faiths. There in some quarters seemed greater delight that the attackers name was 'Jihad' compared to the empathy and sympathy directed towards the victims, why?

I've seen people talking of the contribution Jewish immigrants have made to society, particularly how they integrate. Yet, they have their own dress, their own food rules, their own areas of towns and cities, their own shops and it parts of North London they even have their own ambulances. How does this really differ from the way in which many British Muslims live their life? But if you wave a Palestinian flag you're told to "clear off over there if you care so much" by people who are now falling over themselves posting Israeli flags. Again, why? Probably one for the 'Christian values' brigade to help me with.

Whenever there is a terrorist attack carried out by a Muslim, there is widespread condemnation of the whole race and religion - "why don't they do more to weed out the bad eggs" - Michael Vaughan former England cricket captain once suggested that even Moeen Ali could do more in his community to calm the threat of Islamic terrorism. Yet, not a single question directed towards a Jewish person regarding the actions of the Israeli Government across the last generation, let alone two years. There was no collective arm around the shoulder after the Finsbury Park Mosque attack, or whenever a pigs head is nailed to the front of a mosque.

I'm certainly not trying to argue one side over another, I just want someone to point out the inconsistency and to tell me why it's fine one way and not the other. Every argument I see you could replace the term 'Jew' with 'Muslim' on either side and it would still be 100% accurate. You either stand against all of this kind of behaviour, or none of it. My sympathies are with those affected by yesterdays attack in Manchester and also with those continuing to live through some of the worst things imaginable in Gaza.

Instead of that diatribe you could have just typed, but whatabout the Jews.

(10-03-2025, 12:26 PM)Squid Wrote:
(10-03-2025, 12:20 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(10-03-2025, 12:17 PM)Squid Wrote:
(10-03-2025, 12:12 PM)Jacko Wrote: But whatabout the West Bank...

Don't remember white South Africans being murdered on our streets.

Do you have an actual point you want to make, or is this just a general opportunity for you to express contempt for Palestinian lives?

Lucky none of these Palestinians are men trying to pass themselves off as women, you wouldn't be overly bothered then would you? How about the new Syrian regime you championed who indiscriminately kill Alawites and Druze? How's that for whataboutery?

No actual point then, so you are very oddly trying to make this into something personal.

Your outlook re the middle east is a skewed mess, so yes I'm making it personal because they are your views? Trans stuff was flippant, but I do wonder.
Reply
Excellent post TM
Raw Sausage
Reply
Just as an aside, is there any other way to see The Middle East other than a skewed mess?
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
(10-03-2025, 12:26 PM)Jacko Wrote: Instead of that diatribe you could have just typed, but whatabout the Jews.

I suppose that is absolutely the point, as a society sides have been picked and those with the structures of powers aligned behind them will always have the loudest voices.
Reply
(10-03-2025, 12:38 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(10-03-2025, 12:26 PM)Jacko Wrote: Instead of that diatribe you could have just typed, but whatabout the Jews.

I suppose that is absolutely the point, as a society sides have been picked and those with the structures of powers aligned behind them will always have the loudest voices.

You surely don't think the Jews have the loudest voices (apologies if I've misinterpreted your post)? They aren't out on the streets every weekend protesting Terrorist organisations (or cheering the government of their homeland). They have been sending their kids to school behind 20ft razor wire fences and armed guards for years though.
Reply
It depends what mechanism you think voices are projected most potently through. In your example, you may have a point. In many others, they have evidently far more potent mechanisms than other cultures or ethnic groups may. The experiences you describe as individuals are odd that you appear to have empathy with them but none for other groups subjugated in the same way or worse
Raw Sausage
Reply
(10-03-2025, 12:51 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: It depends what mechanism you think voices are projected most potently through. In your example, you may have a point. In many others, they have evidently far more potent mechanisms than other cultures or ethnic groups may. The experiences you describe as individuals are odd that you appear to have empathy with them but none for other groups subjugated in the same way or worse

And you call us nazis? FFS CF. The power behind the power (the hidden hand) is a classic antisemitic trope.

Outed at last.
Reply
Desperate stuff Jacko
Raw Sausage
Reply
(10-03-2025, 01:02 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Desperate stuff Jacko

Read what you posted. You're nowhere near as bright as you think mate.
Reply
(10-03-2025, 12:26 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(10-03-2025, 12:22 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Didn't really know which of the three or four Israel - Palestine threads to post this in. I've been trying to figure out what my opinion is over the last 24hrs particularly. I'm sure I'll be told why I'm wrong.

I start this post the same way I did in the Charlie Kirk thread when I said I don't believe anyone should be harmed or killed for what they say or what they believe, however neither are they free from people using those same viewpoints against them

Maybe not the greatest of sources but throughout this morning I heard on Good Morning Britain (not ideal but it's what the masses watch) discussion with prominent members of the British Jewish community who are rightfully appalled at what happened in Manchester. They spoke in terms that they are not responsible for the actions of the Jewish Government, no more or less than we are responsible for the actions of Starmer or Johnson before them. To a man those I heard on TV and radio cited the attacks in the context of the October 7th attacks and the subsequent response of the Jewish Government. I think this is where I start to struggle connecting the dots. It's been done to death on here, but 7th October 2023 was no surprise to either side of the conflict in the Middle East (the area formerly known as the 'Armpit').

There seems a real disconnect between the two sides of the debate in this country, especially from people who are not members of the Jewish or Muslim faiths. There in some quarters seemed greater delight that the attackers name was 'Jihad' compared to the empathy and sympathy directed towards the victims, why?

I've seen people talking of the contribution Jewish immigrants have made to society, particularly how they integrate. Yet, they have their own dress, their own food rules, their own areas of towns and cities, their own shops and it parts of North London they even have their own ambulances. How does this really differ from the way in which many British Muslims live their life? But if you wave a Palestinian flag you're told to "clear off over there if you care so much" by people who are now falling over themselves posting Israeli flags. Again, why? Probably one for the 'Christian values' brigade to help me with.

Whenever there is a terrorist attack carried out by a Muslim, there is widespread condemnation of the whole race and religion - "why don't they do more to weed out the bad eggs" - Michael Vaughan former England cricket captain once suggested that even Moeen Ali could do more in his community to calm the threat of Islamic terrorism. Yet, not a single question directed towards a Jewish person regarding the actions of the Israeli Government across the last generation, let alone two years. There was no collective arm around the shoulder after the Finsbury Park Mosque attack, or whenever a pigs head is nailed to the front of a mosque.

I'm certainly not trying to argue one side over another, I just want someone to point out the inconsistency and to tell me why it's fine one way and not the other. Every argument I see you could replace the term 'Jew' with 'Muslim' on either side and it would still be 100% accurate. You either stand against all of this kind of behaviour, or none of it. My sympathies are with those affected by yesterdays attack in Manchester and also with those continuing to live through some of the worst things imaginable in Gaza.

Instead of that diatribe you could have just typed, but whatabout the Jews.

(10-03-2025, 12:26 PM)Squid Wrote:
(10-03-2025, 12:20 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(10-03-2025, 12:17 PM)Squid Wrote:
(10-03-2025, 12:12 PM)Jacko Wrote: But whatabout the West Bank...

Don't remember white South Africans being murdered on our streets.

Do you have an actual point you want to make, or is this just a general opportunity for you to express contempt for Palestinian lives?

Lucky none of these Palestinians are men trying to pass themselves off as women, you wouldn't be overly bothered then would you? How about the new Syrian regime you championed who indiscriminately kill Alawites and Druze? How's that for whataboutery?

No actual point then, so you are very oddly trying to make this into something personal.

Your outlook re the middle east is a skewed mess, so yes I'm making it personal because they are your views? Trans stuff was flippant, but I do wonder.

What on earth does that mean?

I think Palestinians are entitled to statehood as part of a Two State Solution. That is a fairly widely held opinion. You may disagree with it, but describing it as "skewed" would be inaccurate.

I also think the fall of the Assad regime was a very good thing. Here are some stats on the crimes that regime was responsible for from the Syrian Network for Human Rights

https://snhr.org/blog/2024/12/20/summary...-14-years/

Most prominent violations documented

Extrajudicial Killings
SNHR documented the killing of at least 202,000 civilians at the hands of Bashar Assad’s regime forces, including 23,058 children and 12,010 women.

Enforced Disappearance
At least 96,321 cases of enforced disappearance at the hands of Bashar Assad’s regime forces are documented on SNHR’s database, among them 2,329 children and 5,742 women.

Deaths due to torture
At least 15,102 individuals died under torture at the hands of Bashar Assad’s regime forces, including 190 children and 95 women.

The actions of the Assad regime also caused a massive refugee crisis and turbocharged the refugee trafficking industry. So again, wanting a regime that did all that, gone, is hardly skewed. 

I'm not sure where I said I supported the killings of Alawites or Druze, either. So again, not sure where you are getting the "skewed" from. 

And yes, considering that people feared the country would fall into mass conflict and Balkanisation following the fall of the Assad regime, it is a good thing, that for most Syrians, that the country remains relatively stable and life is improving: 

https://northeastbylines.co.uk/news/worl...y-changed/

Over a million refugees have returned:

https://www.unhcr.org/news/press-release...s-more-can

In addition to the mass slaughter and imprisonment of Syrians, the Assad regime also turned the country into a Narcostate, which the new government has worked to dismantle:

https://levant24.com/news/2025/08/drug-s...stability/

This does not mean that the Syria government is a blameless entity that doesn't deserve criticism. But to state Syria 2025 is in a better place than Syria 2024 is not a view which is a "skewed mess"

So again, still not sure where the idea that my outlook re: the Middle East is a skewed mess has come from.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: